HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   High definition TV (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts? (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=52583)

[email protected] August 4th 07 01:31 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
normal.

Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
don't have to worry about a dropout.

Stan


Captain Midnight August 4th 07 02:19 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote in message
ups.com...
I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
normal.

Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
don't have to worry about a dropout.

Stan


http://www.hdtvprimer.com/ANTENNAS/fixes.html



Alan F August 4th 07 02:45 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote:
I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
normal.

Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
don't have to worry about a dropout.

Stan


Yes, there is such a thing as no or almost no dropouts. I rarely get
dropouts for the strong signal stations. Only the more distant marginal
stations have occasional dropouts and that is typically in poor weather.

Drop puts such as you describe can be due to multipath or a marginal
signal. What does you tuner signal meter show when you have dropouts?
The signal meters can be a % from 0 to 100 or some variant of a series
of bars. Do the signal meter jump over a wide range? Is the antenna
indoors, in the attic, or outside? Another possibility - do you live
near an airport or is the antenna aimed pass an airport?

If you want help, please provide the antenna model #, your zip code, and
what you are using as an ATSC tuner as a starting point.

Alan F




[email protected] August 4th 07 02:46 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
"Elmo P. Shagnasty" wrote:
In article . com,
wrote:

I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
normal.


Oh, but it's DIGITAL quality!

snicker


Dont' listen to Elmo, he's a troll.

I suspect your signal is too strong and is overloading
your tuner. You may need to attenuate the signal.

Chip

--
--------------------
http://NewsReader.Com/ --------------------
Usenet Newsgroup Service $9.95/Month 30GB

[email protected] August 4th 07 03:24 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Fri, 03 Aug 2007 16:31:48 -0700 wrote:

| I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
| about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
| matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
| picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
| normal.
|
| Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
| don't have to worry about a dropout.

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.

--
|---------------------------------------/----------------------------------|
| Phil Howard KA9WGN (ka9wgn.ham.org) / Do not send to the address below |
| first name lower case at ipal.net /
|
|------------------------------------/-------------------------------------|

Matthew L. Martin August 4th 07 04:11 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote:
On Fri, 03 Aug 2007 16:31:48 -0700
wrote:

| I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
| about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
| matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
| picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
| normal.
|
| Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
| don't have to worry about a dropout.

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.


The only loose connection involved is likely that between your pea brain
and your typing fingers. I don't think I've seen a connection between
the two, ever, you ignorant, self centered, hypocritical blow hard.

Matthew

--
I'm a consultant. If you want an opinion I'll sell you one.
Which one do you want?

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from
http://www.teranews.com


common_ [email protected] August 4th 07 04:57 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote:

On Fri, 03 Aug 2007 16:31:48 -0700
wrote:

| I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
| about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
| matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
| picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
| normal.
|
| Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
| don't have to worry about a dropout.

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.

--
|---------------------------------------/----------------------------------|
| Phil Howard KA9WGN (ka9wgn.ham.org) / Do not send to the address below |
| first name lower case at ipal.net /
|
|------------------------------------/-------------------------------------|


That or a tree in the way?

I have zero problems with any kind of drop outs on my setup.

If you have this issue on all stations, then its some global problem
such as a bad connection, or something getting in the way of the
signal.

Bruce Tomlin August 4th 07 07:13 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
In article ,
wrote:

I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
normal.


I suspect your signal is too strong and is overloading
your tuner. You may need to attenuate the signal.


As someone who also lives "too close" to the transmitter farm, and with
an old tuner, I have to agree. One of the local analog stations here (on
ch 7) has a horrible ghosting problem, so it is reasonable to assume
that multipath problems are also happening on digital.

I have to aim my outdoor antenna very precisely to get every channel to
tune in well, and there are still times when one channel gets dropouts.
Meanwhile, in another room, a crappy FM dipole indoor antenna gets good
results, except for one local station which is consistently low
strength, not just dropping out.

The first thing to do in this case is to NOT use an amplified antenna,
it will just make things worse. Try rabbit ears, but rotate them to find
the best position.

[email protected] August 4th 07 08:08 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Aug 3, 5:45 pm, Alan F wrote:
wrote:
I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
normal.


Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
don't have to worry about a dropout.


Stan


Yes, there is such a thing as no or almost no dropouts. I rarely get
dropouts for the strong signal stations. Only the more distant marginal
stations have occasional dropouts and that is typically in poor weather.

Drop puts such as you describe can be due to multipath or a marginal
signal. What does you tuner signal meter show when you have dropouts?
The signal meters can be a % from 0 to 100 or some variant of a series
of bars. Do the signal meter jump over a wide range? Is the antenna
indoors, in the attic, or outside? Another possibility - do you live
near an airport or is the antenna aimed pass an airport?

If you want help, please provide the antenna model #, your zip code, and
what you are using as an ATSC tuner as a starting point.

Alan F


Alan,
Thanks for helping me. I looked at my main channels 2,4,5,7,9,11, and
13 and it appears about 75% strength average. I think the 2 channels
that barely have any dropout have a consistent strength at 75%. The
other ones when there is a drop out, the signal varies from 75% to 40%
or below.

The antenna is in the attic. I don't know the model, I just know that
it's one of those really big antenna VHF/UHF antenna that are suppose
to be on the roof. Probably 5 feet big when it's open. I know the
model, I just know I bought it 15 years ago for about $100.00. The
antenna is hooked up with the same type of wire they use for cable
TV. The closest airport is over 20 miles away. Is that close?

My zip code is 91770. I typed my zip into some website and it told me
that all the big channels are about 12 miles away from me. There
aren't that many hills where I live also. The TV i have is a
Philips 30PW9110D/37B that has a built in QAM digital tuner.

I would apprecitate any help.

Thanks,
stan


[email protected] August 4th 07 08:10 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Aug 3, 5:46 pm, wrote:
"Elmo P. Shagnasty" wrote:

In article . com,
wrote:


I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
normal.


Oh, but it's DIGITAL quality!


snicker


Dont' listen to Elmo, he's a troll.

I suspect your signal is too strong and is overloading
your tuner. You may need to attenuate the signal.

Chip

--
--------------------http://NewsReader.Com/--------------------
Usenet Newsgroup Service $9.95/Month 30GB


My next question was should I buy a bigger antenna? My signal
strength goes between 75% to 40%.

Stan



theo[email protected] August 4th 07 08:10 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 


Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.



My analog reception is consistently good.

Stan


[email protected] August 4th 07 08:13 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 

That or a tree in the way?

I have zero problems with any kind of drop outs on my setup.

If you have this issue on all stations, then its some global problem
such as a bad connection, or something getting in the way of the
signal.


There is no tree in the way. The giant antenna I have is in the
attic. I get two channels that are consistently pretty good that
average a signal strength of 75%. My other channels with a lot of
dropout average between 75% to 40%.

Stan



[email protected] August 4th 07 08:15 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 

The first thing to do in this case is to NOT use an amplified antenna,
it will just make things worse. Try rabbit ears, but rotate them to find
the best position.



I have a electronic amplifer that I attempted to hook up. It actually
made it worst so I removed it.

Stan


G-squared August 4th 07 09:00 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Aug 3, 11:15 pm, wrote:
The first thing to do in this case is to NOT use an amplified

antenna,
it will just make things worse. Try rabbit ears, but rotate them

to find
the best position.


I have a electronic amplifer that I attempted to hook up. It

actually
made it worst so I removed it.

Stan


As an inexpensive experiment, you could try a couple different value
attenuators say 3, 6 or 10 dB. If the amplifier made it worse, you may
be simply overloading the front end(s). At 12 miles you shouldn't need
any large antenna unless you have a difficult multipath issue that a
more directional could help though it would have more signal output as
well. Attenuators are excellent for that scenario.

We're in LA and use a Winegard SquareShooter (little over 4 dB gain,
13 dB front-back) 35 miles out, line of sight, signal split 4 ways.
Dropouts are so rare I don't remember the last one.

GG


Matthew L. Martin August 4th 07 01:13 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
Elmo P. Shagnasty wrote:
In article ,
"Matthew L. Martin" wrote:

wrote:
On Fri, 03 Aug 2007 16:31:48 -0700
wrote:

| I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
| about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
| matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
| picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
| normal.
|
| Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
| don't have to worry about a dropout.

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.

The only loose connection involved is likely that between your pea brain
and your typing fingers. I don't think I've seen a connection between
the two, ever, you ignorant, self centered, hypocritical blow hard.

Matthew


ok, so Matthew has "won" in that he has shown the world, for now and
forever, that he's not at all interested in the discussion at hand--that
he will stalk phil and use anything and everything phil says, no matter
how innocuous, as a springboard for attacking phil.


Boo, bloody, hoo.

Matthew

--
I'm a consultant. If you want an opinion I'll sell you one.
Which one do you want?

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from
http://www.teranews.com


Alan F August 4th 07 04:53 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote:
Alan,
Thanks for helping me. I looked at my main channels 2,4,5,7,9,11, and
13 and it appears about 75% strength average. I think the 2 channels
that barely have any dropout have a consistent strength at 75%. The
other ones when there is a drop out, the signal varies from 75% to 40%
or below.

The antenna is in the attic. I don't know the model, I just know that
it's one of those really big antenna VHF/UHF antenna that are suppose
to be on the roof. Probably 5 feet big when it's open. I know the
model, I just know I bought it 15 years ago for about $100.00. The
antenna is hooked up with the same type of wire they use for cable
TV. The closest airport is over 20 miles away. Is that close?

My zip code is 91770. I typed my zip into some website and it told me
that all the big channels are about 12 miles away from me. There
aren't that many hills where I live also. The TV i have is a
Philips 30PW9110D/37B that has a built in QAM digital tuner.

I would apprecitate any help.

Thanks,
stan


In LA, all of the stations are currently digitally broadcasting on
UHF. If you can tune to analog channels, how do the analog UHF stations
look? I suspect your big antenna is not that a good performer for UHF.
Also, if the co-axial cable was put in 15 years ago, it may have been
RG-59 cable. RG-59 has higher loss for the upper UHF channels than RG-6
which is what is strongly recommended for antenna cable use today.

The antennaweb.org digital list for your zip code is a rather long one
which I trimmed to just the stations on Mt. Wilson. The key is the last
number on each line which is the actual broadcast channel of the
station. Stations are simulcasting the digital signal on a different
channel because the analog channel takes up the channel # you know the
station by.

* yellow - uhf KTTV-DT 11.1 FOX LOS ANGELES CA 353° 11.2 65
* yellow - uhf KMEX-DT 34.1 UNI LOS ANGELES CA 352° 11.4 35
* yellow - uhf KCAL-DT 9.1 IND LOS ANGELES CA 352° 11.4 43
* yellow - uhf KCBS-DT 2.1 CBS LOS ANGELES CA 350° 11.7 60
* yellow - uhf KTBN-DT 23.1 TBN SANTA ANA CA 353° 11.2 23
* yellow - uhf KTLA-DT 5.1 CW LOS ANGELES CA 352° 11.4 31
* yellow - uhf KWHY-DT 22.1 IND LOS ANGELES CA 352° 11.4 42
* yellow - uhf KPXN-DT 30.1 ION SAN BERNARDINO CA 354° 10.5 38
* yellow - uhf KRCA-DT 62.1 IND RIVERSIDE CA 354° 10.5 68
* yellow - uhf KXLA-DT 44.1 IND RANCHO PALOS VERDES CA 352° 11.4 51
* yellow - uhf KSCI-DT 18.1 IND LONG BEACH CA 354° 10.5 61
* yellow - uhf KOCE-DT 50.1 PBS HUNTINGTON BEACH CA 352° 11.4 48
* yellow - uhf KDOC-DT 56.1 IND ANAHEIM CA 352° 11.4 32
* yellow - uhf KABC-DT 7.1 ABC LOS ANGELES CA 352° 11.4 53
* yellow - uhf KJLA-DT 57.1 IND VENTURA CA 352° 11.4 49
* yellow - uhf KNBC-DT 4.1 NBC LOS ANGELES CA 353° 11.3 36
* yellow - uhf KLCS-DT 58.1 PBS LOS ANGELES CA 353° 11.2 41
* yellow - uhf KCET-DT 28.1 PBS LOS ANGELES CA 353° 11.2 59
* yellow - uhf KCOP-DT 13.1 MNT LOS ANGELES CA 352° 11.5 66
* yellow - uhf KFTR-DT 46.1 TFA ONTARIO CA 352° 11.4 29
* yellow - uhf KAZA-DT 54.1 AZA AVALON CA 352° 11.4 47

In February, 2009, after the analog shutdown, the four stations with
upper VHF 7 to 13 analog channels - KABC-DT 7, KCAL-DT 9, KTTV-DT 11,
KCOP-DT 13 - will switch their digital signal to their current analog
channel. The stations at low VHF 2 to 6 - KCBS-DT 2, KNBC-DT 4, KTLA-DT
5 will stay at UHF. So for digital reception in the LA area, people need
to get an antenna that has good performance for UHF and upper VHF. The
Channel Master 4228 8 Bay bowtie directional UHF antenna is a popular
antenna in LA because it has good performance for upper VHF.

My advice is to first try to tweak your current setup. Check that the
antenna is aimed at or close to Mt. Wilson. If you can, you might try to
tilt the antenna aim upwards as the Mt. Wilson antenna farm is at over
6000'. The UHF yagi part of these big antennas is much more directional
than the VHF antenna. So tilting the antenna up may help.

Check your co-axial cable. If it is RG-59, can you easily replace it
with quad shielded RG-6 cable? That should help performance for UHF.
Also, if you have any connectors that you can access, open them and
check for corrosion.

If tweaking the antenna aim does not help, there are two options. One
is to get a medium power low noise pre-amp from Winegard or Channel
Master. But you are only ~ 11 miles from the antenna farm and a pre-amp
may make things worse.

The other option is to replace the antenna and co-axial cable run. How
much room do you have in the attic? Do you need to get the analog
stations at low VHF? At your close range, a Channel Master 4221 4 Bay is
a good bet to get the upper VHF channels in 2009.

Useful website for antenna info:
http://www.hdtvprimer.com/ISSUES/erecting_antenna.html.

Alan F




[email protected] August 4th 07 05:08 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Aug 4, 12:00 am, G-squared wrote:
On Aug 3, 11:15 pm, wrote:
The first thing to do in this case is to NOT use an amplified

antenna,
it will just make things worse. Try rabbit ears, but rotate them

to find
the best position.


I have a electronic amplifer that I attempted to hook up. It

actually
made it worst so I removed it.

Stan


As an inexpensive experiment, you could try a couple different value
attenuators say 3, 6 or 10 dB. If the amplifier made it worse, you may
be simply overloading the front end(s). At 12 miles you shouldn't need
any large antenna unless you have a difficult multipath issue that a
more directional could help though it would have more signal output as
well. Attenuators are excellent for that scenario.

We're in LA and use a Winegard SquareShooter (little over 4 dB gain,
13 dB front-back) 35 miles out, line of sight, signal split 4 ways.
Dropouts are so rare I don't remember the last one.

GG


GG,
I got to buy one of these. Thanks so much. At least now I know it's
possible.

Stan


[email protected] August 4th 07 05:27 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 

As an inexpensive experiment, you could try a couple different value
attenuators say 3, 6 or 10 dB. If the amplifier made it worse, you may
be simply overloading the front end(s). At 12 miles you shouldn't need
any large antenna unless you have a difficult multipath issue that a
more directional could help though it would have more signal output as
well. Attenuators are excellent for that scenario.

We're in LA and use a Winegard SquareShooter (little over 4 dB gain,
13 dB front-back) 35 miles out, line of sight, signal split 4 ways.
Dropouts are so rare I don't remember the last one.

GG


GG,
interesting. I got to try one of these. I didn't even know they
existed.

thanks,
stan


Wes Newell August 4th 07 05:34 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Sat, 04 Aug 2007 06:08:49 +0000, theory4debate wrote:

The antenna is in the attic. I don't know the model, I just know that
it's one of those really big antenna VHF/UHF antenna that are suppose
to be on the roof. Probably 5 feet big when it's open. I know the
model, I just know I bought it 15 years ago for about $100.00. The
antenna is hooked up with the same type of wire they use for cable
TV. The closest airport is over 20 miles away. Is that close?


I'm sure Alan will cover this in great detail, but with that type of
antenna, and it should be good enough at only 12 miles, it needs to be
pointed precisely. So plug in your exact address in antennaweb and then
make sure the antenna as close to the direction as possible. While it
might work better outside, as long as there's nothing else between you and
the towers and it's not a metallic roof, the attic should be fine.

--
Want the ultimate in free OTA SD/HDTV Recorder? http://mythtv.org
http://mysettopbox.tv/knoppmyth.html Usenet alt.video.ptv.mythtv
My server http://wesnewell.no-ip.com/cpu.php
HD Tivo S3 compared http://wesnewell.no-ip.com/mythtivo.htm


[email protected] August 4th 07 05:38 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
Alan,

thanks for your help. Here is a reply to your questions...

In LA, all of the stations are currently digitally broadcasting on
UHF. If you can tune to analog channels, how do the analog UHF stations
look?


I just went through all my Analog UHF and here are the results for the
channels that register on my TV....

22, 28, 30, 34, 40, 54, 56 excellent picture.

33, 45, 46. 50,52, 58, 63 a little snow on picture, but very
watchable

18, 25, 44, 57, 67 a lot of snow, barely watchable

24, 27, 62, poor, can see picture, but unwatchable

I suspect your big antenna is not that a good performer for UHF.
Also, if the co-axial cable was put in 15 years ago, it may have been
RG-59 cable. RG-59 has higher loss for the upper UHF channels than RG-6
which is what is strongly recommended for antenna cable use today.


Do you still recommend me changing the cable wire after knowing the
results of my analog UHF channels?

Channel Master 4228 8 Bay bowtie directional UHF antenna is a popular
antenna in LA because it has good performance for upper VHF.


I will look into that.

My advice is to first try to tweak your current setup. Check that the
antenna is aimed at or close to Mt. Wilson. If you can, you might try to
tilt the antenna aim upwards as the Mt. Wilson antenna farm is at over
6000'. The UHF yagi part of these big antennas is much more directional
than the VHF antenna. So tilting the antenna up may help.


I never aimed the antenna at Mt. Wilson. I only installed the antenna
without consider that. I don't even know which way is the front of
the antenna. I'm guessing it's the side that is pointy like a arrow.


Check your co-axial cable. If it is RG-59, can you easily replace it
with quad shielded RG-6 cable? That should help performance for UHF.
Also, if you have any connectors that you can access, open them and
check for corrosion.


I got to look at that.


The other option is to replace the antenna and co-axial cable run. How
much room do you have in the attic?


A lot of space. I can stand up.


Do you need to get the analog
stations at low VHF?



Here are my results for analog VHF channel....
2, 5, 7, excellent picture

4, 9, 11, 13 very good, some lines on the picture, but no snow.

6, snowy picture and not watchable

Thanks for your help,

Stan


[email protected] August 4th 07 05:41 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
I'm sure Alan will cover this in great detail, but with that type of
antenna, and it should be good enough at only 12 miles, it needs to be
pointed precisely. So plug in your exact address in antennaweb and then
make sure the antenna as close to the direction as possible. While it
might work better outside, as long as there's nothing else between you and
the towers and it's not a metallic roof, the attic should be fine.


Wes,

Thanks, I'm going to try to aim the antenna. I never pointed the
antenna at anything. I don't even know which side is the front of the
antenna. I assume it's the pointy side that looks like a arrow. My
roof is a cheap roof. No metallic.

thanks,
stan


Chris McGonnell August 4th 07 05:44 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Sat, 04 Aug 2007 00:08:35 -0400, Elmo P. Shagnasty wrote:

tomfoolery snipped

ok, so Matthew has "won" in that he has shown the world, for now and
forever, that he's not at all interested in the discussion at hand--that
he will stalk phil and use anything and everything phil says, no matter
how innocuous, as a springboard for attacking phil.


With a name like Shagnasty, it's got to be good!

--
Chris McG.
Harming humanity since 1951.
"Well now you're just getting SILLY." -- Darla

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com


[email protected] August 4th 07 06:30 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
ANOTHER IMPORT FACT!!!!!!!!!!

I've never tested my HDTV OTA channels on a saturday morning. All my
previous test were always during prime time TV during the evening from
6pm to 10pm.
Today is Saturday morning at 9:25 am and for the last hour I've been
testing each channel about 5 to 10 minutes each. I actually watched
channels 2, 4, 7, 9, 11, 13 without dropouts. The only channel with
several dropout in 3 minutes was channel 5.


In the past I always had a dropout every 5-10 minutes all every
channel with the exception of two channels.






Tantalust August 4th 07 06:31 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
Hats off to Alan for always being so helpful here.



Cass Lewart August 4th 07 07:12 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote:
: I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I receive
: about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
: matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs. The
: picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
: normal.

: Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog because I
: don't have to worry about a dropout.

: Stan

Location, location. You may also try an in-line amplifier form
Radio Shack for around $35. It works great for me.
Cass

G-squared August 4th 07 07:40 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Aug 4, 10:12 am, (Cass Lewart) wrote:
wrote:

: I live about 12 miles away from the broadcasting antenna. I

receive
: about 40 OTA (over the air) channels. However, it seems like no
: matter which channel I'm watching, there are always drop outs.

The
: picture or the sound does something weird. Then it goes back to
: normal.

: Although HDTV is much more clear. I actually prefer analog

because I
: don't have to worry about a dropout.

: Stan

Location, location. You may also try an in-line amplifier form
Radio Shack for around $35. It works great for me.
Cass


Apparently you're not following the thread. He already tried an
amplifier which made things worse so he removed it. At that time I
sugested attenuators but now that we know his other reception issues,
antenna aim and good coax might clean it up for him.

I use clear silicone grease on the outdoor connectors under the
weather boots. The splitter is under the eave where it can get no rain
- even when driving BAD. Due to the splitters location, a drip loop
(good thing) is unavoidable. You also want drip loops where the coax
enters the outside wall. Radio Shack has flanged cylinders for the
passes through the walls. I use white bathtub caulk (stucco house) on
the outside.

GG


ValveJob August 4th 07 09:16 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Sat, 04 Aug 2007 06:10:58 -0000, wrote:



Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.



My analog reception is consistently good.

Stan


Attics can block over 50% of your signal strength. You should have
no lower than 90% signal strength on all the channels you watch.

You need to get that antenna out of the attic and on the roof. Your
problems will go away.



Alan F August 4th 07 10:00 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote:
Alan,

thanks for your help. Here is a reply to your questions...

In LA, all of the stations are currently digitally broadcasting on
UHF. If you can tune to analog channels, how do the analog UHF stations
look?


I just went through all my Analog UHF and here are the results for the
channels that register on my TV....

22, 28, 30, 34, 40, 54, 56 excellent picture.
33, 45, 46. 50,52, 58, 63 a little snow on picture, but very
watchable
18, 25, 44, 57, 67 a lot of snow, barely watchable
24, 27, 62, poor, can see picture, but unwatchable



At your close range, you should be getting a decent analog picture for
most of the UHF stations. Some of them may be at low power though.

I suspect your big antenna is not that a good performer for UHF.
Also, if the co-axial cable was put in 15 years ago, it may have been
RG-59 cable. RG-59 has higher loss for the upper UHF channels than RG-6
which is what is strongly recommended for antenna cable use today.


Do you still recommend me changing the cable wire after knowing the
results of my analog UHF channels?

Channel Master 4228 8 Bay bowtie directional UHF antenna is a popular
antenna in LA because it has good performance for upper VHF.


I will look into that.

My advice is to first try to tweak your current setup. Check that the
antenna is aimed at or close to Mt. Wilson. If you can, you might try to
tilt the antenna aim upwards as the Mt. Wilson antenna farm is at over
6000'. The UHF yagi part of these big antennas is much more directional
than the VHF antenna. So tilting the antenna up may help.


I never aimed the antenna at Mt. Wilson. I only installed the antenna
without consider that. I don't even know which way is the front of
the antenna. I'm guessing it's the side that is pointy like a arrow.


Aiming the antenna is likely to make a BIG difference. It probably
works for VHF because it is picking up the VHF stations in the sidelobe,
but not very well for UHF. Here is a example spec sheet for a Winegard
VHF/UHF antenna:
http://www.winegard.com/offair/pdf/HD7082P.pdf. If you
look at the beam patterns, it is narrower the higher you go in channels
and frequency.

The front of your antenna should have shorter elements and a vertical
V reflector. This is the UHF part of the your antenna. Aim the antenna
at around 352° with a compass or around 20 degrees west of true north.

Some trig for elevation angle. A check with google Earth shows the
height of your zip code above sea level is around 300'. The antenna
height for KABC-DT is 1821 meters ASL or 5973'
(http://www.fcc.gov/fcc-bin/tvq?call=KABC-TV). You are ~ 11 miles away,
so arc tan (5673' difference / (11 miles * 5280')) = 5.6°, so the
broadcast antennas are ~5.6° up! So tilting the antenna up a bit is
worth doing.

Check your co-axial cable. If it is RG-59, can you easily replace it
with quad shielded RG-6 cable? That should help performance for UHF.
Also, if you have any connectors that you can access, open them and
check for corrosion.


I got to look at that.


Open the cable connectors you can easily reach or any that are located
outside and check for any moisture or corrosion. It can sometimes help
to wipe the inside and the center connector with tissue paper and then
reconnect them, but make sure the connection is tight.

The other option is to replace the antenna and co-axial cable run. How
much room do you have in the attic?


A lot of space. I can stand up.


See what you can do with your current antenna. At your range, I would
not be surprised if an indoor UHF antenna would work fine. Another thing
to try, if you can, is to move the antenna around in the attic. Attics
have dead spots, so the antenna could be at a poor location for some of
the UHF channels.

If you want to buy new cable or mounting gear, Lowes usually stocks
antenna mounting gear & cables. I have seen posts that Frys Electronics
often stocks Channel Master 4228 and 4221 bowtie antennas, if you don't
have success with your current antenna.

Do you need to get the analog stations at low VHF?


Here are my results for analog VHF channel....
2, 5, 7, excellent picture

4, 9, 11, 13 very good, some lines on the picture, but no snow.

6, snowy picture and not watchable

Thanks for your help,

Stan


The lines in the analog picture suggest some interference. A shielded
RG-6 cable run can sometimes help with that. But again, try aiming the
antenna first. Analog 6 could be XETV Fox 6 located just across the
Mexico border serving San Diego. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XETV-TV.

Let me know what results you get by tweaking the antenna aim. Good luck!

Alan F




Alan F August 4th 07 10:08 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
valvejob wrote:
On Sat, 04 Aug 2007 06:10:58 -0000, wrote:

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.


My analog reception is consistently good.

Stan


Attics can block over 50% of your signal strength. You should have
no lower than 90% signal strength on all the channels you watch.

You need to get that antenna out of the attic and on the roof. Your
problems will go away.


Yes, attics do reduce signal strength. But Stan is only 11 miles from
the huge antenna farm on Mt. Wilson, so he has a clear shot at the
broadcast towers. Attic mounts are usually easier to put in and access.
If he can get good reception from the attic, he should stick with it.

That is why I always ask for zip code, what model and where the
antenna is before I try to give any specific advice. What someone needs
at 5 miles from the broadcast towers is very different that what someone
needs at 70 miles & over a ridge.

Alan F



Matthew L. Martin August 4th 07 11:35 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
Alan F wrote:
valvejob wrote:
On Sat, 04 Aug 2007 06:10:58 -0000, wrote:

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.


My analog reception is consistently good.

Stan


Attics can block over 50% of your signal strength. You should have
no lower than 90% signal strength on all the channels you watch.
You need to get that antenna out of the attic and on the roof. Your
problems will go away.


Yes, attics do reduce signal strength. But Stan is only 11 miles from
the huge antenna farm on Mt. Wilson, so he has a clear shot at the
broadcast towers. Attic mounts are usually easier to put in and access.
If he can get good reception from the attic, he should stick with it.


I installed a deep fringe VHF/UHF in my attic in Sutton MA. I was able
to get good watchable pictures from southern NH, through Boston and down
to Providence. I was able to get a barely watchable signal from Mt
Washington, NH when WWMT was there. I would estimate that to be a
distance of ~160 air miles (It's just over 200 driving miles).

That is why I always ask for zip code, what model and where the
antenna is before I try to give any specific advice. What someone needs
at 5 miles from the broadcast towers is very different that what someone
needs at 70 miles & over a ridge.


That's because you are genuinely helpful, unlike poor old phil.

Matthew

--
I'm a consultant. If you want an opinion I'll sell you one.
Which one do you want?

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from
http://www.teranews.com


Matthew L. Martin August 4th 07 11:39 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
Matthew L. Martin wrote:
Alan F wrote:
valvejob wrote:
On Sat, 04 Aug 2007 06:10:58 -0000, wrote:

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.


My analog reception is consistently good.

Stan

Attics can block over 50% of your signal strength. You should have
no lower than 90% signal strength on all the channels you watch. You
need to get that antenna out of the attic and on the roof. Your
problems will go away.


Yes, attics do reduce signal strength. But Stan is only 11 miles from
the huge antenna farm on Mt. Wilson, so he has a clear shot at the
broadcast towers. Attic mounts are usually easier to put in and access.
If he can get good reception from the attic, he should stick with it.


I installed a deep fringe VHF/UHF in my attic in Sutton MA. I was able
to get good watchable pictures from southern NH, through Boston and down
to Providence. I was able to get a barely watchable signal from Mt
Washington, NH when WWMT was there. I would estimate that to be a
distance of ~160 air miles (It's just over 200 driving miles).


That should WMTW, Channel 8.

That is why I always ask for zip code, what model and where the
antenna is before I try to give any specific advice. What someone needs
at 5 miles from the broadcast towers is very different that what someone
needs at 70 miles & over a ridge.


That's because you are genuinely helpful, unlike poor old phil.

Matthew



--
I'm a consultant. If you want an opinion I'll sell you one.
Which one do you want?

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from
http://www.teranews.com


Otto Bahn August 5th 07 01:06 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
"Elmo P. Shagnasty" wrote

ok, so Matthew has "won" in that he has shown the world, for now and
forever, that he's not at all interested in the discussion at hand--that
he will stalk phil and use anything and everything phil says, no matter
how innocuous, as a springboard for attacking phil.


He's actually doing a service to mankind. The pompous
blowhards need negative feedback loops, which makes all
of our days a bit sunnier while also helping to stop
global warming.

--oTTo--

"You can only eat a goat once, but you can make cheese
from their milk for years."

-- Stanley Fish, October 25, 1987

Matthew L. Martin August 5th 07 05:32 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
Otto Bahn wrote:
"Elmo P. Shagnasty" wrote

ok, so Matthew has "won" in that he has shown the world, for now and
forever, that he's not at all interested in the discussion at hand--that
he will stalk phil and use anything and everything phil says, no matter
how innocuous, as a springboard for attacking phil.


He's actually doing a service to mankind. The pompous
blowhards need negative feedback loops, which makes all
of our days a bit sunnier while also helping to stop
global warming.

--oTTo--

"You can only eat a goat once, but you can make cheese
from their milk for years."


"Give a man a fish and feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and he
will drink beer in his boat all day long".

Matthew

--
I'm a consultant. If you want an opinion I'll sell you one.
Which one do you want?

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com


G-squared August 5th 07 05:44 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Aug 4, 12:16 pm, valvejob wrote:
On Sat, 04 Aug 2007 06:10:58 -0000, wrote:

Do you see any glitches or pulses or other interference on the

analog?
One possible cause if the problem affects all channels is some

loose
connection somewhere along the antenna lead line.


My analog reception is consistently good.


Stan


Attics can block over 50% of your signal strength. You should

have
no lower than 90% signal strength on all the channels you watch.

You need to get that antenna out of the attic and on the roof.

Your
problems will go away.


KABC-DT is reporting 65% on the HDTV Wonder in this computer. Several
others are about the same. The best one is 88%. I have no issues at
all with the 64% channels or any of the stronger ones.

I _have_ had a Tektronix spectrum analyzer on the antenna feed and I
know that _all_ the channels have nearly texbook response but it did
take raising the antenna another 5 feet to get it all to behave.

GG


[email protected] August 5th 07 09:32 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
Thanks for all the help. I will be trying to fix my reception soon.
I will post my results afterwards.

thanks,
stan



Alan F August 8th 07 05:45 AM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
wrote:
Thanks for all the help. I will be trying to fix my reception soon.
I will post my results afterwards.

thanks,
stan



Have you been able to check the aim of the antenna yet?

Alan F

[email protected] August 8th 07 04:51 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 


Have you been able to check the aim of the antenna yet?

Alan F


The last time I was up there, there was a mouse about 2 feet in front
of me. I've been scared to go up there for the longest time.
However, now since the temperature is so hot, I don't think there are
any mouse up there now. I will try to go up today.

Stan


G-squared August 8th 07 05:51 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Aug 8, 7:51 am, wrote:
Have you been able to check the aim of the antenna yet?


Alan F


The last time I was up there, there was a mouse about 2 feet in

front
of me. I've been scared to go up there for the longest time.
However, now since the temperature is so hot, I don't think there

are
any mouse up there now. I will try to go up today.

Stan


The mouse was probably more scared than you...

Before I raised the antenna the last 5 feet to clear the house across
the street, the antenna aim was very fussy because of the reflections/
diffractions. The Winegard SquareShooter has a very broad pickup angle
(60 degree) but changing the antenna aim just a few degrees would
cause all sorts of anomalies. I had the fortune of having a spectrum
analyzer to verify my suspicions.

GG


[email protected] August 8th 07 06:30 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
On Wed, 08 Aug 2007 14:51:51 -0000 wrote:

| The last time I was up there, there was a mouse about 2 feet in front
| of me. I've been scared to go up there for the longest time.
| However, now since the temperature is so hot, I don't think there are
| any mouse up there now. I will try to go up today.

Take along a non-flammable non-toxic-to-humans aerosol spray can or an
air horn.

--
|---------------------------------------/----------------------------------|
| Phil Howard KA9WGN (ka9wgn.ham.org) / Do not send to the address below |
| first name lower case at ipal.net /
|
|------------------------------------/-------------------------------------|

[email protected] August 8th 07 10:02 PM

Is there such thing as OTA HDTV without dropouts?
 
FINALLY COMPLETED!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I went up in the attic and looked at the position of the antenna. The
antenna was actually aimed West (it should be aimed North at Mt
Wilson's antenna farm.) I aimed the antenna North and checked the
reception.

The HDTV reception remained at about 75%....however this time it was
consistent. There were no dropouts. Wow! I then checked my analog
station and it actually made some channels worst. Since I have
ReplayTV, I still need analog TV.

I then moved the antenna out of the attic and on the roof. On my
roof, I can actually see the antenna farm where the TV stations
antenna are. I never noticed the Antenna Farm until Alan F mention it
on the thread. I pointed my antenna directly at the Antenna Farm.

Now both my analog TV works fine, and my Digitial HDTV works perfect.
I was watching TV for about an hours and there wasn't even one drop-
out.

AWESOME!!!!



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:08 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com