HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   UK digital tv (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   10ft mast on 12" bracket (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=59278)

Marky P July 2nd 08 12:10 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Would this be an unstable set up:

Blake SR18 element group b
Triax 10 element group C/D
10'x2" mast
12" cradle bracket

I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".

Marky P.


Ivan July 2nd 08 12:13 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Marky P wrote:
|| Would this be an unstable set up:
||
|| Blake SR18 element group b
|| Triax 10 element group C/D
|| 10'x2" mast
|| 12" cradle bracket
||
|| I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
|| aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
|| idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
|| be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
|| 18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
|| think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".
||

Freesat?

|| Marky P.

Bill Wright July 2nd 08 02:55 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Marky P" wrote in message
...
Would this be an unstable set up:

Blake SR18 element group b
Triax 10 element group C/D
10'x2" mast
12" cradle bracket

I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".


Are you sure the mast is 10ft x 2"? That's an unusual size. Could it be 12ft
x 2"? Anyway, I'd think twice before putting a ten foot mast with two
aerials on a single lashing wire.

Bill



Paul D.Smith July 2nd 08 09:41 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Marky P wrote:
|| Would this be an unstable set up:
|| || Blake SR18 element group b
|| Triax 10 element group C/D
|| 10'x2" mast
|| 12" cradle bracket
|| || I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
|| aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
|| idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
|| be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
|| 18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
|| think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".
||
Freesat?

|| Marky P.


Freesat is an interesting thought as the expense of your components must be
starting to get up to the cost of a Freesat setup. Or even, perhaps, the
Sky FTA offering i.e. getting someone else to put the dish up for him ;-).
I did hear of cheap deals from Currys/Dixons. If you make sure the dish is
in a good place, and he gets one of the multi-head LNBs, then next time
you're down there you can wire up some extra cables for him and he gets 4
output (2 for PVR plus two bedrooms perhaps?).

Paul DS


Glenn Millar July 2nd 08 09:46 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Marky P wrote:
Would this be an unstable set up:

Blake SR18 element group b
Triax 10 element group C/D
10'x2" mast
12" cradle bracket

I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".

Marky P.

http://www.vanjak.com/images/super2/CBG-09.htm

The above is the bracket I use every day with 10' x 2" Aluminium masts.

Glenn...

Glenn Millar July 2nd 08 09:47 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Glenn Millar wrote:
Marky P wrote:
Would this be an unstable set up:

Blake SR18 element group b
Triax 10 element group C/D
10'x2" mast
12" cradle bracket

I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".

Marky P.

http://www.vanjak.com/images/super2/CBG-09.htm

The above is the bracket I use every day with 10' x 2" Aluminium masts.

Glenn...


Should have added, it's a 14" bracket.

Brian Gaff July 2nd 08 09:54 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Heck of a lot of leverage in a ten foot mast. Might sway a bit in a gale
and gradually work bracket loose even if its soundly fixed.

Mind you, I'm on top of a hill!

Brian

--
Brian Gaff....Note, this account does not accept Bcc: email.
graphics are great, but the blind can't hear them
Email:
__________________________________________________ __________________________________________________ __________


"Marky P" wrote in message
...
Would this be an unstable set up:

Blake SR18 element group b
Triax 10 element group C/D
10'x2" mast
12" cradle bracket

I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".

Marky P.




tony sayer July 2nd 08 12:04 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
In article , Paul D.Smith
scribeth thus
"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Marky P wrote:
|| Would this be an unstable set up:
|| || Blake SR18 element group b
|| Triax 10 element group C/D
|| 10'x2" mast
|| 12" cradle bracket
|| || I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
|| aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
|| idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
|| be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
|| 18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
|| think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".
||
Freesat?

|| Marky P.


Freesat is an interesting thought as the expense of your components must be
starting to get up to the cost of a Freesat setup. Or even, perhaps, the
Sky FTA offering i.e. getting someone else to put the dish up for him ;-).
I did hear of cheap deals from Currys/Dixons. If you make sure the dish is
in a good place, and he gets one of the multi-head LNBs, then next time
you're down there you can wire up some extra cables for him and he gets 4
output (2 for PVR plus two bedrooms perhaps?).

Paul DS


Theres no fun in that;).

Waaay too sensible....
--
Tony Sayer





Carpy July 2nd 08 12:34 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Marky P" wrote in message
...
Would this be an unstable set up:

Blake SR18 element group b
Triax 10 element group C/D
10'x2" mast
12" cradle bracket

I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".

Marky P.


As far as I'm aware Mr P, there's no readily available 12" cradle bracket.
It's either 8" or 13.5".

Assuming you've got the 13.5" then I wouldn't worry about it too much. Yes
it would be better to have 2 straps around the chimney and a nice space
inbetween, but if this can't be easily done then I wouldn't worry about it.

Just make sure the chimney is in good condition and the strap is nice and
tight.

Here's a 13.5" cradle with a 10ft mast and a few aerials on it. This mast is
actually 1.5" diameter.

http://img392.imageshack.us/img392/3936/markyge3.jpg

I've noticed lately that there are "new" cheaper 13.5" galvanised cradle
brackets available. They are about 30% cheaper than the normal ones, but the
metal is much slimmer and they feel terribly flimsy. I ordered a load by
mistake without realising.

I also noticed the same has happened to non penetrating roof mounts. I
sometimes use the 2" version (450m slabs), and used to pay about £100 for
it. Then they changed the price down to about £45. Everything else looked
the same so I ordered one for a job, but when it arrived it wasn't great.
They have cut out lots of metal from all over, and it now weighs half of the
old one and it can't support an aerial properly now as much of the metal has
been removed from the centre part with the mast coming up.

I complained and was told the older version wasn't available and the new one
was just as good! I now have to order the "older" version (much better
version) directly from Blake UK.



Bill Wright July 2nd 08 03:45 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Glenn Millar" wrote in message
...
http://www.vanjak.com/images/super2/CBG-09.htm

The above is the bracket I use every day with 10' x 2" Aluminium masts.


Glenn, I admit that I'm over cautious.

Bill



Bill Wright July 2nd 08 03:53 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Carpy" wrote in message
...
http://img392.imageshack.us/img392/3936/markyge3.jpg

I know I'm over cautious, and I'm sure that the job in your picture is just
fine, but I personally would never put that installation on one lashing
wire. I know, I know! It's me.

I also noticed the same has happened to non penetrating roof mounts. I
sometimes use the 2" version (450m slabs), and used to pay about £100 for
it. Then they changed the price down to about £45. Everything else looked
the same so I ordered one for a job, but when it arrived it wasn't great.
They have cut out lots of metal from all over, and it now weighs half of
the old one and it can't support an aerial properly now as much of the
metal has been removed from the centre part with the mast coming up.

I complained and was told the older version wasn't available and the new
one was just as good! I now have to order the "older" version (much better
version) directly from Blake UK.

I spent some time at the show talking to ISS of Leeds who make these items
for Sat Sol. The product range is VG. Have a look.

Anyway, next year I'm going to twist the arms of a few people on here to
come to the show.

Bill



Ivan July 2nd 08 04:34 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Bill Wright wrote:
|| "Carpy" wrote in message
|| ...
||| http://img392.imageshack.us/img392/3936/markyge3.jpg
|||
|| I know I'm over cautious, and I'm sure that the job in your picture
|| is just fine, but I personally would never put that installation on
|| one lashing wire. I know, I know! It's me.
||
||| I also noticed the same has happened to non penetrating roof
||| mounts. I sometimes use the 2" version (450m slabs), and used to
||| pay about £100 for it. Then they changed the price down to about
||| £45. Everything else looked the same so I ordered one for a job,
||| but when it arrived it wasn't great. They have cut out lots of
||| metal from all over, and it now weighs half of the old one and it
||| can't support an aerial properly now as much of the metal has been
||| removed from the centre part with the mast coming up.
|||
||| I complained and was told the older version wasn't available and
||| the new one was just as good! I now have to order the "older"
||| version (much better version) directly from Blake UK.
|| I spent some time at the show talking to ISS of Leeds who make these
|| items for Sat Sol. The product range is VG. Have a look.
||
|| Anyway, next year I'm going to twist the arms of a few people on
|| here to come to the show.
||

Provided that the lashing wire is of good quality then they're probably
won't be any reason for it to let go, I still see heavy duty galvanised
chimney brackets dating back around 50 years which were fitted by
Rediffusion to carry some pretty weighty catenaries across busy main roads,
the lashing wire on those consisted of stranded phosphorus bronze.

|| Bill


Ivan July 2nd 08 04:46 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 



Sorry I omitted to trim Bills post, so it wasn't obvious exactly what part
of it I was replying to.. error corrected.
Ivan

||
|| Bill Wright wrote:
|||| "Carpy" wrote in message
|||| ...
||||| http://img392.imageshack.us/img392/3936/markyge3.jpg
|||||
|||| I know I'm over cautious, and I'm sure that the job in your picture
|||| is just fine, but I personally would never put that installation on
|||| one lashing wire. I know, I know! It's me.
||||


|| Provided that the lashing wire is of good quality then there
|| probably won't be any reason for it to let go, I still see heavy
|| duty galvanised chimney brackets dating back around 50 years which
|| were fitted by Rediffusion to carry some pretty weighty catenaries
|| across busy main roads, the lashing wire on those consisted of
|| stranded phosphorus bronze.
||


Bill Wright July 2nd 08 08:18 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Provided that the lashing wire is of good quality then they're probably
won't be any reason for it to let go, I still see heavy duty galvanised
chimney brackets dating back around 50 years which were fitted by
Rediffusion to carry some pretty weighty catenaries across busy main
roads, the lashing wire on those consisted of stranded phosphorus bronze.


Yes, I've had to cut a few of them down. . .

Modern lash wire is, of course, a poor thing by comparision. My worries,
though, are usually about the stresses on the masonry than the strength of
the wire. I must say, again, that I know I'm overcautious about this.

Bill



Ivan July 3rd 08 12:17 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Bill Wright wrote:
|| "Ivan" wrote in message
|| ...
||| Provided that the lashing wire is of good quality then they're
||| probably won't be any reason for it to let go, I still see heavy
||| duty galvanised chimney brackets dating back around 50 years which
||| were fitted by Rediffusion to carry some pretty weighty catenaries
||| across busy main roads, the lashing wire on those consisted of
||| stranded phosphorus bronze.
||
|| Yes, I've had to cut a few of them down. . .
||
|| Modern lash wire is, of course, a poor thing by comparision. My
|| worries, though, are usually about the stresses on the masonry than
|| the strength of the wire. I must say, again, that I know I'm
|| overcautious about this.
||
|| Bill

You're right to be so Bill, there were many old neglected and bomb damaged
Victorian buildings in the postwar inner cities and those aforementioned
'weighty catenaries' usually required the efforts of a couple of blokes on
each end pulling them as taught as they could and then making off the
stainless steel support wire onto the J bolts.
In one instance I can recall despite the J bolts being tightened at both
ends no noticeable increase in tautness could be seen, the reason for this
soon became apparent when it was noticed that one of the stacks was starting
to lean forward at a precarious angle, needless to say that the J bolts were
quickly slackened and the stack eased back into its original position!

|


Marky P July 3rd 08 12:29 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
On Wed, 2 Jul 2008 11:04:44 +0100, tony sayer
wrote:

In article , Paul D.Smith
scribeth thus
"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Marky P wrote:
|| Would this be an unstable set up:
|| || Blake SR18 element group b
|| Triax 10 element group C/D
|| 10'x2" mast
|| 12" cradle bracket
|| || I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
|| aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
|| idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
|| be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
|| 18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
|| think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".
||
Freesat?

|| Marky P.


Freesat is an interesting thought as the expense of your components must be
starting to get up to the cost of a Freesat setup. Or even, perhaps, the
Sky FTA offering i.e. getting someone else to put the dish up for him ;-).
I did hear of cheap deals from Currys/Dixons. If you make sure the dish is
in a good place, and he gets one of the multi-head LNBs, then next time
you're down there you can wire up some extra cables for him and he gets 4
output (2 for PVR plus two bedrooms perhaps?).

Paul DS


Theres no fun in that;).

Waaay too sensible....


Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.

Marky P.


Marky P July 3rd 08 12:34 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 


As far as I'm aware Mr P, there's no readily available 12" cradle bracket.
It's either 8" or 13.5".


Actually you're right. It is a 13.5" bracket. Got it from CPC. At
the time, I didn't know if the chimney was tall enough for an 18"
bracket, so I went for the next size down.

Marky P.


- July 3rd 08 02:09 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Bill Wright" wrote in message
...

"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Provided that the lashing wire is of good quality then they're probably
won't be any reason for it to let go, I still see heavy duty galvanised
chimney brackets dating back around 50 years which were fitted by
Rediffusion to carry some pretty weighty catenaries across busy main
roads, the lashing wire on those consisted of stranded phosphorus bronze.


Yes, I've had to cut a few of them down. . .

Modern lash wire is, of course, a poor thing by comparision. My worries,
though, are usually about the stresses on the masonry than the strength of
the wire. I must say, again, that I know I'm overcautious about this.

Bill


The way I see it is that if the same bracket / lashing was only supporting a
small 10 element aerial on the same 10ft mast, then I wouldn't do the
lashing kit any looser, so really the compressional stress (which I believe
is the more relevant one) on the chimney is the same for either rig.

If you look at the bracket as a kind of dual cantilever beam with virtually
no deflection, then having 3 smallish aerials instead of 1 adds so little to
the imposed load that it won't have any worthwhile bearing on the moment
applied to the bracket (beam).

The wind loading will be increased a fair bit, but it could never really
impose enough force on the chimney to matter. The mast will always be the
weakest link and must resist constantly going from tension to compression,
so a nice lightweight aerial such as a log is a good choice if possible.
Obviously the higher up the pole the aerial goes the more magnified the
force becomes as force = load x distance..

The Sky dish adds a small load but in that position relative to the bracket
it's irrelevant.

So really for me, with a bracket like this, the only relevant things are the
horizontal compression stresses on the chimney, and a mast that is plenty
strong enough yet will flex sufficiently to prevent transferring too much to
the chimney, and not be so thick that it becomes overly heavy and places a
much larger load on the bracket.

We always used to design structures with a safety factor of 3. That is, work
out the maximum theoretical load that could ever possibly be imposed and
design the building / structure to take three times that load. I'm confident
that a bracket / chimney like the one above has a much much larger safety
factor.

All this could of course be complete ********, as it's been quite a few
years since I've done anything remotely useful in the Civil / Structural
engineering scene, but I still maintain a good "eye" for what's acceptable
and what's not, although these days it's more down to judgement than
calculation.



Bill (Adopt) July 3rd 08 09:22 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
In article ,
Bill Wright wrote:

"Ivan" wrote in message
...
You're right to be so Bill, there were many old neglected and bomb damaged
Victorian buildings in the postwar inner cities and those aforementioned


with it. This was a fortunate because the damage caused by a hundredweight
of soot landing in the living room was considerable.


We forget these days about soot. I used to come home covered in the stuff,
and I could never get it out of my pores.


Good detoxing agent? ..or early toner refill
as it's mostly carbon. With white lips and a
banjo fashioned from aerial wires, you must
have been made around the clubs.. ;'))

Bill ZFC

--
Adoption InterLink UK with -=- http://www.billsimpson.com/
Domain Host Orpheus Internet -=- http://www.orpheusinternet.co.uk/

Paul D.Smith July 3rd 08 10:15 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
....snip...

Freesat is an interesting thought as the expense of your components must
be
starting to get up to the cost of a Freesat setup. Or even, perhaps, the
Sky FTA offering i.e. getting someone else to put the dish up for him
;-).
I did hear of cheap deals from Currys/Dixons. If you make sure the dish
is
in a good place, and he gets one of the multi-head LNBs, then next time
you're down there you can wire up some extra cables for him and he gets 4
output (2 for PVR plus two bedrooms perhaps?).

Paul DS


Theres no fun in that;).

Waaay too sensible....


Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.

Marky P.


I suppose the cost does go up for each Freesat box purchased, which I hadn't
allowed for. Question is will your friend wait until SD Freesat boxes are
10-a-penny or does he want all his TVs NOW! But then I add up "PVR + 3
others = 5" - bother, one more than a quad LNB can handle.

How often does your friend have multiple TVs on watching multiple things?
What about somehow driving the other TVs from the Freesat box? Or perhaps
he needs a full blown "hotel" like distribution system.

All getting too complicated now ;-) Good luck with the aerial.

Paul DS.


tony sayer July 3rd 08 11:29 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
In article , Marky P
scribeth thus
On Wed, 2 Jul 2008 11:04:44 +0100, tony sayer
wrote:

In article , Paul D.Smith
scribeth thus
"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Marky P wrote:
|| Would this be an unstable set up:
|| || Blake SR18 element group b
|| Triax 10 element group C/D
|| 10'x2" mast
|| 12" cradle bracket
|| || I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
|| aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
|| idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
|| be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
|| 18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
|| think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".
||
Freesat?

|| Marky P.

Freesat is an interesting thought as the expense of your components must be
starting to get up to the cost of a Freesat setup. Or even, perhaps, the
Sky FTA offering i.e. getting someone else to put the dish up for him ;-).
I did hear of cheap deals from Currys/Dixons. If you make sure the dish is
in a good place, and he gets one of the multi-head LNBs, then next time
you're down there you can wire up some extra cables for him and he gets 4
output (2 for PVR plus two bedrooms perhaps?).

Paul DS


Theres no fun in that;).

Waaay too sensible....


Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.

Marky P.

Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
satellite?..
--
Tony Sayer



Andy Wade July 3rd 08 01:16 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
tony sayer wrote:

Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.


Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
satellite?..


If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've heard
talk of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4 is the usual
limit, with a multiswitch being needed after that - or a real move to
the single-cable ('SCR') technology.

--
Andy

Ivan July 3rd 08 01:29 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Andy Wade wrote:
|| tony sayer wrote:
||
|||| Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview
|||| for the other 3 tellies.
||
||| Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
||| satellite?..
||
|| If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've heard
|| talk of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4 is the usual
|| limit, with a multiswitch being needed after that - or a real move to
|| the single-cable ('SCR') technology.
||

Technomate TM8

|| --
|| Andy

Ivan July 3rd 08 01:41 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Ivan wrote:
|| Andy Wade wrote:
|||| tony sayer wrote:
||||
|||||| Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview
|||||| for the other 3 tellies.
||||
||||| Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
||||| satellite?..
||||
|||| If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've
|||| heard talk of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4 is
|||| the usual limit, with a multiswitch being needed after that - or a
|||| real move to the single-cable ('SCR') technology.
||||
||
|| Technomate TM8
||

Or the Wistron Sky Octo LNB

http://www.brittany-satellites.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=211

|||| --
|||| Andy


Steve Terry[_2_] July 3rd 08 04:23 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"tony sayer" wrote in message
...
In article , Marky P
scribeth thus
On Wed, 2 Jul 2008 11:04:44 +0100, tony sayer
wrote:

In article , Paul D.Smith
scribeth thus
"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Marky P wrote:

snip
Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.
Marky P.

Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
satellite?..
Tony Sayer


That's what i would do, (have done before) Stick a 4 output LNB
on the dish and feed it to 4 used SKY STBs.

Much more future proofed too
28 east is going to carry far more FTA than DVB-T ever will

Steve Terry



Steve Terry[_2_] July 3rd 08 04:27 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Andy Wade" wrote in message
...
tony sayer wrote:

Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.


Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
satellite?..


If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've heard talk
of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4 is the usual limit,
with a multiswitch being needed after that - or a real move to the
single-cable ('SCR') technology.
Andy


Dishes and quad LNBs are cheap enough without looking for more,
or feeding an expensive distribution system.

Just stick a second dish up with another quad LNB.
another 30quid, tops.

Steve Terry



Steve Terry[_2_] July 3rd 08 04:29 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Ivan wrote:
|| Andy Wade wrote:
|||| tony sayer wrote:
||||
|||||| Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview
|||||| for the other 3 tellies.
||||
||||| Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
||||| satellite?..
||||
|||| If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've
|||| heard talk of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4 is
|||| the usual limit, with a multiswitch being needed after that - or a
|||| real move to the single-cable ('SCR') technology.
||||
||
|| Technomate TM8
||

Or the Wistron Sky Octo LNB

http://www.brittany-satellites.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=211


75quid!
Another dish and quad LNB = 30quid
But it is a solution if you aren't allowed to install another dish.

Steve Terry






Ivan July 3rd 08 06:48 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Steve Terry wrote:
|| "Ivan" wrote in message
|| ...
||| Ivan wrote:
||||| Andy Wade wrote:
||||||| tony sayer wrote:
|||||||
||||||||| Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need
||||||||| Freeview for the other 3 tellies.
|||||||
|||||||| Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
|||||||| satellite?..
|||||||
||||||| If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've
||||||| heard talk of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4
||||||| is the usual limit, with a multiswitch being needed after that
||||||| - or a real move to the single-cable ('SCR') technology.
|||||||
|||||
||||| Technomate TM8
|||||
|||
||| Or the Wistron Sky Octo LNB
|||
|||
http://www.brittany-satellites.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=211
|||
|||
|| 75quid!
|| Another dish and quad LNB = 30quid
|| But it is a solution if you aren't allowed to install another dish.
||

IMO it wouldn't be right for others on this newsgroup [who after all have to
try and make a living] for me to quote a trade price, however IIRC from
previous posts long past I believe that Marky P. had some kind of access to
a trade outlet?.. if so then I think he won't be too unhappy with the price.


|| Steve Terry


tony sayer July 3rd 08 08:40 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
In article , Steve Terry
scribeth thus

"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Ivan wrote:
|| Andy Wade wrote:
|||| tony sayer wrote:
||||
|||||| Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview
|||||| for the other 3 tellies.
||||
||||| Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
||||| satellite?..
||||
|||| If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've
|||| heard talk of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4 is
|||| the usual limit, with a multiswitch being needed after that - or a
|||| real move to the single-cable ('SCR') technology.
||||
||
|| Technomate TM8
||

Or the Wistron Sky Octo LNB

http://www.brittany-satellites.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=211


75quid!
Another dish and quad LNB = 30quid
But it is a solution if you aren't allowed to install another dish.

Steve Terry





I do believe they are available for less then that...
--
Tony Sayer



Marky P July 4th 08 12:56 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
On Thu, 3 Jul 2008 09:15:15 +0100, "Paul D.Smith"
wrote:

...snip...

Freesat is an interesting thought as the expense of your components must
be
starting to get up to the cost of a Freesat setup. Or even, perhaps, the
Sky FTA offering i.e. getting someone else to put the dish up for him
;-).
I did hear of cheap deals from Currys/Dixons. If you make sure the dish
is
in a good place, and he gets one of the multi-head LNBs, then next time
you're down there you can wire up some extra cables for him and he gets 4
output (2 for PVR plus two bedrooms perhaps?).

Paul DS


Theres no fun in that;).

Waaay too sensible....


Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.

Marky P.


I suppose the cost does go up for each Freesat box purchased, which I hadn't
allowed for. Question is will your friend wait until SD Freesat boxes are
10-a-penny or does he want all his TVs NOW! But then I add up "PVR + 3
others = 5" - bother, one more than a quad LNB can handle.

How often does your friend have multiple TVs on watching multiple things?
What about somehow driving the other TVs from the Freesat box? Or perhaps
he needs a full blown "hotel" like distribution system.

All getting too complicated now ;-) Good luck with the aerial.

Paul DS.


In the past year, my friend (and his wife) have only been to their
holiday home three times. They do rent it out, but only to friends
and that's not often. So the tellys aren't used a great deal. Got a
call last night from him saying that all Freeview channels are
breaking up now & he wants me to go down there next weekend and
install the new Blake aerial. I told him it might make no difference,
but I'm happy to do it.

Marky P.


Marky P July 4th 08 12:57 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
On Thu, 3 Jul 2008 10:29:07 +0100, tony sayer
wrote:

In article , Marky P
scribeth thus
On Wed, 2 Jul 2008 11:04:44 +0100, tony sayer
wrote:

In article , Paul D.Smith
scribeth thus
"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Marky P wrote:
|| Would this be an unstable set up:
|| || Blake SR18 element group b
|| Triax 10 element group C/D
|| 10'x2" mast
|| 12" cradle bracket
|| || I've just had a word with my friend about the replacement of his
|| aerial down in Devon and he thought a higher mast would be a good
|| idea, due to the flats being built in the line of fire. But I would
|| be dubious about using a 10' mast with a 12" bracket. Changing to an
|| 18" bracket would be loads of hassle (and extra expense) and I don't
|| think it's worth it. What d'ya reckon? Current mast is 6'x2".
||
Freesat?

|| Marky P.

Freesat is an interesting thought as the expense of your components must be
starting to get up to the cost of a Freesat setup. Or even, perhaps, the
Sky FTA offering i.e. getting someone else to put the dish up for him ;-).
I did hear of cheap deals from Currys/Dixons. If you make sure the dish is
in a good place, and he gets one of the multi-head LNBs, then next time
you're down there you can wire up some extra cables for him and he gets 4
output (2 for PVR plus two bedrooms perhaps?).

Paul DS


Theres no fun in that;).

Waaay too sensible....


Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need Freeview for
the other 3 tellies.

Marky P.

Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
satellite?..


I'll suggest it, but it's all extra boxes. I had to install all the
bedroom tellies on wall bracket and put all wiring through the walls
so nothing would show. It was a right bugger.

Marky P.


Marky P July 4th 08 12:59 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
On Thu, 3 Jul 2008 17:48:28 +0100, "Ivan"
wrote:

Steve Terry wrote:
|| "Ivan" wrote in message
|| ...
||| Ivan wrote:
||||| Andy Wade wrote:
||||||| tony sayer wrote:
|||||||
||||||||| Freesat is an option for the main telly, but still need
||||||||| Freeview for the other 3 tellies.
|||||||
|||||||| Why not use a multi output LNB and simply convert the whole to
|||||||| satellite?..
|||||||
||||||| If "main telly" includes a PVR he'll need a 5-output LNB. I've
||||||| heard talk of 6- or 8-o/p LNBs, but do they actually exist? 4
||||||| is the usual limit, with a multiswitch being needed after that
||||||| - or a real move to the single-cable ('SCR') technology.
|||||||
|||||
||||| Technomate TM8
|||||
|||
||| Or the Wistron Sky Octo LNB
|||
|||
http://www.brittany-satellites.com/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=211
|||
|||
|| 75quid!
|| Another dish and quad LNB = 30quid
|| But it is a solution if you aren't allowed to install another dish.
||

IMO it wouldn't be right for others on this newsgroup [who after all have to
try and make a living] for me to quote a trade price, however IIRC from
previous posts long past I believe that Marky P. had some kind of access to
a trade outlet?.. if so then I think he won't be too unhappy with the price.


|| Steve Terry


I have no access to a trade outlet :-(. Just a humble amateur, me.

Marky P.


Bill Wright July 4th 08 01:35 AM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Marky P" wrote in message
...
On Thu, 3 Jul 2008 17:48:28 +0100, "Ivan"
I have no access to a trade outlet :-(. Just a humble amateur, me.


Marky, most full time installers are amateurs, humble or otherwise. If you
walk into any trade outlet and offer to pay cash you will have no problem.

Bill



chunkyoldcortina July 4th 08 05:37 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Marky P wrote:

I have no access to a trade outlet :-(. Just a humble amateur, me.


Try Solutions Group in Northampton, just off the Bedford Road in Brackmills.

Marky P July 4th 08 05:49 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
On Fri, 04 Jul 2008 16:37:08 +0100, chunkyoldcortina
wrote:

Marky P wrote:

I have no access to a trade outlet :-(. Just a humble amateur, me.


Try Solutions Group in Northampton, just off the Bedford Road in Brackmills.


OK. Next time I'm up that way I'll pop in.

Marky P.


Bill Wright July 4th 08 08:11 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Marky P" wrote in message
...
On Fri, 04 Jul 2008 16:37:08 +0100, chunkyoldcortina
wrote:

Marky P wrote:

I have no access to a trade outlet :-(. Just a humble amateur, me.


Try Solutions Group in Northampton, just off the Bedford Road in
Brackmills.


OK. Next time I'm up that way I'll pop in.


Get your face tattooed and smoke a fag and they'll think you're a proper
aerial man.

Bill



Ivan July 6th 08 05:45 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
Alan Pemberton wrote:
|| Bill Wright wrote:
||
||| Marky, most full time installers are amateurs, humble or otherwise.
||| If you walk into any trade outlet and offer to pay cash you will
||| have no problem.
||
|| I once walked into Blakes and offered cash for one of their famous
|| log periodics but they wanted twice the price that CPC do them for.
|| It's the same with the plumbing trade counter down the road,
|| compared with Screwfix prices for the same thing. They can all smell
|| real tradesmen a mile off.
||

Although Alan even genuine tradesmen dealing with trade outlets can
sometimes find the same item being sold in supermarkets cheaper than they
can buy it at trade price.. long gone are the days of retail price
maintenance when one was 'guaranteed' of profit margin of 33.3%.

|| --
|| Alan Pemberton
|| Sheffield, South Yorkshire, England
|| To e-mail me directly, please visit
|| http://www.pembers.freeserve.co.uk/index.html#Mail-me


Andy Burns[_4_] July 6th 08 06:06 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 
On 06/07/2008 16:19, Alan Pemberton wrote:

I once walked into Blakes and offered cash


I had no problems with Blakes a couple of years back; I turned up and
they sold me LP/FM/DAB aerials, bracket, mast, amp and various outlet
plates, all at very favourable prices compared to the catalogue/website.

Bill Wright July 6th 08 10:02 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Ivan" wrote in message
...
Alan Pemberton wrote:
|| Bill Wright wrote:
||
||| Marky, most full time installers are amateurs, humble or otherwise.
||| If you walk into any trade outlet and offer to pay cash you will
||| have no problem.
||
|| I once walked into Blakes and offered cash for one of their famous
|| log periodics but they wanted twice the price that CPC do them for.
|| It's the same with the plumbing trade counter down the road,
|| compared with Screwfix prices for the same thing. They can all smell
|| real tradesmen a mile off.
||

Although Alan even genuine tradesmen dealing with trade outlets can
sometimes find the same item being sold in supermarkets cheaper than they
can buy it at trade price.. long gone are the days of retail price
maintenance when one was 'guaranteed' of profit margin of 33.3%.


Many years ago the situation arose that the small distribution amplifiers we
were fond of using became available at Wickes, at prices not dissimiliar to
the trade price. Now the problem is, if you install a dist. amp you are
automatically giving 12 month's on-site warranty (a free call out and
replacement) so my policy was to mark amps up by a huge margin. I actually
had customers ringing me complaining that the amp I had sold them was
available at much lower cost at Wickes. Now the fact is, Joe Public has
never understood about costs and overheads, and with some of them it's a
waste of breath telling them. They like to think that if they pay £150 for
an aerial installation the aerial cost £140 and the installation cost a
tenner (instead of the other way round in the case of some installers).

Ok, well Labgear (for it was they) are entitled to trade just how they like.
They'd figured that they could make more money by selling via Wickes than by
not doing so, and good luck to them. It's the same with filling stations
that hold up the diesel queue by selling lottery tickets at the same till.
It's their decision, but there are lots of other filling stations so if I'm
delayed by lottery customers I never, ever, return. Fair enough I think. So
I spoke to Labgear and suggested that they make some simple cosmetic changes
and took the Labgear name off the amps that they sold to Wickes. But no. So
that's when I stopped using Labgear amps. Haven't used one for 25 years now.
Must have cost them a fair bit, because I know I wasn't the only one.

Incidentally, when Antiference used to sell via Tandy they rebadged the
product and altered it slightly, which was fine.

Bill



Bill Wright July 6th 08 10:04 PM

10ft mast on 12" bracket
 

"Andy Burns" wrote in message
et...
On 06/07/2008 16:19, Alan Pemberton wrote:

I once walked into Blakes and offered cash


I had no problems with Blakes a couple of years back; I turned up and they
sold me LP/FM/DAB aerials, bracket, mast, amp and various outlet plates,
all at very favourable prices compared to the catalogue/website.


I've used wholesalers when I've been short of gear in places away from base,
and I've never had the slightest problem. On one occasion someone asked,
"Are you in the trade?" and I said, "Well as it happens yes but I'm paying
by card anyway" and that was that.

Bill




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:44 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com