HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   UK digital tv (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   National Mass Retuning Day (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=63394)

J G Miller[_4_] May 21st 09 09:49 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup

Ivan[_2_] May 21st 09 11:19 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 

"J G Miller" wrote in message
...

A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.


I'm a protestant will it affect me?




Peter Duncanson May 21st 09 11:33 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On Thu, 21 May 2009 22:19:41 +0100, "Ivan"
wrote:


"J G Miller" wrote in message
...

A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.


I'm a protestant will it affect me?


smile

kim May 22nd 09 01:45 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
J G Miller wrote:
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The
Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup


Nearer £300 with a hard drive I suspect?

(kim)



Mark Carver May 22nd 09 07:55 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
J G Miller wrote:
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup


With ITV and C4 thinking very carefully about whether to commit to DTT
HD (AIUI ITV's 'Future Technology' staff were sacked yesterday), DVB-T2
might well stall. With only one HD service looking possible, T2 won't be
needed yet. You could transmit BBC HD within the 64QAM DSO'd version of
Mux B (aka PSB 3) keeping it at DVB-T1. Of course existing receivers
would not be able to receive the HD service, but the clearing of PSB 3
of existing SD services would not be necessary.

Just a thought.

--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

http://www.paras.org.uk/

Agamemnon May 22nd 09 09:56 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 

"J G Miller" wrote in message
...
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup


These morons have got to be out of their minds. You can get a Sky+HD box,
which includes a built in hard drive for only £49, and installation is free.
On top of that the bitrate on satellite is considerably higher than the
6mbps that each channel is going to be broadcast at on DVB-T2. 6mbps is
barley adequate for SD quality on DVD let alone HD.

And to pay for this rubbish, are these ******* are going to cram the
existing 5 terrestrial channels, plus BBC3/CBBC, BBC4/Cbeebies, BBC News,
BBC Parliament, 3 BBC interactive streams and 12 BBC radio stations and the
text service into 24mbps, averaging less than 2mbps each? And if not where
are the other 8 channels (counting the radio stations as one channel) going
to go?




Brian Gaff May 22nd 09 10:09 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
You know it always amazes me that when all of this was being designed, the
need for a transmitter commanded retune was not seen. It was obvious to me
from the very start that the evolving standards and the fact that at the
outset transmissions would need to share with analogue, that this function
would be tremendously useful.

Brian

--
Brian Gaff -
Note:- In order to reduce spam, any email without 'Brian Gaff'
in the display name may be lost.
Blind user, so no pictures please!
"J G Miller" wrote in message
...
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup




Brian Gaff May 22nd 09 10:11 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
And if nobody buys them they will keep reducing the quality of standard
freeview until they do..
Brian

--
Brian Gaff -
Note:- In order to reduce spam, any email without 'Brian Gaff'
in the display name may be lost.
Blind user, so no pictures please!
"kim" wrote in message
...
J G Miller wrote:
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The
Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup


Nearer £300 with a hard drive I suspect?

(kim)




Mark C May 22nd 09 10:22 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On May 22, 9:09*am, "Brian Gaff" wrote:
You know it always amazes me that when all of this was being designed, the
need for a transmitter commanded retune was not seen. It was obvious to me
from the very start that the evolving standards and the fact that at the
outset transmissions would need to share with analogue, that this function
would be tremendously useful.


I agree, even the Freesat platform (only a year old) doesn't seem to
have fully transparent handling when new channels arrive, you are
prompted to perform a scan. Yet Sky's platform, has always been able
to automagically add, remove, and shuffle its channels and services
without any viewer intervention required. If a service moves
transponder (the equivalent of a DTT mux change, it is silently
remapped within the EPG, with zero fuss).

David Hearn May 22nd 09 10:23 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
Agamemnon wrote:

"J G Miller" wrote in message
...
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup


These morons have got to be out of their minds. You can get a Sky+HD
box, which includes a built in hard drive for only £49, and installation
is free.


£49, plus minimum of £26.25 per month for minimum of 12 months. So
absolute minimum cost over the 12 months = £364.

They give you the box for peanuts, because they hope you'll stay for
longer than 1 year - each subsequent year they get another £315 off you.
They probably recoup their costs in the first year, but hope you'll
stay on for longer.

Do you still lose the ability to record, or play back recorded
programmes ones you've cancelled your subscription? If so, then you
just end up with a glorified FreeSat box.

D

Mark C May 22nd 09 10:29 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On May 22, 9:23*am, David Hearn wrote:

£49, plus minimum of £26.25 per month for minimum of 12 months. *So
absolute minimum cost over the 12 months = £364.

They give you the box for peanuts, because they hope you'll stay for
longer than 1 year - each subsequent year they get another £315 off you..
* *They probably recoup their costs in the first year, but hope you'll
stay on for longer.

Do you still lose the ability to record, or play back recorded
programmes ones you've cancelled your subscription? *If so, then you
just end up with a glorified FreeSat box.


That's right, kill the Sky sub, and you effectively kill the HDD.

Ivan[_2_] May 22nd 09 10:31 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 

"David Hearn" wrote in message
...
Agamemnon wrote:

"J G Miller" wrote in message
...
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The
Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup


These morons have got to be out of their minds. You can get a Sky+HD box,
which includes a built in hard drive for only £49, and installation is
free.


£49, plus minimum of £26.25 per month for minimum of 12 months. So
absolute minimum cost over the 12 months = £364.

They give you the box for peanuts, because they hope you'll stay for
longer than 1 year - each subsequent year they get another £315 off you.
They probably recoup their costs in the first year, but hope you'll stay
on for longer.

Do you still lose the ability to record, or play back recorded programmes
ones you've cancelled your subscription? If so, then you just end up with
a glorified FreeSat box.


Also bear in mind that the very mention of the words 'Sky' or 'Murdoch' has
a similar effect on many people to that of 'Thatcher' on a dyed in the wool
socialist.










tony sayer May 22nd 09 11:38 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
In article , Agamemnon
scribeth thus

"J G Miller" wrote in message
...
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009...view-retuning-

world-cup

These morons have got to be out of their minds. You can get a Sky+HD box,
which includes a built in hard drive for only £49, and installation is free.
On top of that the bitrate on satellite is considerably higher than the
6mbps that each channel is going to be broadcast at on DVB-T2. 6mbps is
barley adequate for SD quality on DVD let alone HD.

And to pay for this rubbish, are these ******* are going to cram the
existing 5 terrestrial channels, plus BBC3/CBBC, BBC4/Cbeebies, BBC News,
BBC Parliament, 3 BBC interactive streams and 12 BBC radio stations and the
text service into 24mbps, averaging less than 2mbps each? And if not where
are the other 8 channels (counting the radio stations as one channel) going
to go?




Whats your MP have to say about this?, if you can get his/her snout outa
the trough for long enough;..
--
Tony Sayer




tony sayer May 22nd 09 11:39 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
In article , Ivan
scribeth thus

"David Hearn" wrote in message
...
Agamemnon wrote:

"J G Miller" wrote in message
...
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The
Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009...view-retuning-

world-cup

These morons have got to be out of their minds. You can get a Sky+HD box,
which includes a built in hard drive for only £49, and installation is
free.


£49, plus minimum of £26.25 per month for minimum of 12 months. So
absolute minimum cost over the 12 months = £364.

They give you the box for peanuts, because they hope you'll stay for
longer than 1 year - each subsequent year they get another £315 off you.
They probably recoup their costs in the first year, but hope you'll stay
on for longer.

Do you still lose the ability to record, or play back recorded programmes
ones you've cancelled your subscription? If so, then you just end up with
a glorified FreeSat box.


Also bear in mind that the very mention of the words 'Sky' or 'Murdoch' has
a similar effect on many people to that of 'Thatcher' on a dyed in the wool
socialist.


Meanwhile Arqiva have a bigger business and monopoly and no one bats an
eyelid;!..


Its the Aussies revenge;!...









--
Tony Sayer




Richard Brooks[_2_] May 22nd 09 12:05 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
J G Miller said the following on 21/05/2009 20:49:
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup



Remember the olden days when you'd get a plain screen announcing
transmitter engineering works which will happen in a couple of months
time and apologies for any inconvenience caused? After it was done,
that would be it for a long time.

Wouldn't it be nice for a governing body to suspend channel renaming
and frequency shifting and for it to be done all on one day.

charles May 22nd 09 12:19 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
In article , Richard Brooks
wrote:


Remember the olden days when you'd get a plain screen announcing
transmitter engineering works which will happen in a couple of months
time and apologies for any inconvenience caused? After it was done,
that would be it for a long time.


Wouldn't it be nice for a governing body to suspend channel renaming and
frequency shifting and for it to be done all on one day.


no telly for a whole day - you'd have a riot ;-)

--
From KT24 - in "Leafy Surrey"

Using a RISC OS computer running v5.11


Graham.[_3_] May 22nd 09 12:24 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
Remember the olden days when you'd get a plain screen announcing
transmitter engineering works which will happen in a couple of months time
and apologies for any inconvenience caused?


Cue grams "Walk and Talk"

--
Graham.

%Profound_observation%



South Downs May 22nd 09 12:30 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
tony sayer wrote:

Also bear in mind that the very mention of the words 'Sky' or 'Murdoch' has
a similar effect on many people to that of 'Thatcher' on a dyed in the wool
socialist.


Meanwhile Arqiva have a bigger business and monopoly and no one bats an
eyelid;!..


Its the Aussies revenge;!...



Not really. Arqiva might have cornered the transmission market, but that market
is being slowly replaced by satellite and broadband over 3G and 4G. The BBC and
other broadcasters know this, hence the large investment in those technologies.


Steve Terry[_2_] May 22nd 09 12:55 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 

"Ivan" wrote in message
...
"J G Miller" wrote in message
...

A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.


I'm a protestant will it affect me?


Only if you have been circumcised

Steve Terry



[email protected] May 22nd 09 01:26 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On 22 Maj, 01:45, "kim" wrote:
J G Miller wrote:
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.


And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The
Grauniad)


http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retun....


Nearer £300 with a hard drive I suspect?

(kim)


I posted this on digitalspy
http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/forums/s...7&postcount=21

Where 'Ilse Howling, the managing director of Freeview'
is quoted - May 4. - for the £200, NOT for
a Freeview box - but a Freeview + HD box.

It took me 3-4 minutes and Google to find
this article and the quote.

Lars :)

PS! PSB-3 HD channels will share 36.1 Mbps
or 11.5 Mbps each (+ overhead 1-2 Mbps)
Later in 2010 4 channels will use 8.5 Mbps.


Mark Carver May 22nd 09 02:25 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
South Downs wrote:
tony sayer wrote:

Also bear in mind that the very mention of the words 'Sky' or 'Murdoch' has
a similar effect on many people to that of 'Thatcher' on a dyed in the wool
socialist.

Meanwhile Arqiva have a bigger business and monopoly and no one bats an
eyelid;!..


Its the Aussies revenge;!...



Not really. Arqiva might have cornered the transmission market, but that market
is being slowly replaced by satellite and broadband over 3G and 4G. The BBC and
other broadcasters know this, hence the large investment in those technologies.


Arqiva also supply the BBC with OB Trucks, studio facilities, and (via
sister company Red Bee) playout and subtitling.



--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

http://www.paras.org.uk/

Mark Carver May 22nd 09 02:32 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
wrote:


PS! PSB-3 HD channels will share 36.1 Mbps
or 11.5 Mbps each (+ overhead 1-2 Mbps)
Later in 2010 4 channels will use 8.5 Mbps.


Replace 'will' with 'might'. There's a deep recession on if you haven't
noticed !



--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

http://www.paras.org.uk/

[email protected] May 22nd 09 03:12 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On 22 Maj, 14:32, Mark Carver wrote:
There's a deep recession on if you haven't
noticed !


And ? -

The C4 ITV problems are related to income
- not expenses.

Its an advertising based businessmodel that
breaks in all recessions - currently in the UK
and almost everywhere.

In the US newpapers are dying - for the
very same reason. This has nothing to do
with DTT transmissions of HD in the UK.

The BBC have the same income (and the
government do print money).

MUX-B must pass DSO and the cost will be
next to identical for DVB-T and DVB-T2.

Consumers may buy a few boxes more or less
- who cares as long as the BBC-1 is universally
available.

Lars :)

tony sayer May 22nd 09 06:54 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
In article , South Downs
[email protected]?.? scribeth thus
tony sayer wrote:

Also bear in mind that the very mention of the words 'Sky' or 'Murdoch' has
a similar effect on many people to that of 'Thatcher' on a dyed in the wool
socialist.


Meanwhile Arqiva have a bigger business and monopoly and no one bats an
eyelid;!..


Its the Aussies revenge;!...



Not really. Arqiva might have cornered the transmission market, but that market
is being slowly replaced by satellite and broadband over 3G and 4G. The BBC and
other broadcasters know this, hence the large investment in those technologies.


Come on now .. that may happen one day but at the moment a lot of the
country is staggering along with very poor ADSL over 100 year old copper
delivery and theres a lot of places barely 30 miles from London where 2G
voice is **** poor still!..

Also Arqiva have cornered the market for the delivery of 3 and whatever
G mobile as they own a lot of the infrastructure do it with...
--
Tony Sayer


Andy Champ[_2_] May 22nd 09 10:04 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
J G Miller wrote:
A National Mass Retuning Day has been proposed.

And DVB-t2/MPEG-4 boxes are to be priced at GBP 200 (claims The Grauniad)

http://www.guardian.co.UK/media/2009/may/20/digital-tv-freeview-retuning-world-cup


Let me get this right - at the moment there are no DVB-T2 boxes available.

There won't be any until maybe Q4 this year.

So in the 6 months following that they hope to roll out maybe 10 million
boxes for all the footy nuts in the UK? In the middle of a recession,
when they haven't got any money?

Andy

J G Miller[_4_] May 22nd 09 10:42 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On Fri, 22 May 2009 21:04:36 +0100, Andy Champ wrote:

So in the 6 months following that they hope to roll out maybe 10 million
boxes for all the footy nuts in the UK? In the middle of a recession,
when they haven't got any money?


Consumer driven economic recovery? ;)


[email protected] May 23rd 09 05:17 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On 22 Maj, 22:04, Andy Champ wrote:

Let me get this right - at the moment there are no DVB-T2 boxes available..

There won't be any until maybe Q4 this year.


Nobody will need then before Q4.

So in the 6 months following that they hope to roll out maybe 10 million
boxes for all the footy nuts in the UK? *In the middle of a recession,
when they haven't got any money?

Andy


Nobody expect all 10 million households to be 'footy nuts'
and buy a new receiver in the first 6 months - even though
this would not present any larger logistical problem than
delivering say a box or 'Kellogg's' for 10 million households.

Nobody cares if some viewers cannot afford a new box
in 6 months, in 12 or ever. I hope HD is NOT on the list
of 'must have' at social security offices.

The HD broadcast is a service that will be offered for free
but it will have a small initial cost - say £100 - for a STB,
if you or others want to use this service - end of story.

Its just TV - not life or death.

Lars :)

Mark Carver May 23rd 09 06:19 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
wrote:

So in the 6 months following that they hope to roll out maybe 10 million
boxes for all the footy nuts in the UK? In the middle of a recession,
when they haven't got any money?

Andy


Nobody expect all 10 million households to be 'footy nuts'
and buy a new receiver in the first 6 months - even though
this would not present any larger logistical problem than
delivering say a box or 'Kellogg's' for 10 million households.


I think you'll find anybody who is a 'Footy Nut' already has Sky ?
Any HD inclined 'Footy Nut' will already have (or will soon upgrade to) Sky HD.


--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

www.paras.org.uk

J G Miller[_4_] May 23rd 09 07:09 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
On Sat, 23 May 2009 08:17:18 -0700, reslfj wrote:

I hope HD is NOT on the list of 'must have' at social
security offices.


It is if you live in The Netherlands.

http://www.shortnews.COM/start.cfm?id=74409


Andy Champ[_2_] May 23rd 09 11:58 PM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
Mark Carver wrote:

I think you'll find anybody who is a 'Footy Nut' already has Sky ?
Any HD inclined 'Footy Nut' will already have (or will soon upgrade to)
Sky HD.



That's a good argument.

So why are they concerned about getting HD on it ready for the world cup?

Andy

Mark Carver May 24th 09 12:28 AM

National Mass Retuning Day
 
Andy Champ wrote:
Mark Carver wrote:

I think you'll find anybody who is a 'Footy Nut' already has Sky ?
Any HD inclined 'Footy Nut' will already have (or will soon upgrade
to) Sky HD.



That's a good argument.

So why are they concerned about getting HD on it ready for the world cup?


Perhaps because the World Cup is one of the most popular sporting events that
BSkyB don't have exclusive rights to ? Rights in Europe are still held by the
PSBs through their EBU membership (BBC and ITV jointly for the UK).


--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

www.paras.org.uk


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:07 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com