HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   UK digital tv (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Mumbling actors and loud musc (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=73353)

Derek F[_3_] July 19th 13 01:15 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn
Derek

Brian Gaff July 19th 13 09:43 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Its not just actors is it. On some recent Horizon episodes the music was so
loud I could not hear the carefully chosen sound bytes from scientists I'd
never heard of at all.
Brian

--
From the Sofa of Brian Gaff Reply address is active
"Derek F" wrote in message
...
Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn
Derek




Derek F[_3_] July 19th 13 10:21 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On 19/07/2013 08:43, Brian Gaff wrote:
Its not just actors is it. On some recent Horizon episodes the music was so
loud I could not hear the carefully chosen sound bytes from scientists I'd
never heard of at all.
Brian

Its not just a TV problem as most Movies are just as bad.
British stage actors used to have voices that carried without the need
of electronics. We went to see Dame Judy in a play and sitting in the
rear of the circle it was a struggle to hear her.
Derek

NY July 19th 13 10:37 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Derek F" wrote in message
...
On 19/07/2013 08:43, Brian Gaff wrote:
Its not just actors is it. On some recent Horizon episodes the music was
so
loud I could not hear the carefully chosen sound bytes from scientists
I'd
never heard of at all.
Brian

Its not just a TV problem as most Movies are just as bad.
British stage actors used to have voices that carried without the need of
electronics. We went to see Dame Judy in a play and sitting in the rear of
the circle it was a struggle to hear her.


I'd rather have actors and actresses speaking in normal (but audible,
intelligible) voices than have them straining to project their voices to the
back of a theatre without the aid of amplification. A projected voice never
sounds natural.


Jim Lesurf[_2_] July 19th 13 11:39 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article , Brian Gaff
wrote:
Its not just actors is it. On some recent Horizon episodes the music was
so loud I could not hear the carefully chosen sound bytes from
scientists I'd never heard of at all. Brian


In contrast, some of the recent 'Tony Robinson presented' items on C4 in
recent years have all the voiceovers dynamically auto-level compressed to
the max, so seem like 'shouting' all the time he does them. As with the
above example, I have to assume no-one producing them ever bothers to
listen to the result.

Slainte,

Jim

--
Please use the address on the audiomisc page if you wish to email me.
Electronics http://www.st-and.ac.uk/~www_pa/Scot...o/electron.htm
Armstrong Audio http://www.audiomisc.co.uk/Armstrong/armstrong.html
Audio Misc http://www.audiomisc.co.uk/index.html


Dave Plowman (News) July 19th 13 11:40 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
NY wrote:
I'd rather have actors and actresses speaking in normal (but audible,
intelligible) voices than have them straining to project their voices to
the back of a theatre without the aid of amplification. A projected
voice never sounds natural.


You want things in a theatre to be natural? ;-)

--
*Money isn't everything, but it sure keeps the kids in touch *

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Dave Plowman (News) July 19th 13 11:46 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Two different things. You can drown out any voice with too loud music and
or effects. Mumbling can be difficult to understand on its own.

It's definitely not helped by pretty well all TV drama these days using
personal mics buried beneath layers of ordinary clothing. Nothing much you
can do about poorly recorded sound. And than add in the poor sound systems
on most tellies.

--
*If God had wanted me to touch my toes, he would have put them on my knees

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Steve Thackery[_2_] July 19th 13 12:45 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Dave Plowman (News) wrote:

You want things in a theatre to be natural? ;-)


I agree with that point. Whenever I go to the theatre I am struck by
how unnatural all the acting is. In my experience they *always*
project their voices, and they always make larger-than-life movements.
It has to be that way - you would never normally observe or interact
with people a hundred feet or more away.

That's why I dislike the theat the actors don't act, they perform.
Television and film are far more intimate. Sophie Grabol (The Killing)
does such subtle, and superb, face acting that the only way to see it
is when her face fills the whole screen. Michael Kitchen (Foyle's War)
is another masterful TV actor in much the same way. I love that kind
of acting. I haven't seen Grabol or Kitchen in a theatre, but I'm sure
both must "enlarge" their acting into full-blown performances.
Inevitably this makes it less natural.

--
SteveT

Dave Plowman (News) July 19th 13 04:04 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
Steve Thackery wrote:
Dave Plowman (News) wrote:


You want things in a theatre to be natural? ;-)


I agree with that point. Whenever I go to the theatre I am struck by
how unnatural all the acting is. In my experience they *always*
project their voices, and they always make larger-than-life movements.
It has to be that way - you would never normally observe or interact
with people a hundred feet or more away.


Quite. It's how it has always been.

That's why I dislike the theat the actors don't act, they perform.
Television and film are far more intimate.


I can enjoy both sorts.

Sophie Grabol (The Killing)
does such subtle, and superb, face acting that the only way to see it
is when her face fills the whole screen. Michael Kitchen (Foyle's War)
is another masterful TV actor in much the same way. I love that kind
of acting. I haven't seen Grabol or Kitchen in a theatre, but I'm sure
both must "enlarge" their acting into full-blown performances.
Inevitably this makes it less natural.


Remember going to see French and Saunders in a play wot they wrote. They
both mumbled to the point none of our (youngish) group could hear much of
what they said. So most of us simply slept through it, and demanded our
money back afterwards. Got it too.

--
*Isn't it a bit unnerving that doctors call what they do "practice?"

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

the dog from that film you saw[_3_] July 19th 13 06:50 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On 19/07/2013 08:43, Brian Gaff wrote:
Its not just actors is it. On some recent Horizon episodes the music was so
loud I could not hear the carefully chosen sound bytes from scientists I'd
never heard of at all.
Brian




maybe you have (a) not very good speakers in your tv
or
(b) not very good ears.

just a thought :)

--
Gareth.
That fly.... Is your magic wand.

Woody[_4_] July 19th 13 08:09 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"the dog from that film you saw"
wrote in message ...
On 19/07/2013 08:43, Brian Gaff wrote:
Its not just actors is it. On some recent Horizon episodes the
music was so
loud I could not hear the carefully chosen sound bytes from
scientists I'd
never heard of at all.
Brian




maybe you have (a) not very good speakers in your tv
or
(b) not very good ears.

just a thought :)



There's no doubt that speakers make a huge difference.

We changed out caravan late last year and the new one is fitted
with a JVC car radio that has a 3.5mm input socket on the front.
I built a simple preamp, ran cables around inside the cupboards
and left a tail to plug into the headphone socket of our Sharp
19" TV. The difference in quality and audibility was amazing -
plus there was/is no need to have it anything like so loud - and
the sound on the Sharp is pretty good anyway!

What was noticable was/is that the dynamic range is much less
than expected and there is no need to keep adjusting the volume
levels.

Thinking about a simple similar solution for our bedroom TV now!


--
Woody

harrogate three at ntlworld dot com



Bill Wright[_2_] July 19th 13 08:33 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Woody wrote:

We changed out caravan late last year and the new one is fitted
with a JVC car radio that has a 3.5mm input socket on the front.
I built a simple preamp, ran cables around inside the cupboards
and left a tail to plug into the headphone socket of our Sharp
19" TV.


I'm surprised you need a preamp. The 'aux in' on my motorhome radio
works fine straight from the telly.

Bill

Dave Plowman (News) July 19th 13 08:41 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
Woody wrote:
maybe you have (a) not very good speakers in your tv
or
(b) not very good ears.

just a thought :)



There's no doubt that speakers make a huge difference.


As does how the voices are recorded - as I keep on saying. When last did
you have problem understanding voices on R4? Even when they are the same
actors you have problems with on TV.

FFS, even newsreaders on BBC TV - wearing an exposed personal mic - often
sound like they're speaking through layers of cloth. A combination of
(possibly) microphones which are out of spec and a sound mixer who either
doesn't know how to eq a mic properly, or doesn't care. That's assuming
there actually is still some human involvement.

--
*I don't work here. I'm a consultant

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Woody[_4_] July 19th 13 09:38 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Bill Wright" wrote in message
...
Woody wrote:

We changed out caravan late last year and the new one is
fitted with a JVC car radio that has a 3.5mm input socket on
the front. I built a simple preamp, ran cables around inside
the cupboards and left a tail to plug into the headphone
socket of our Sharp 19" TV.


I'm surprised you need a preamp. The 'aux in' on my motorhome
radio works fine straight from the telly.

Bill




The TV switches to headphone mode with a considerably reduced
output as soon as a plug is inserted. It surprised me as well -
given the amp needed 30dB of gain!


--
Woody

harrogate three at ntlworld dot com



NY July 19th 13 10:04 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Dave Plowman (News)" wrote in message
...
As does how the voices are recorded - as I keep on saying. When last did
you have problem understanding voices on R4? Even when they are the same
actors you have problems with on TV.


Close-miked radio presenters are fine. But Radio 4 are very bad at matching
the level of studio voices with those outside contributors, especially those
using inferior lines such as landline or mobile telephones, although even
high-quality live reports are often much louder or quieter than the studio.
BBC TV news doesn't seem to suffer from that problem, although I agree that
the quality of the newsreaders' personal mikes can sometimes be a bit
woolly.

One thing that R4 suffers badly from is excruciatingly annoying sibilant S
sounds, especially on female voices. Maybe for TV newsreaders, the mikes
have a poorer HF response so the sibilance of some voices is lessened.


Plays on R4 are completely different kettle of fish: they seem to suffer
from distant-mike syndrome which causes much more variation in the level of
an actor's voice from one word to another, making it quite difficult to
listen to for any time because you are alternately being deafened or having
to strain to hear some words, depending on whether they are on-mike or not
at that moment.


Max Demian July 20th 13 12:49 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Bill Wright" wrote in message
...
Woody wrote:

We changed out caravan late last year and the new one is fitted with a
JVC car radio that has a 3.5mm input socket on the front. I built a
simple preamp, ran cables around inside the cupboards and left a tail to
plug into the headphone socket of our Sharp 19" TV.


I'm surprised you need a preamp. The 'aux in' on my motorhome radio works
fine straight from the telly.


Audio (line) inputs are usually low level high impedance, and headphone
outputs are medium level low impedance. The impedance mismatch compensates
for the level mismatch, avoiding overload. I always just plug the headphone
outputs of various MP3 players straight into various amplifier inputs
without trouble.

--
Max Demian



Derek F[_3_] July 20th 13 01:07 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On 19/07/2013 09:37, NY wrote:
"Derek F" wrote in message
...
On 19/07/2013 08:43, Brian Gaff wrote:
Its not just actors is it. On some recent Horizon episodes the music
was so
loud I could not hear the carefully chosen sound bytes from
scientists I'd
never heard of at all.
Brian

Its not just a TV problem as most Movies are just as bad.
British stage actors used to have voices that carried without the need
of electronics. We went to see Dame Judy in a play and sitting in the
rear of the circle it was a struggle to hear her.


I'd rather have actors and actresses speaking in normal (but audible,
intelligible) voices than have them straining to project their voices to
the back of a theatre without the aid of amplification. A projected
voice never sounds natural.

It has made stage acting the same as movie acting. How long before
someone starts making stage plays more dramatic by adding music:-)
Derek

Dave Plowman (News) July 20th 13 01:18 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
NY wrote:
One thing that R4 suffers badly from is excruciatingly annoying sibilant
S sounds, especially on female voices.


What are you listening on?

Maybe for TV newsreaders, the
mikes have a poorer HF response so the sibilance of some voices is
lessened.


A personal mic is simply in the wrong place for decent audio quality.
Although this does vary from person to person. But the frequency response
of the individual mic (eq) should be adjusted for each and every
presenter, etc.



Plays on R4 are completely different kettle of fish: they seem to suffer
from distant-mike syndrome which causes much more variation in the level
of an actor's voice from one word to another, making it quite difficult
to listen to for any time because you are alternately being deafened or
having to strain to hear some words, depending on whether they are
on-mike or not at that moment.


Strange. I listen to the afternoon play most days and have never noticed
this. They can and do have a reasonable dynamic range, though, which is
how it should be done.

--
*Procrastinate now

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Derek F[_3_] July 20th 13 01:48 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On 19/07/2013 11:14, Martin wrote:
On Fri, 19 Jul 2013 10:46:17 +0100, "Dave Plowman (News)"
wrote:

Two different things. You can drown out any voice with too loud music and
or effects. Mumbling can be difficult to understand on its own.

It's definitely not helped by pretty well all TV drama these days using
personal mics buried beneath layers of ordinary clothing. Nothing much you
can do about poorly recorded sound. And than add in the poor sound systems
on most tellies.


The head of RADA complained about mumbling actors some weeks ago.

In 2011 we went to see Keira Knightley and Elizabeth Moss in Children's
Hour at the Comedy Theatre. Their idea of stage acting was to strut,
stamp, wave their arms about and shout with pained expressions on their
faces.
By contrast the two older more experienced stage actors (evidently not
allowed to call them actresses now) Bryony Hannah believably went
through a wide range of emotions playing the part of a schoolgirl. One
was inclined to watch her movements and expression even when the leading
ladies were were doing their stuff.
Ellen Burstyn gave a beautiful performance here as good as any she has
done in all of her years on screen.
As one reviewer said that is the difference between a celluloid
mannequin and a top-flight stage actress when praising Bryony Hannah.
Derek



Bill Wright[_2_] July 20th 13 02:55 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Max Demian wrote:
"Bill Wright" wrote in message
...
Woody wrote:

We changed out caravan late last year and the new one is fitted with a
JVC car radio that has a 3.5mm input socket on the front. I built a
simple preamp, ran cables around inside the cupboards and left a tail to
plug into the headphone socket of our Sharp 19" TV.

I'm surprised you need a preamp. The 'aux in' on my motorhome radio works
fine straight from the telly.


Audio (line) inputs are usually low level high impedance, and headphone
outputs are medium level low impedance. The impedance mismatch compensates
for the level mismatch, avoiding overload. I always just plug the headphone
outputs of various MP3 players straight into various amplifier inputs
without trouble.

I have two Sony tellys (both fairly new) with their headphone sockets
feeding audio amps. No problems.

In one case I went for ages with the audio to the amp coming from the TV
set's accompanying Humax box, aware of the slight lipsync issue but
couldn't be arsed to do anything about it. Then, inexplicably, the
lipsync error suddenly because gross, so I had to go find a 3.5mm stereo
jack to twin phone patch cord.

Bill

Woody[_4_] July 20th 13 12:38 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Max Demian" wrote in message
...
"Bill Wright" wrote in message
...
Woody wrote:

We changed out caravan late last year and the new one is
fitted with a JVC car radio that has a 3.5mm input socket on
the front. I built a simple preamp, ran cables around inside
the cupboards and left a tail to plug into the headphone
socket of our Sharp 19" TV.


I'm surprised you need a preamp. The 'aux in' on my motorhome
radio works fine straight from the telly.


Audio (line) inputs are usually low level high impedance, and
headphone outputs are medium level low impedance. The impedance
mismatch compensates for the level mismatch, avoiding overload.
I always just plug the headphone outputs of various MP3 players
straight into various amplifier inputs without trouble.

--
Max Demian


Er, where did you learn your 'lectronics Max?

Normal format is low impedence out, high impredence in as you
say. The input will thus not load the output in any way and there
will be no level change as a consequence. In fact as the
headphone output is not loaded (usually expected to be between
32R and 330R these days) the actual signal voltage available
would be higher than expected when loaded.


--
Woody

harrogate three at ntlworld dot com



NY July 20th 13 07:47 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Dave Plowman (News)" wrote in message
...
In article ,
NY wrote:
One thing that R4 suffers badly from is excruciatingly annoying sibilant
S sounds, especially on female voices.


What are you listening on?


I'm encountered it on R4 on a variety of radios, ranging from cheap portable
through car radio to expensive Technics tuner, amplifier and
speakers/headphones, though worst with expensive kit, due maybe to the
better HF response which allows sibilant frequencies through which cheaper
kit suppresses.

Harriet Cass and Corrie Corfield seemed to suffer from it more than
Charlotte Green.


Bill Wright[_2_] July 20th 13 08:44 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Woody wrote:

Er,


Anyway, how's it going Woody? Has she said you're getting in her way and
given you a tenner to go down the pub yet?

Bill

Woody[_4_] July 20th 13 10:00 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Bill Wright" wrote in message
...
Woody wrote:

Er,


Anyway, how's it going Woody? Has she said you're getting in
her way and given you a tenner to go down the pub yet?

Bill




Nah, been away in't van since the event and she's starving me -
OK I get told off if she finds me eating choc biscuits - with the
intent of weight reduction. 4lbs in three weeks seems good and
I'm not missing the snacks, still drinking though!!



--
Woody

harrogate three at ntlworld dot com



Grimly Curmudgeon[_2_] July 20th 13 11:39 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On Fri, 19 Jul 2013 00:15:41 +0100, Derek F
wrote:

Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn


About bloody time. Even though affected a bit by accumulated decades,
my hearing is still pretty good and I was seriously wondering if it
had got worse in some frequencies because of that shower of mumbling
******* and their demonic meeja-studies graduate producers.

PeterC July 21st 13 12:15 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On Sat, 20 Jul 2013 22:39:07 +0100, Grimly Curmudgeon wrote:

On Fri, 19 Jul 2013 00:15:41 +0100, Derek F
wrote:

Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn


About bloody time. Even though affected a bit by accumulated decades,
my hearing is still pretty good and I was seriously wondering if it
had got worse in some frequencies because of that shower of mumbling
******* and their demonic meeja-studies graduate producers.


er, hear hear!
On most studio programmes I can have the sound on the telly at 12 - 14% (bit
more as the day progresses - perhaps my hearing needs an afternoon nap
nowadays), but some films, drama and older programmes need the AVR, a
grotesque preset to give preference to speech and 40% or even more (Stargate
SG1 for instance).
--
Peter.
The gods will stay away
whilst religions hold sway

Dave Plowman (News) July 21st 13 12:59 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
NY wrote:
"Dave Plowman (News)" wrote in message
...
In article ,
NY wrote:
One thing that R4 suffers badly from is excruciatingly annoying
sibilant S sounds, especially on female voices.


What are you listening on?


I'm encountered it on R4 on a variety of radios, ranging from cheap
portable through car radio to expensive Technics tuner, amplifier and
speakers/headphones, though worst with expensive kit, due maybe to the
better HF response which allows sibilant frequencies through which
cheaper kit suppresses.


Harriet Cass and Corrie Corfield seemed to suffer from it more than
Charlotte Green.


I'd need your definition of 'sibilant' before commenting further. I tend
to think of it as 'splashy' S sounds - common on an FM receiver which is
suffering from multi-path reception or is poorly designed. Or distortion
elsewhere in the chain.

Since the reproduction of those frequencies will vary dramatically from
one system to another, I think we must be talking about a different thing.

--
*Dance like nobody's watching.

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

charles July 21st 13 08:32 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
Dave Plowman (News) wrote:
In article ,
NY wrote:
"Dave Plowman (News)" wrote in message
...
In article ,
NY wrote:
One thing that R4 suffers badly from is excruciatingly annoying
sibilant S sounds, especially on female voices.

What are you listening on?


I'm encountered it on R4 on a variety of radios, ranging from cheap
portable through car radio to expensive Technics tuner, amplifier and
speakers/headphones, though worst with expensive kit, due maybe to the
better HF response which allows sibilant frequencies through which
cheaper kit suppresses.


Harriet Cass and Corrie Corfield seemed to suffer from it more than
Charlotte Green.


I'd need your definition of 'sibilant' before commenting further. I tend
to think of it as 'splashy' S sounds - common on an FM receiver which is
suffering from multi-path reception or is poorly designed. Or distortion
elsewhere in the chain.



sometimes sibilance is caused by poor audio amplifier performance. Early
Ampex VTRs suffered in this way. Certain female voices are particularly
successful in setting the effect off and many voices become sibilant after
taking a drink (it doesn't have to be alcoholic). I've heard that problem
within a local radio studio building - no off air path.

--
From KT24

Using a RISC OS computer running v5.18


Dave Plowman (News) July 21st 13 12:12 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
charles wrote:
I'd need your definition of 'sibilant' before commenting further. I
tend to think of it as 'splashy' S sounds - common on an FM receiver
which is suffering from multi-path reception or is poorly designed. Or
distortion elsewhere in the chain.



sometimes sibilance is caused by poor audio amplifier performance. Early
Ampex VTRs suffered in this way. Certain female voices are particularly
successful in setting the effect off and many voices become sibilant
after taking a drink (it doesn't have to be alcoholic). I've heard that
problem within a local radio studio building - no off air path.


It's also common practice to EQ a mic in such a way as to emphasise the
presence frequencies which will include the 'S'.

But the only time I've heard a problem with this on R4 is with faulty
reception or equipment. And I listen to R4 a great deal.

--
*Experience is something you don't get until just after you need it.*

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

tony sayer July 21st 13 04:38 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article , Grimly
Curmudgeon scribeth thus
On Fri, 19 Jul 2013 00:15:41 +0100, Derek F
wrote:

Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn


About bloody time. Even though affected a bit by accumulated decades,
my hearing is still pretty good and I was seriously wondering if it
had got worse in some frequencies because of that shower of mumbling
******* and their demonic meeja-studies graduate producers.


JOOI have you had it tested in recent years?. There is a dip in peoples
hearing when they are getting on a bit that can have quite an effect in
that area..

Do agree about production standards tho;!..
--
Tony Sayer


Max Demian July 21st 13 07:39 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Grimly Curmudgeon" wrote in message
...
On Fri, 19 Jul 2013 00:15:41 +0100, Derek F
wrote:

Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn


About bloody time. Even though affected a bit by accumulated decades,
my hearing is still pretty good and I was seriously wondering if it
had got worse in some frequencies because of that shower of mumbling
******* and their demonic meeja-studies graduate producers.


Most of what the actors are saying doesn't matter as it's just filler or
'character development'. The problem is you can't tell whether what they
have just said is a vitally important part of the plot which will be only
said once.

A lot of TV/film directors just don't know how to tell a story.

--
Max Demian



Ian Jackson[_2_] July 21st 13 10:45 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In message , Max Demian
writes
"Grimly Curmudgeon" wrote in message
.. .
On Fri, 19 Jul 2013 00:15:41 +0100, Derek F
wrote:

Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn


About bloody time. Even though affected a bit by accumulated decades,
my hearing is still pretty good and I was seriously wondering if it
had got worse in some frequencies because of that shower of mumbling
******* and their demonic meeja-studies graduate producers.


Most of what the actors are saying doesn't matter as it's just filler or
'character development'. The problem is you can't tell whether what they
have just said is a vitally important part of the plot which will be only
said once.

A lot of TV/film directors just don't know how to tell a story.

My wife has tinnitus, and has to use subtitles all the time. I have
pretty good hearing, but I too am starting to use subtitles (if
available). I also usually watch a recording of the programme (more
often than not a watch-and-record) so I can go back and re-hear the
mumbly bits. Unfortunately, a lot of the subtitles are total rubbish -
especially (but not only) when the programme is live. The BBC is
particularly bad, but the ITV and other channels are now also learning
the art of adding gibberish text.
--
Ian

--- news://freenews.netfront.net/ - complaints: ---

Max Demian July 21st 13 11:26 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
"Ian Jackson" wrote in message
...
In message , Max Demian


Most of what the actors are saying doesn't matter as it's just filler or
'character development'. The problem is you can't tell whether what they
have just said is a vitally important part of the plot which will be only
said once.

A lot of TV/film directors just don't know how to tell a story.

My wife has tinnitus, and has to use subtitles all the time. I have pretty
good hearing, but I too am starting to use subtitles (if available). I
also usually watch a recording of the programme (more often than not a
watch-and-record) so I can go back and re-hear the mumbly bits.
Unfortunately, a lot of the subtitles are total rubbish - especially (but
not only) when the programme is live. The BBC is particularly bad, but the
ITV and other channels are now also learning the art of adding gibberish
text.


Jonathan Creek had lumps missing from the subtitles on Drama.

--
Max Demian



Chris J Dixon July 22nd 13 09:19 AM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Dave Plowman (News) wrote:

In article ,
NY wrote:
One thing that R4 suffers badly from is excruciatingly annoying sibilant
S sounds, especially on female voices.


What are you listening on?

Maybe for TV newsreaders, the
mikes have a poorer HF response so the sibilance of some voices is
lessened.


A personal mic is simply in the wrong place for decent audio quality.
Although this does vary from person to person. But the frequency response
of the individual mic (eq) should be adjusted for each and every
presenter, etc.

Many years ago, with my first hi-fi set up, I was a little
concerned that a particular LP seemed to exhibit considerable
sibilance, and spent some time in a vain attempt to reduce the
effect.

It was only when I saw the performer live, without PA, that I
discovered that my audio kit was faithfully reproducing the
original sound.

Chris
--
Chris J Dixon Nottingham UK


Plant amazing Acers.

Bill Wright[_2_] July 22nd 13 02:36 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Chris J Dixon wrote:

Many years ago, with my first hi-fi set up, I was a little
concerned that a particular LP seemed to exhibit considerable
sibilance, and spent some time in a vain attempt to reduce the
effect.

It was only when I saw the performer live, without PA, that I
discovered that my audio kit was faithfully reproducing the
original sound.


I had the same experience with some of sounds made by string
instruments, and recently an odd high pitched percussive sound on an
amateur brass band recording was eventually traced to a carrier bag
containing four bottles of beer.

Bill

Chris J Dixon July 22nd 13 06:59 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
Bill Wright wrote:

I had the same experience with some of sounds made by string
instruments, and recently an odd high pitched percussive sound on an
amateur brass band recording was eventually traced to a carrier bag
containing four bottles of beer.

There is a tale of a more rock-oriented sound crew being faced
with a folk music group, and having to mike a hurdy gurdy.

They spent many minutes on the desk fiddling and tweaking trying
to get rid of the buzz. ;-)

Chris
--
Chris J Dixon Nottingham UK


Plant amazing Acers.

Dave Plowman (News) July 22nd 13 07:52 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
In article ,
Chris J Dixon wrote:
Bill Wright wrote:


I had the same experience with some of sounds made by string
instruments, and recently an odd high pitched percussive sound on an
amateur brass band recording was eventually traced to a carrier bag
containing four bottles of beer.

There is a tale of a more rock-oriented sound crew being faced
with a folk music group, and having to mike a hurdy gurdy.


They spent many minutes on the desk fiddling and tweaking trying
to get rid of the buzz. ;-)


Rule 1 when required to mic up something you don't know is listen to it
first.

Saw a pic on Facebook the other day of a guitar speaker with separate amp
on top. With the amp miked up...

--
*Make it idiot-proof and someone will make a better idiot.

Dave Plowman London SW
To e-mail, change noise into sound.

Mark[_13_] July 23rd 13 12:10 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On Sat, 20 Jul 2013 22:39:07 +0100, Grimly Curmudgeon
wrote:

On Fri, 19 Jul 2013 00:15:41 +0100, Derek F
wrote:

Is the message at last getting through?
http://tinyurl.com/osakepn


About bloody time. Even though affected a bit by accumulated decades,
my hearing is still pretty good and I was seriously wondering if it
had got worse in some frequencies because of that shower of mumbling
******* and their demonic meeja-studies graduate producers.


I'm sure it's not just old age in our household. It's generally the
kids that ask for subtitles to be turned on.
--
(\__/) M.
(='.'=) If a man stands in a forest and no woman is around
(")_(") is he still wrong?


Grimly Curmudgeon[_2_] July 28th 13 01:05 PM

Mumbling actors and loud musc
 
On Sun, 21 Jul 2013 15:38:29 +0100, tony sayer
wrote:

About bloody time. Even though affected a bit by accumulated decades,
my hearing is still pretty good and I was seriously wondering if it
had got worse in some frequencies because of that shower of mumbling
******* and their demonic meeja-studies graduate producers.


JOOI have you had it tested in recent years?.


Last proper test was a decade ago, when I was taking up employment in
a very noisy environment (very good protection was provided) and the
employer had to make sure exactly what state employees' hearing was
in, in case of future hearing loss action. There was a dip in some
frequencies, but armed with that knowledge I've been very aware of my
state of hearing since then.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:13 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com