HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   High definition TV (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Is current tv worth hdtv? (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=49634)

John Anderson February 11th 07 09:28 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?




R Sweeney February 11th 07 09:34 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 

"John Anderson" wrote in message
news:v%[email protected]_s22...
I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?


There are only a handful of network series worth watching in ANY resolution.

Movies, eye-candy and sports are the main reasons for HDTV
Not to mention HD/BD DVD's and HD video games.




G-squared February 11th 07 09:40 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
On Feb 11, 12:28 pm, "John Anderson" wrote:
I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive

set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the

cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?


Since you've been waiting for over 50 years ?.... The programming
keeps changing for better and worse. What I _can_ say about HDTV,
football games look really good, the Rose Parade also. The wide shots
on Men In Trees (Alaska) are pretty impressive and the HD on Nature
(PBS) are pretty good as well.

In your case I'd say find some more good books to read - they're
cheaper and more satisfying anyway.

GG


Lloyd Parsons February 11th 07 10:36 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
In article v%[email protected]_s22,
"John Anderson" wrote:

I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?


For you, you shouldn't.

For me and many others, HD has plenty (but not enough) to offer.

Lloyd Parsons February 11th 07 10:38 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
In article ,
"R Sweeney" wrote:

"John Anderson" wrote in message
news:v%[email protected]_s22...
I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?


There are only a handful of network series worth watching in ANY resolution.

Movies, eye-candy and sports are the main reasons for HDTV
Not to mention HD/BD DVD's and HD video games.


Yeah, only a handful. Here's what I record/watch in a typical week:
Heroes, Law & Order (3 different ones), CSI (3 of them too), Grey's
Anatomy, Cold Case, Close to Home, Boston Legal, 24, Justice and I think
there is a few more.

Enough more that I'm thinking about getting an additional 622 so I have
enough tuners!

Lloyd Parsons February 11th 07 10:39 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
In article . com,
"G-squared" wrote:

On Feb 11, 12:28 pm, "John Anderson" wrote:
I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive

set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the

cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?


Since you've been waiting for over 50 years ?.... The programming
keeps changing for better and worse. What I _can_ say about HDTV,
football games look really good, the Rose Parade also. The wide shots
on Men In Trees (Alaska) are pretty impressive and the HD on Nature
(PBS) are pretty good as well.

In your case I'd say find some more good books to read - they're
cheaper and more satisfying anyway.

GG


Not just nature, but almost everything on DiscoveryHD and National
GeographicHD too.

skip February 11th 07 11:36 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
"John Anderson" wrote in news:v%Kzh.1188036$084.928655
@attbi_s22:

I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?


Not this troll again. Here we go



Sam Spade February 12th 07 03:05 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
Lloyd Parsons wrote:


Yeah, only a handful. Here's what I record/watch in a typical week:
Heroes, Law & Order (3 different ones), CSI (3 of them too), Grey's
Anatomy, Cold Case, Close to Home, Boston Legal, 24, Justice and I think
there is a few more.

Enough more that I'm thinking about getting an additional 622 so I have
enough tuners!


Try Shark on CBS.

Lloyd Parsons February 12th 07 03:16 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
In article ,
Sam Spade wrote:

Lloyd Parsons wrote:


Yeah, only a handful. Here's what I record/watch in a typical week:
Heroes, Law & Order (3 different ones), CSI (3 of them too), Grey's
Anatomy, Cold Case, Close to Home, Boston Legal, 24, Justice and I think
there is a few more.

Enough more that I'm thinking about getting an additional 622 so I have
enough tuners!


Try Shark on CBS.


I said there were a few more. Shark was in that group! ;-)

As was Bones, Eureka (SciFi) and Dresden Files (SciFi)

And then of course, there is sports for all and sundry. Golf and
football are great in HD! And last, but not least, is the Discovery
type stuff.

There is so much that really is good on TV these days, you have to
really want it to suck to take the time to find the bad stuff.

Dave Gower February 12th 07 03:59 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 

"Elmo P. Shagnasty" wrote

Of course, there are people out there who spent $10,000 on an HDTV just
so they could watch the sun rise over a mountain in 1080i; those people
are goofy.


And people who massage their ego by judging the tastes and private behaviour
of others are of course mature and balanced.



willbill February 12th 07 04:33 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
John Anderson wrote:

I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?



HDTV is a misleading term coz it can
be either a device (TV), or the video
material itself. the material can
be any or all of: OTA, DVD movie,
cable, satelite, video camera

you don't have to pay for OTA HDTV,
and it's generally quite good. also,
you'll need a half decent roof top
antenna with half decent reception,
otherwise don't bother with OTA

for OTA reception, what you'll need
is a recent TV (either flat screen
or tube, that has HD capability (preferably
720p or 1080i or 1080p)) with both an
analog OTA TV tuner (NTSC), and a digital
OTA TV tuner (ATSC)

bill

G-squared February 12th 07 05:37 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
On Feb 11, 6:59 pm, "Dave Gower"
wrote:
"Elmo P. Shagnasty" wrote

Of course, there are people out there who spent $10,000 on an

HDTV just
so they could watch the sun rise over a mountain in 1080i; those

people
are goofy.


And people who massage their ego by judging the tastes and private

behaviour
of others are of course mature and balanced.


10-4 on that. Thanks for the laugh, Dave

GG





Dave Gower February 12th 07 01:57 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 

"Elmo P. Shagnasty" wrote

Ah, spoken like one who spent $10,000 on an HDTV and sat there and
ooohed and aaahhhhed over a mountain sunrise scene.


No, $3000 on a D-ILA and I really enjoyed the Pebble Beach Open yesterday.
No sunrise tho.

Your snide superiority says more about you than any of your intended
targets. Grow up.



John Briggs February 12th 07 05:47 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
Lloyd Parsons wrote:


Try Shark on CBS.


I said there were a few more. Shark was in that group! ;-)

As was Bones, Eureka (SciFi) and Dresden Files (SciFi)

And then of course, there is sports for all and sundry. Golf and
football are great in HD! And last, but not least, is the Discovery
type stuff.

There is so much that really is good on TV these days, you have to
really want it to suck to take the time to find the bad stuff.


May I put in a word for Veronica Mars on The CW. Like Buffy the Vampire
Slayer and Firefly, an overlooked gem.

--

John Briggs Phoenix, Arizona, USA)

Lloyd Parsons February 12th 07 05:55 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
In article ,
John Briggs wrote:

Lloyd Parsons wrote:


Try Shark on CBS.


I said there were a few more. Shark was in that group! ;-)

As was Bones, Eureka (SciFi) and Dresden Files (SciFi)

And then of course, there is sports for all and sundry. Golf and
football are great in HD! And last, but not least, is the Discovery
type stuff.

There is so much that really is good on TV these days, you have to
really want it to suck to take the time to find the bad stuff.


May I put in a word for Veronica Mars on The CW. Like Buffy the Vampire
Slayer and Firefly, an overlooked gem.


Like Firefly you say?? One of my very favorite shows, I have the DVDs
of all the episodes and of course, Serenity, the movie.

CW is on here, but it is a digital sub of one of the other channels and
I don't have a guide listing for it. When is Veronica Mars on?

Tockk February 12th 07 11:21 PM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
I watch Letterman and the talking heads on Sunday morning. Aside from
that, I don't find much on TV worth watching.

Talking to you fine folks is much more fun . . .

-Tock



[email protected] February 13th 07 02:17 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
On Feb 11, 2:40 pm, "G-squared" wrote:
On Feb 11, 12:28 pm, "John Anderson" wrote:
I cannot find progamming that suits me in STD, let alone
want to have an HDTV!

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive

set.
I have standard tvs, but hardly think programming is worth the

cost, even
for standard tv definition. So why pay for HDTV?


Since you've been waiting for over 50 years ?.... The programming
keeps changing for better and worse. What I _can_ say about HDTV,
football games look really good, the Rose Parade also. The wide shots
on Men In Trees (Alaska) are pretty impressive and the HD on Nature
(PBS) are pretty good as well.

In your case I'd say find some more good books to read - they're
cheaper and more satisfying anyway.

GG


Right after I got my HDTV (32in Sanyo 4:3 with built in ATSC tuner) I
lived in a town which broadcast the PBS HD feed during primetime and
they had some fantastic programming. I was very enthusiastic about
PBS. Moved to another state and the PBS channel here chooses to
broadcast 4 SD channels 24 hours a day and its some of the worst
programming imaginable. I like educational programming but this is
like PBS used to be in the 70's, with "shows" that are sometimes just
somebody lecturing against an institutionally painted wall. So I
cannot recommend PBS because it is completely dependent on your local
station.

That being said, some of the network shows are worth watching (Heroes,
and CSI even after many seasons pulls out great episodes) and look
great in HD all from my set top antenna. ($12.95 at Wal-Mart).

-beaumon


John Anderson February 13th 07 02:46 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 

"Lloyd Parsons" wrote in message
...
In article ,
Sam Spade wrote:

There is so much that really is good on TV these days, you have to
really want it to suck to take the time to find the bad stuff.



That depends on what you consider "good"
First of all, I am not interested at all in sports.
Most USA movies are a drag, network sob stories are as well,
and prime time evening, I have not liked in decades.

I will watch some Discovery, Travel Channel, to see places I can
never afford to visit, heck, I have not seen much of my own state (IOWA)!

I am beginning to think that I was born in the wrong country!



Lloyd Parsons February 13th 07 03:19 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
In article [email protected]_s21,
"John Anderson" wrote:

"Lloyd Parsons" wrote in message
...
In article ,
Sam Spade wrote:

There is so much that really is good on TV these days, you have to
really want it to suck to take the time to find the bad stuff.



That depends on what you consider "good"
First of all, I am not interested at all in sports.
Most USA movies are a drag, network sob stories are as well,
and prime time evening, I have not liked in decades.

I will watch some Discovery, Travel Channel, to see places I can
never afford to visit, heck, I have not seen much of my own state (IOWA)!

I am beginning to think that I was born in the wrong country!


You're right, it does depend on what you consider good. I find good
drama, scifi and comedy to fill the bill for me. Throw in a discovery
type show or more and I'm good to go.

You could watch the BBC. Plenty of bland Brit humor and such there...
;-)

R Sweeney February 13th 07 03:39 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 

"John Anderson" wrote in message

I am beginning to think that I was born in the wrong country!


right country, wrong decade

TV today is written by 24 year olds, for 14 year olds.
The AVERAGE age for the screen writers guild is 34.

And the average IQ of the screen writer is down from the days of Rod Serling
as well.



Jim H February 13th 07 07:52 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
"John Anderson" wrote in message
news:v%[email protected]_s22...

I cannot find programming that suits me in STD,...


You should have that "STD" looked at whether you like the programming
or not.

I have been waiting since the 50's for tv worth buying an expensive set.


After half a century and not seeing any improvement in the programming,
maybe you should consider reading a book.



John Briggs February 14th 07 02:17 AM

Is current tv worth hdtv?
 
Lloyd Parsons wrote:

In article ,
John Briggs wrote:

....
May I put in a word for Veronica Mars on The CW. Like Buffy the Vampire
Slayer and Firefly, an overlooked gem.


Like Firefly you say?? One of my very favorite shows, I have the DVDs
of all the episodes and of course, Serenity, the movie.

CW is on here, but it is a digital sub of one of the other channels and
I don't have a guide listing for it. When is Veronica Mars on?


Well, it isn't sci-fi or demon fighting. It does have the comedy/dram combo
of those two shows, however. The concept is a modern Nancy Drew -- her
father is a private eye and she has picked up a lot from him. Still, I find
the writing and acting first rate. It airs Tuesday nights, 8:00 pm MST,
9:00/8:00 Central, according to the web site.

--

John Briggs Phoenix, Arizona, USA)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:17 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com