HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   UK digital tv (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   BBC News report: extra second of time (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=61386)

Jay December 31st 08 09:12 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!





Mike O'Sullivan December 31st 08 09:18 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!

Absolutely agree. There is nothing that infuriates me more about the BBC.

[email protected] December 31st 08 09:30 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Jay wrote:

I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!



What caused the delay ?.

The Queen would have gone out on time and someone else on another group says
it was for the full 10 minutes, so did the news at 5.45 pm over run ?

Ian Jackson[_2_] December 31st 08 10:24 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
In message , Mike O'Sullivan
writes
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!

Absolutely agree. There is nothing that infuriates me more about the
BBC.


For those bringing in the New Year when watching digital TV or radio,
the magic stroke of midnight will already be around a second too late.
Should they start Ould Lang Syne on the 6th pip of the time signal?
This, of course, is normally the last, long pip. However, on this
occasion, it will be short, being the penultimate of 7 pips.
--
Ian

Bill Ridgeway December 31st 08 10:35 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
"Mike O'Sullivan" wrote in message
...
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the
year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC
One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!



There is a piece of technology called Programme Delivery Control (PDC)
which, with appropriate recorders, start and stop recording on transmission
of the programme. This is available on BBC1, BBC2 (and others?) and Channel
5 but not ITV1 or Channel 4 (This is not definitive!). Unfortunately this
does depend on the techies inserting the PDC code. I have missed recording
programmes either because the PDC code wasn't present or (for some reason)
only about the first two minutes recorded. There is also the problem of how
the recorder handles a following problem. Does it start immediately
(missing a few minutes) or does it not bother at all.

The BBC (and others) build in 'recovery time' into its schedules and also
includes repeats which can be pulled quickly when an 'important' programme
needs to be aired. What is VERY annoying is that even though the schedule
is running late it still insists on putting in trailers. Sureley these
could / should be dropped in an effort to regain lost time. I can
understand that commercial channels need to include advertising even when
running late but the comment on trailers equally applies to them.

Bill Ridgeway



Jay December 31st 08 10:48 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 

"Bill Ridgeway" wrote in message
...
"Mike O'Sullivan" wrote in message
...
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line

with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the
year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its

own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC
One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal

to
time programmes these days!



There is a piece of technology called Programme Delivery Control (PDC)
which, with appropriate recorders, start and stop recording on

transmission
of the programme. This is available on BBC1, BBC2 (and others?) and

Channel
5 but not ITV1 or Channel 4 (This is not definitive!). Unfortunately this
does depend on the techies inserting the PDC code. I have missed

recording
programmes either because the PDC code wasn't present or (for some reason)
only about the first two minutes recorded.


I agree, but would it not make more sense to keep to the schedule and proper
start time? I know there are odd occasions when a massive news story breaks
or somthing similar occurs when the schedule might be changed, but with
modern timing and digital methods they have no excuse for not starting and
ending programmes on time. Infact if I ran a radio or TV service, it would
be a priority to make sure timing was really accurate. It really is
unnaceptable for the BBC to be running such poor time keeping and I urge
everyone to complain to them about it.



Mark Carver December 31st 08 11:03 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
wrote:

What caused the delay ?.

The Queen would have gone out on time and someone else on another group says
it was for the full 10 minutes, so did the news at 5.45 pm over run ?


AIUI the delay was mostly caused by Strictly Come Dancing Christmas Special
overrunning. This programme was pre recorded on the afternoon of Monday 22nd
December, so why they couldn't edit it down to the allotted timeslot, when
they had 72 hours to do so is puzzling. In fact even more puzzling is this
programme was repeated on the BBC HD channel on Sunday evening, and ran for
its originally allocated timeslot of 60 mins !

The BBC/Red Bee could have eased the situation by ditching all subsequent
trailers, to move the schedule back towards the original timings. They didn't.
They even gave W&G a 35 second continuity announcement, FFS, just say " And
now, later than billed, Wallace and Grommet."

I'm afraid the whole sad state of affairs highlights the Beeb's attitude that
trailers and presentation are more important than the programmes themselves.
The apparent incomplete control of PDC, Freeview AR, and Sky+ triggers
displays technical incompetence, because those features are supposed to
safeguard situations like this, and whoever *deliberately* scheduled the
evening with those timings, just displayed utter contempt for the viewer.

In short a total disgrace.


--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

Light of Aria[_2_] December 31st 08 11:28 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
utter contempt for the viewer.




The BBC: "This is what we do"





Brian Gaff December 31st 08 11:29 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
I made my comments on this earlier, suffice to say, that if the recording
system worked on a unique ID on program content, rather than time, it would
really not matter.

Brian

--
Brian Gaff....Note, this account does not accept Bcc: email.
graphics are great, but the blind can't hear them
Email:
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________


"Jay" wrote in message
...
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC
One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!







Woody[_3_] December 31st 08 11:31 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
"Mike O'Sullivan" wrote in message
...
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line
with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the
year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its
own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the
'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost
every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal
to
time programmes these days!

Absolutely agree. There is nothing that infuriates me more about the
BBC.




Actually it is nothing to do with the BBC. It is the world time standard
that is being corrected to bring atomic time back into sync with solar
time as the earth's rotation is slightly slower than man-made time.

There has been much discussion of late that, rather than add a leap
second (as it is known) every so often, they should be held back and one
minute added perhaps twice a millenium. If this were done the next
adjustment would not be until (IMSMC) around 2050. However that would
cause all sorts of problems for other reasons, so I think they have
decided to let things run as now.

If you want more info - from a British perspective - look at
http://www.npl.co.uk/server.php?show=ConWebDoc.3010 which explains it
all.


--
Woody

harrogate three at ntlworld dot com



Jay December 31st 08 11:54 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 

"Woody" wrote in message
...
"Mike O'Sullivan" wrote in message
...
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line
with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the
year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its
own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the
'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost
every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal
to
time programmes these days!

Absolutely agree. There is nothing that infuriates me more about the
BBC.




Actually it is nothing to do with the BBC.


Nobody said it was anything to do with the BBC. I just said that the BBC
had reported the story on BBC News. Who said anything about it being
anything to do with the BBC?

What is the BBC's fault is the lack of time keeping on its TV channels.




Jay December 31st 08 11:58 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 

"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...
wrote:

What caused the delay ?.

The Queen would have gone out on time and someone else on another group

says
it was for the full 10 minutes, so did the news at 5.45 pm over run ?


AIUI the delay was mostly caused by Strictly Come Dancing Christmas

Special
overrunning. This programme was pre recorded on the afternoon of Monday

22nd
December, so why they couldn't edit it down to the allotted timeslot,


Probably for the same reason that no-one seemed to listen to the Ross's
recorded radio show that caused such an uproar a few weeks ago after it was
allowed to be broadcast.





Jay December 31st 08 12:07 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 

"Brian Gaff" wrote in message
m...
I made my comments on this earlier, suffice to say, that if the recording
system worked on a unique ID on program content, rather than time, it

would
really not matter.

Brian


Come on Brian, if the BBC can't tell the bloody time, how are they gonna
work out ID codes?

Time is simple enough and if they can't get that right they are obviously
behind the door. Obviously some t*at at the BBC overlooked the overun of
Strictly Con Dancing.
I am sure I could have done a good enough edit of it myself to fit it into
the alloted time slot. So why didn't they do it? Had they shut up the edit
shop for Christmas?

The Big finger is pointing to 12 and the little finger is pointing to the
3... Oh it must be 9 o'clock!





Laurence Payne[_2_] December 31st 08 12:07 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
On Wed, 31 Dec 2008 08:18:42 +0000, Mike O'Sullivan
wrote:

Absolutely agree. There is nothing that infuriates me more about the BBC.


Well, that's not too bad then!

The "Today" programme followed up (and rather trumped) that news at
8.30 this morning by giving a time-check that was 2 hours wrong.

Brian Gaff December 31st 08 12:45 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Well, pdc was invented yonks ago, and has been said on here, it appears not
all the broadcasters will support it...Cannot think why...So iits not just
the bbc is it. Nobody is going to go overboard with a system unless everyone
supports it.

anyway, what are you all going to do with your extra second.

Brian

--
Brian Gaff -
Note:- In order to reduce spam, any email without 'Brian Gaff'
in the display name may be lost.
Blind user, so no pictures please!
"Jay" wrote in message
...

"Brian Gaff" wrote in message
m...
I made my comments on this earlier, suffice to say, that if the recording
system worked on a unique ID on program content, rather than time, it

would
really not matter.

Brian


Come on Brian, if the BBC can't tell the bloody time, how are they gonna
work out ID codes?

Time is simple enough and if they can't get that right they are obviously
behind the door. Obviously some t*at at the BBC overlooked the overun of
Strictly Con Dancing.
I am sure I could have done a good enough edit of it myself to fit it into
the alloted time slot. So why didn't they do it? Had they shut up the
edit
shop for Christmas?

The Big finger is pointing to 12 and the little finger is pointing to the
3... Oh it must be 9 o'clock!







Mark Carver December 31st 08 12:47 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Brian Gaff wrote:
Well, pdc was invented yonks ago, and has been said on here, it appears not
all the broadcasters will support it...Cannot think why...So iits not just
the bbc is it. Nobody is going to go overboard with a system unless everyone
supports it.


It's all a very long story:-

http://625.uk.com/pdc/index.htm



--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

Dickie mint December 31st 08 12:57 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Mark Carver wrote:
wrote:

What caused the delay ?.

The Queen would have gone out on time and someone else on another
group says
it was for the full 10 minutes, so did the news at 5.45 pm over run ?


AIUI the delay was mostly caused by Strictly Come Dancing Christmas
Special overrunning. This programme was pre recorded on the afternoon of
Monday 22nd December, so why they couldn't edit it down to the allotted
timeslot, when they had 72 hours to do so is puzzling. In fact even more
puzzling is this programme was repeated on the BBC HD channel on Sunday
evening, and ran for its originally allocated timeslot of 60 mins !

The BBC/Red Bee could have eased the situation by ditching all
subsequent trailers, to move the schedule back towards the original
timings. They didn't.
They even gave W&G a 35 second continuity announcement, FFS, just say "
And now, later than billed, Wallace and Grommet."

I'm afraid the whole sad state of affairs highlights the Beeb's attitude
that trailers and presentation are more important than the programmes
themselves. The apparent incomplete control of PDC, Freeview AR, and
Sky+ triggers displays technical incompetence, because those features
are supposed to safeguard situations like this, and whoever
*deliberately* scheduled the evening with those timings, just displayed
utter contempt for the viewer.

In short a total disgrace.



Some years ago, whilst still working for the BBC, I asked a Presentation
contact why a certain trail (The Cliffhanger one) hadn't been pulled.

He said they weren't allowed to overrule marketing decisions, and that
they had to follow what ads - sorry trails - had been listed.

Also, this particular trail had been queried by Pres with marketing who
said it should go out. I think it resulted in something like 288
complaints.

marketing still rule though.

Richard

charles December 31st 08 01:20 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
In article ,
wrote:
On 31 Dec,
Laurence Payne wrote:



The "Today" programme followed up (and rather trumped) that news at
8.30 this morning by giving a time-check that was 2 hours wrong.


Jack Demaneu (SP?) lives on!


De Manio

--
From KT24 - in "Leafy Surrey"

Using a RISC OS computer running v5.11


Phil Cook[_2_] December 31st 08 01:54 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Jay wrote:

I see the BBC..........................On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!


Luckily I pad my recordings off Freeview with -1 +10 on my PVR so I
didn't miss anything. But I was wondering, how on earth did they get
that late? Was there some massive news breaking on Christmas Day that
I was and remain unaware of, or did they suffer some hicup in playout
of an "unmissable" programme?
--
Phil Cook looking north over the park to the "Westminster Gasworks"

Jay December 31st 08 02:01 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 

"Phil Cook" wrote in message
...
Jay wrote:

I see the BBC..........................On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC

One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!


Luckily I pad my recordings off Freeview with -1 +10 on my PVR so I
didn't miss anything. But I was wondering, how on earth did they get
that late? Was there some massive news breaking on Christmas Day that
I was and remain unaware of, or did they suffer some hicup in playout
of an "unmissable" programme?
--
Phil Cook looking north over the park to the "Westminster Gasworks"


The general consensus is that Strictly Come Dancing Christmas Special overan
its allocated time slot. Thus leaving everything else after it running by
about seven minutes late.



Peter Duncanson December 31st 08 02:20 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
On Wed, 31 Dec 2008 13:01:45 -0000, "Jay"
wrote:


"Phil Cook" wrote in message
.. .
Jay wrote:

I see the BBC..........................On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC

One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!


Luckily I pad my recordings off Freeview with -1 +10 on my PVR so I
didn't miss anything. But I was wondering, how on earth did they get
that late? Was there some massive news breaking on Christmas Day that
I was and remain unaware of, or did they suffer some hicup in playout
of an "unmissable" programme?
--
Phil Cook looking north over the park to the "Westminster Gasworks"


The general consensus is that Strictly Come Dancing Christmas Special overan
its allocated time slot. Thus leaving everything else after it running by
about seven minutes late.

The system does sometimes work well.

Following John Sergeant's withdrawal from Strictly Come Dancing there was an
extended edition of It Takes Two on BBC2. ITT started half an hour early and
lasted an hour instead of a half. It was correctly recorded in full by my
Humax Freeview PVR.

Grimly Curmudgeon December 31st 08 02:20 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the
drugs began to take hold. I remember "Jay"
saying something like:

I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?.


I must admit my ears perked up when I heard the Sky News bimbo announce
that "... the Earth has been turning slower than usual this year."

Followed at this end by gales of laughter.

Brian W December 31st 08 02:22 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 

"Jay" wrote in message
...
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC
One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal to
time programmes these days!

Strange. I managed to record 'Doctor Who' on my PC (with a manual tuner
setting - no EPG auto-updating) and didn't miss the end. I added two minutes
of padding and this was more than enough.


Peter Duncanson December 31st 08 02:33 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
On Wed, 31 Dec 2008 13:20:48 +0000, Grimly Curmudgeon
wrote:

We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the
drugs began to take hold. I remember "Jay"
saying something like:

I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?.


I must admit my ears perked up when I heard the Sky News bimbo announce
that "... the Earth has been turning slower than usual this year."

Followed at this end by gales of laughter.


Yes! As the Wikipedia article says:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leap_second

the rotation of Earth slows down continually, though at a slightly
variable rate.

Whether or not 2008 was a particularly slow (or less slow) year that is not
the reason for the leap second.


Adrian[_3_] December 31st 08 03:39 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Jay wrote:
"Woody" wrote in message
...
"Mike O'Sullivan" wrote in message
...
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in
line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of
the year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get
its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the
'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost
every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6
minutes. Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at
their disposal to
time programmes these days!

Absolutely agree. There is nothing that infuriates me more about the
BBC.




Actually it is nothing to do with the BBC.


Nobody said it was anything to do with the BBC. I just said that the
BBC had reported the story on BBC News. Who said anything about it
being anything to do with the BBC?

What is the BBC's fault is the lack of time keeping on its TV
channels.


You said it was to bring the UK in line with global timing, which is wrong.



Java Jive December 31st 08 04:03 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
I didn't think PDC was supported on DTT, only legacy analogue?

On Wed, 31 Dec 2008 09:35:02 -0000, "Bill Ridgeway"
wrote:

There is a piece of technology called Programme Delivery Control (PDC)
which, with appropriate recorders, start and stop recording on transmission
of the programme. This is available on BBC1, BBC2 (and others?) and Channel
5 but not ITV1 or Channel 4 (This is not definitive!).


Woody[_3_] December 31st 08 05:34 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Whilst we're on this topic peoples, watch you digital off-air clock at
midnight tonight. For one second you will see 23:59:60 - which we all
know cannot exist.


Where is The Doctor when he's needed?



--
Woody

harrogate three at ntlworld dot com



Light of Aria[_2_] December 31st 08 06:06 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 



Some years ago, whilst still working for the BBC, I asked a Presentation
contact why a certain trail (The Cliffhanger one) hadn't been pulled.

He said they weren't allowed to overrule marketing decisions, and that
they had to follow what ads - sorry trails - had been listed.

Also, this particular trail had been queried by Pres with marketing who
said it should go out. I think it resulted in something like 288
complaints.

marketing still rule though.

Richard




One imagines these sorts as the SS/Gestapo of the BBC regime, going around
in distinctive black uniforms with peaked caps and red BBC swastika logos on
their arms.

Your loyalty to the BBC Reich is in doubt: Your name vil go on ze list.




Johnny B Good December 31st 08 06:33 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
The message
from Java Jive contains these words:

I didn't think PDC was supported on DTT, only legacy analogue?


On Wed, 31 Dec 2008 09:35:02 -0000, "Bill Ridgeway"
wrote:

There is a piece of technology called Programme Delivery Control (PDC)
which, with appropriate recorders, start and stop recording on
transmission
of the programme. This is available on BBC1, BBC2 (and others?) and
Channel
5 but not ITV1 or Channel 4 (This is not definitive!).


I too get all 'vexed' by the scheduling tw*ts at the Beeb when they
pull such stunning c*nts with the scheduling (and it isn't only due to
program over-runs, they also have a knack of playing 'shuffle the deck'
with regular weekly programs - as noted by various viewers who wrote in
to complain to the Beeb's PoV program a few weeks back).

However, such shenanagins will soon become rather academic once hard
disk space gets even cheaper and the whole day's worth of programming
gets dumped to disk as a matter of routine. After all, it's no more work
to 'top and tail' individual program segments from a 16 hour or so's
worth of capture than it is, currently, to do from a 4 or 5 hour
capture.

The BBC don't seem to realise that such c*ntinuity behaviour and playing
fast and loose with the scheduling is eroding their esteem in the eyes
of the TV viewing public. Eventually, the 'Bean Counters' will reduce
the BBC to being _only_ a playout centre with no added value whatsover
to mark them above the level of a cable TV shopping channel.

With the way the broadcasters are behaving right now and for the
forseeable future, there's definitely a market for an intelligent "PVR"
whereby, with a bit of AI and a 6 (or even 24) hour disk buffer per
channel of interest, it will become possible to make such 'dirty tricks'
by both the BBC and commercial broadcasters totally irreleveant to the
viewer's endpoint experience.

Year on year, it gets cheaper and cheaper to build a PC based PVR using
Open Source Software, such as Myth TV (Linux based). Although it would
seem the government and commercial entities are having it all their own
way regarding the use of technology to control and restrict what the
'governed' can and cannot do, such open source projects offer the
possibility to turn the tables and allow us to keep track of whatever
government promises have been made (readily accessable News program
archiving) and filter the 'Spam' out of both public and commercial
broadcasting.

Considering the above paragraph, this sort of application may well be
"_The_ Killer App" that 'buries microsoft' and lets loose, upon the
world's consciousness, the opensource operating system known as Linux.
;-)

Never mind the "Solution Looking For A Problem" type of software
application, here is a superlative example of a (worldwide) problem
demanding a solution to drive the development of such an open source
software project (and then some). Forget the TiVo, that was a mere
harbinger of what is to come.

If you're a broadcasting company, be worried, be very worried
(especially if you're a commercial broadcaster - be _very_ _very_
worried). The very technology that helps you diseminate your 'wares' on
the cheap is going to make you reconsider the viability of your very
existence.

For the rest us, remember, "Revenge Is A Dish, Best Served Cold". Next
time such broadcast nonsense starts raising your blood pressure, relax
and keep in mind that your next open source based "Myth TV on steroids"
PVR is going to render such irritation a thing of the past (and probably
free up some precious bandwidth in the process ;-).

--
Regards, John.

Please remove the "ohggcyht" before replying.
The address has been munged to reject Spam-bots.


J G Miller[_4_] December 31st 08 09:02 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
On Wed, 31 Dec 2008 17:33:00 +0000, Johnny B Good wrote:

Eventually, the 'Bean Counters' will reduce the BBC to being _only_ a
playout centre


That is done for them by Red Bee is it not?

(Except for playout of regional programs in Northern Ireland, Scotland,
and Wales I think.)

Mike O'Sullivan December 31st 08 09:04 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Bill Ridgeway wrote:

There is a piece of technology called Programme Delivery Control (PDC)
which, with appropriate recorders, start and stop recording on transmission
of the programme. This is available on BBC1, BBC2 (and others?) and Channel
5 but not ITV1 or Channel 4 (This is not definitive!).


Only works on analogue transmissions doesn't it?

I found it to be unreliable and gave up using it.

Roderick Stewart[_2_] December 31st 08 09:36 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
In article , Johnny B Good
wrote:
With the way the broadcasters are behaving right now and for the
forseeable future, there's definitely a market for an intelligent "PVR"


Agreed, but in the meantime, a stupid PVR with an intelligent user is
good enough.

Rod.
--
Virtual Access V6.3 free usenet/email software from
http://sourceforge.net/projects/virtual-access/


tony sayer December 31st 08 10:36 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
In article , Jay [email protected]
ospam.org scribeth thus

"Woody" wrote in message
...
"Mike O'Sullivan" wrote in message
...
Jay wrote:
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line
with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the
year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its
own
ship in order when it comes to timing?. On Christmas Day 2008 the
'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost
every
programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6 minutes.
Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at their disposal
to
time programmes these days!

Absolutely agree. There is nothing that infuriates me more about the
BBC.




Actually it is nothing to do with the BBC.


Nobody said it was anything to do with the BBC. I just said that the BBC
had reported the story on BBC News. Who said anything about it being
anything to do with the BBC?

What is the BBC's fault is the lack of time keeping on its TV channels.




Perhaps they ought to alter the rotational speed of old mutter earth;!..
--
Tony Sayer




Johnny B Good December 31st 08 10:41 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
The message en.co.uk
from Roderick Stewart
contains these words:

In article , Johnny B Good
wrote:
With the way the broadcasters are behaving right now and for the
forseeable future, there's definitely a market for an intelligent "PVR"


Agreed, but in the meantime, a stupid PVR with an intelligent user is
good enough.


I agree, but us 'intelligent users' are rather outnumbered by those who
would expect the technology to do the 'Donkeywork' for them. Me, I'm
hoping someone with even more acumen would fulfil their hopes and
dreams. ;-)

--
Regards, John.

Please remove the "ohggcyht" before replying.
The address has been munged to reject Spam-bots.


kim December 31st 08 10:48 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Light of Aria wrote:

One imagines these sorts as the SS/Gestapo of the BBC regime, going
around in distinctive black uniforms with peaked caps and red BBC
swastika logos on their arms.

Your loyalty to the BBC Reich is in doubt: Your name vil go on ze
list.


"Name?"

"Don't tell him Pike!"

(kim)



kim December 31st 08 10:55 PM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Brian W wrote:
"Jay" wrote in message
...
I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line
with global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end
of the year tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot
seem to get its own ship in order when it comes to timing?. On
Christmas Day 2008 the 'BBC One'
schedule ran 7 minutes 21 seconds late, which resulted in almost
every programme being recorded that night, missing the last 5 or 6
minutes. Pathetic when you consider the technology they have at
their disposal to time programmes these days!

Strange. I managed to record 'Doctor Who' on my PC (with a manual
tuner setting - no EPG auto-updating) and didn't miss the end. I
added two minutes of padding and this was more than enough.


"Doctor Who: Confidential" started on BBC3 before "Doctor Who" had finished
on BBC1. If you had used the digital programme guide to set a timer you
would have missed the end of Doctor Who.

(kim)



Max Demian January 1st 09 01:26 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
"Mike O'Sullivan" wrote in message
...
Bill Ridgeway wrote:
There is a piece of technology called Programme Delivery Control (PDC)
which, with appropriate recorders, start and stop recording on
transmission of the programme. This is available on BBC1, BBC2 (and
others?) and Channel 5 but not ITV1 or Channel 4 (This is not
definitive!).


Only works on analogue transmissions doesn't it?


There's an equivalent available on Freeview as part of the Freeview+
recorder spec (e.g. Humax PVR-9200T with up to date software). It works
reasonably well, though it misses out the first and/or last 30 seconds or so
of programmes sometimes. I doesn't seem to miss programmes altogether like
PDC (mainly BBC).



Max Demian January 1st 09 01:39 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
"Peter Duncanson" wrote in message
...
On Wed, 31 Dec 2008 13:20:48 +0000, Grimly Curmudgeon
wrote:

We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the
drugs began to take hold. I remember "Jay"
saying something like:

I see the BBC has got hold of the fact that to bring UK time in line with
global timing, we are to have an extra second added to the end of the
year
tonight (New Years Eve). What a pity the BBC cannot seem to get its own
ship in order when it comes to timing?.


I must admit my ears perked up when I heard the Sky News bimbo announce
that "... the Earth has been turning slower than usual this year."

Followed at this end by gales of laughter.


Yes! As the Wikipedia article says:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leap_second

the rotation of Earth slows down continually, though at a slightly
variable rate.

Whether or not 2008 was a particularly slow (or less slow) year that is
not
the reason for the leap second.


The BBC have got it rather wrong here
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/7797818.stm by muddling solar and
sidereal days up:

"For thousands of years the definition of a day was easy enough: the length
of time it takes for a full rotation of the Earth around its axis.

"Since ancient times, clocks of various descriptions have helped us keep
track.

"But recently, clocks have become so accurate that it has emerged that the
Earth's rotation can take slightly longer or shorter than 24 hours."

Well the time taken for a full rotation of the earth on its axis is about 23
hours 56 minutes, never 24 hours.

--
Max Demian



[email protected] January 1st 09 05:03 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
Ian Jackson wrote:
For those bringing in the New Year when watching digital TV or radio,
the magic stroke of midnight will already be around a second too late.
Should they start Ould Lang Syne on the 6th pip of the time signal?
This, of course, is normally the last, long pip. However, on this
occasion, it will be short, being the penultimate of 7 pips.


Which radio station broadcasts the pips and Old Lang Syne at the
beginning of a new year?

Kennedy McEwen January 1st 09 07:02 AM

BBC News report: extra second of time
 
In article , tony sayer
writes

Perhaps they ought to alter the rotational speed of old mutter earth;!..


"On the third stroke - JUMP"

Well it works for 1Bn Chinese! ;-)
--
Kennedy
Yes, Socrates himself is particularly missed;
A lovely little thinker, but a bugger when he's ****ed.
Python Philosophers (replace 'nospam' with 'kennedym' when replying)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:14 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com