HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   UK digital tv (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Freesat from Sky (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=37190)

[email protected] October 21st 05 01:01 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
Just wondered if anyone at all had ordered this. It seems like a
deliberate rip-off.

£150 for freesat, which doesn't even give more4, or free Sky
installation, plus 3 months at £7.50, and then 9 @ £15, with 2 of
their mixes, total cost £157.50, after which you are free to cancel.

Has anyone actually ordered the £150 offer, as it doesn't look at all
attractive.


Dave Fawthrop October 21st 05 01:41 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
On 21 Oct 2005 04:01:50 -0700, wrote:

| Just wondered if anyone at all had ordered this. It seems like a
| deliberate rip-off.
|
| £150 for freesat, which doesn't even give more4, or free Sky
| installation, plus 3 months at £7.50, and then 9 @ £15, with 2 of
| their mixes, total cost £157.50, after which you are free to cancel.
|
| Has anyone actually ordered the £150 offer, as it doesn't look at all
| attractive.

You do not have to pay GBP150 to get freesatfromsky you need only spend
GBP20 see sig.

Next year BBC and ITV will launch a *real* freesat
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertain...io/4221722.stm
This will work off generic STB and dish.

--
Dave Fawthrop dave hyphenologist co uk Sat ITV, Ch4, Ch5, only GBP20
http://www.freesatfromsky.com - "what is freesat?" - "view T&C" -
What will I receive "£20 ... one Viewing Card". You will also need
$ky box and dish. List of Channels at http://www.wickonline.com/fta.htm


spiney October 21st 05 01:56 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
"Freesat"?

Sky are canny, they have an effective monopoly, and "pitch" prices at
whatever they believe will maximise revenue.

Most people can't self-install, and even buying 2nd hand equipment
often might not leave too much change from £150, after getting a card
for ITV (and of course, in some places satellite is the only viable tv
reception system!).

After which, once you've got a receiver and card, it's so easy to
upgrade to subscription channels, just needs a phone call .........

As Dave Fawthrop says, ITV wil be going actually free to air
(unencrypted), then there should be some competition, forcing prices
down.

Unfortunately, good tv progs cost money to make, and that's why we
should properly fund public service broadcasting, despite this being a
"tax".


Minty October 21st 05 02:19 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
spiney wrote:
"Freesat"?

Sky are canny, they have an effective monopoly, and "pitch" prices at
whatever they believe will maximise revenue.


Quite. Their is a perception in the UK that satellite TV = Sky and only
Sky. There are more satellites receivable in the UK than the Astra 2
cluster that Sky use.

Most people can't self-install, and even buying 2nd hand equipment
often might not leave too much change from £150, after getting a card
for ITV (and of course, in some places satellite is the only viable tv
reception system!).


Really? With kits like these
http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?...=1&doy=21 m10
and those sold by Lidl is slowly dispelling the myths that DIY isn't an
option and the only route is Sky.

After which, once you've got a receiver and card, it's so easy to
upgrade to subscription channels, just needs a phone call .........


If you haven't already fallen for the sales pitch and committed yourself to
£500 a year in subs :-(

As Dave Fawthrop says, ITV wil be going actually free to air
(unencrypted), then there should be some competition, forcing prices
down.


Which is good for everyone except Sky.

Unfortunately, good tv progs cost money to make, and that's why we
should properly fund public service broadcasting, despite this being
a "tax".




spiney October 21st 05 03:02 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

Minty wrote:

Quite. Their is a perception in the UK that satellite TV = Sky and only
Sky. There are more satellites receivable in the UK than the Astra 2
cluster that Sky use.

Most people can't self-install .....


Really? With kits like these
http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?...=1&doy=21 m10
and those sold by Lidl is slowly dispelling the myths that DIY isn't an
option and the only route is Sky.

After which ...


If you haven't already fallen for the sales pitch and committed yourself to
£500 a year in subs :-(

As Dave Fawthrop says, ...


Which is good for everyone except Sky.

Yes, Minty, agreed.

The Lidl receivers/kits are unbelievably good value, and (of course)
will get ITV after it starts non-encrypted satellite broadcasting.
However, note that Sky's version of BBCi can't be got on such receivers
(special software).

Minidishes are cheap, and used Sky digiboxes too, but new digiboxes
cost more than "Freesat" (due to Sky's installer subsidy).


[email protected] October 21st 05 03:16 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

Dave Fawthrop wrote:
On 21 Oct 2005 04:01:50 -0700, wrote:

| Just wondered if anyone at all had ordered this. It seems like a
| deliberate rip-off.
|
| £150 for freesat, which doesn't even give more4, or free Sky
| installation, plus 3 months at £7.50, and then 9 @ £15, with 2 of
| their mixes, total cost £157.50, after which you are free to cancel.
|
| Has anyone actually ordered the £150 offer, as it doesn't look at all
| attractive.

You do not have to pay GBP150 to get freesatfromsky you need only spend
GBP20 see sig.


Well that's clearly not true. £20 gets you a card, which you still
need to stick in a skybox, which needs to be connected to a satellite
dish.

These are not free.

Here's an alternative option from Maplin (£130).
http://www.maplin.co.uk/Module.aspx?...305&doy=21m10D

The text obviously wasn't read before being cut and pasted on the site:

Free to Air Digital Satellite Kit
Includes Satellite dish, receiver, and LNB
PLUG AND PLAY, No Subscriptions, No Cards, No Hassle
DIY instructions and National Install Hotline included* (* Note
Installation quotes available from National qualified and insured
company) do this in small letters at bottom end somewhere!
Complete list of Digital channels available for multi languages
Receive BBC1, BBC2, ITV News, ITV3 etc. Coming soon early 2006 - ITV1
&ITV2


spiney October 21st 05 03:34 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

wrote:
Dave Fawthrop wrote:


etc, see the actual post .....

OK, agreed, but the Maplin kit is roughly twice the price of the Lidl
kit (when available!).At Present time, it can't get ITV/Ch4/Ch5. And -
of course - can never receive any Sky subscription channels.

Also, Sky offer many interactive facilties via phoneline (very
expensively, fair enough!) you can't get on non-Sky receviers.

I believe there's currently a Sky CAM, which will accept Sky cards in
CI slot satellite receivers.


John Patrick October 21st 05 03:40 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

I believe there's currently a Sky CAM, which will accept Sky cards in
CI slot satellite receivers.


I think you believe wrong



spiney October 21st 05 03:53 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

John Patrick wrote:

I believe there's currently a Sky CAM, which will accept Sky cards in
CI slot satellite receivers.


I think you believe wrong


Sky haven't officially authorised this, and it probably doesn't work
reliably, but see:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Videoguard .


Adrian October 21st 05 04:00 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
John Patrick wrote:
I believe there's currently a Sky CAM, which will accept Sky cards in
CI slot satellite receivers.


I think you believe wrong


No, he's right, it's called the Dragon Cam.



Rod L October 21st 05 05:07 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

"Adrian" wrote in message
om...
John Patrick wrote:
I believe there's currently a Sky CAM, which will accept Sky cards in
CI slot satellite receivers.


I think you believe wrong


No, he's right, it's called the Dragon Cam.

I think the latest firmware has removed the NDS bit.



Tiny Tim October 21st 05 05:20 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
On Fri, 21 Oct 2005 15:00:00 +0100, "Adrian" wrote:

John Patrick wrote:
I believe there's currently a Sky CAM, which will accept Sky cards in
CI slot satellite receivers.


I think you believe wrong


No, he's right, it's called the Dragon Cam.


Being a long term Sky Digital subscriber I'm a bit dopey when it comes
to the rest of the satellite market, so please bear with me....

I have a home built Windows Media Center PC which records from my Sky
digibox using a Scart-composite video connection into my analogue
capture card. Obviously my recorded picture quality is not as good as
a direct RGB connection from the digibox to the TV. But, if I bought a
DVB-S card for my PC and stuck in a Dragon Cam and my Sky card into
that, am I likely to see anything useful and be able to record the
original MPEG2 data without any extra wires or signal conversion?

Is there a good site I can view to see which channels I might get, if
the encypted (or all) Sky digital channels will not be available? If
the CAM and Sky card won't get me Sky channels is there any point in
getting the CAM at all. My viewing interests are mainstream English
speaking entertainment (comedy, dramas, documentaries, sci--fi and
films) - not sport or foreign stuff.

I understand MCE is not compatible with DVB-S cards but I'm quite
happy to run something else on Win XP if I can get much improved
picture quality and more reliable channel changing (no more IR blaster
etc.).

Thanks,
Tim.

--
To save on your shopping click here - http://www.rpoints.com/?ruid=44653
To sign up with PlusNet click here - http://tinyurl.com/b9wqs

Ad C October 21st 05 08:05 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
In article . com,
says...


Unfortunately, good tv progs cost money to make, and that's why we
should properly fund public service broadcasting, despite this being a
"tax".

It is just a shame we don't get good programmes for the money then.



Dave Fawthrop October 21st 05 08:18 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
On 21 Oct 2005 06:16:23 -0700, wrote:

|
| Dave Fawthrop wrote:
| On 21 Oct 2005 04:01:50 -0700,
wrote:
|
| | Just wondered if anyone at all had ordered this. It seems like a
| | deliberate rip-off.
| |
| | £150 for freesat, which doesn't even give more4, or free Sky
| | installation, plus 3 months at £7.50, and then 9 @ £15, with 2 of
| | their mixes, total cost £157.50, after which you are free to cancel.
| |
| | Has anyone actually ordered the £150 offer, as it doesn't look at all
| | attractive.
|
| You do not have to pay GBP150 to get freesatfromsky you need only spend
| GBP20 see sig.
|
| Well that's clearly not true. £20 gets you a card, which you still
| need to stick in a skybox, which needs to be connected to a satellite
| dish.

Which was explicitly stated in the sig repeated below.

--
Dave Fawthrop dave hyphenologist co uk Sat ITV, Ch4, Ch5, only GBP20
http://www.freesatfromsky.com - "what is freesat?" - "view T&C" -
What will I receive "£20 ... one Viewing Card". You will also need
$ky box and dish. List of Channels at http://www.wickonline.com/fta.htm

:::Jerry:::: October 21st 05 10:07 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

"Ad C" wrote in message
...
In article . com,
says...


Unfortunately, good tv progs cost money to make, and that's why

we
should properly fund public service broadcasting, despite this

being a
"tax".

It is just a shame we don't get good programmes for the money then.



We might if they forgot about the phoney 'ratings war', leave the
dross and crap to the commercial sector...



Jomtien October 22nd 05 09:26 AM

Freesat from Sky
 
Tiny Tim wrote:

But, if I bought a
DVB-S card for my PC and stuck in a Dragon Cam and my Sky card into
that, am I likely to see anything useful and be able to record the
original MPEG2 data without any extra wires or signal conversion?


Currently you can. There is absolutely no guarantee that this will
work tomorrow though.

--
Digibox problem? : A reboot solves 90% of these.
The Sky Digital FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/7rm2m
UK TV overseas: http://tinyurl.com/6p73
BBC reception questions? ; http://www.astra2d.com/
Fed up with on-screen logos? : http://logofreetv.org/
----
Only the truth as I see it.
No monies return'd. ;-)

Tiny Tim October 22nd 05 11:10 AM

Freesat from Sky
 
On Sat, 22 Oct 2005 09:26:21 +0200, Jomtien wrote:

Tiny Tim wrote:

But, if I bought a
DVB-S card for my PC and stuck in a Dragon Cam and my Sky card into
that, am I likely to see anything useful and be able to record the
original MPEG2 data without any extra wires or signal conversion?


Currently you can. There is absolutely no guarantee that this will
work tomorrow though.


Sounds almost tempting enough to give it a go. Can you recommend a
site with a bit more info about this sort of setup? If Sky did do some
fiddling what might I end up still being able to view - a bunch of
foreign junk only, FTA/FTV or just FTV stuff? I think the DVB-S card
and CAM will cost over £120 so I don't want to spend that just for an
"experiment".

--
To save on your shopping click here - http://www.rpoints.com/?ruid=44653
To sign up with PlusNet click here - http://tinyurl.com/b9wqs

:::Jerry:::: October 22nd 05 11:43 AM

Freesat from Sky
 

"Noel" wrote in message
...
On Fri, 21 Oct 2005 21:07:02 +0100, ":::Jerry::::"
wrote:


We might if they forgot about the phoney 'ratings war', leave the
dross and crap to the commercial sector...


Until then, why should the TV owning public be expected to

subsidise
the production of such dross and crap (inevitably yet another
'reality' programme) through the payment of an annual TV Tax?


Why shouldn't we though, at least with true publicly funded PBS there
is a chance that things will change... It's only because of the
'rating war' that we are in this situation, I also suspect that we
are also starting to come out of that rut, remember that it takes
time for new programmes to come on air.



Ad C October 22nd 05 02:21 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
In article s.net,
LID says...

It is just a shame we don't get good programmes for the money then.



We might if they forgot about the phoney 'ratings war', leave the
dross and crap to the commercial sector...

I agree and stop wasting money on stupid things.
Maybe they should stop employing so many people that do n nothing all
day

Ad C October 22nd 05 02:22 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
In article s.net,
LID says...

Why shouldn't we though, at least with true publicly funded PBS there
is a chance that things will change... It's only because of the
'rating war' that we are in this situation, I also suspect that we
are also starting to come out of that rut, remember that it takes
time for new programmes to come on air.

Nothing have chnaged in the last 15 years, so it is certainly is going
to change now.


The BBc knows it got a licence to waste money and waste they do.

:::Jerry:::: October 22nd 05 06:00 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

"Ad C" wrote in message
k...
In article

s.net,
LID says...

Why shouldn't we though, at least with true publicly funded PBS

there
is a chance that things will change... It's only because of the
'rating war' that we are in this situation, I also suspect that

we
are also starting to come out of that rut, remember that it takes
time for new programmes to come on air.

Nothing have chnaged in the last 15 years, so it is certainly is

going
to change now.


The BBc knows it got a licence to waste money and waste they do.


Change your record and take your head out of your rear end FFS.

Or are you just one of those who morn the passing of 'Dusty Bin'?...



:::Jerry:::: October 22nd 05 06:02 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

"Ad C" wrote in message
k...
In article

s.net,
LID says...

It is just a shame we don't get good programmes for the money

then.



We might if they forgot about the phoney 'ratings war', leave the
dross and crap to the commercial sector...

I agree and stop wasting money on stupid things.
Maybe they should stop employing so many people that do n nothing

all
day


Do tell more, just who are these workless people and were are they
employed?...



Jomtien October 23rd 05 09:12 AM

Freesat from Sky
 
Tiny Tim wrote:

Can you recommend a
site with a bit more info about this sort of setup?


A search for Dragon Cam should provide the info needed. It's not
something I follow myself.


If Sky did do some
fiddling what might I end up still being able to view - a bunch of
foreign junk only, FTA/FTV or just FTV stuff?


If Sky cared to alter their encryption technique slightly you would
probably no longer be able to receive any UK encrypted channels. UK
FTA would not be affected.

--
Digibox problem? : A reboot solves 90% of these.
The Sky Digital FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/7rm2m
UK TV overseas: http://tinyurl.com/6p73
BBC reception questions? ; http://www.astra2d.com/
Fed up with on-screen logos? : http://logofreetv.org/
----
Only the truth as I see it.
No monies return'd. ;-)

John Porcella October 23rd 05 12:59 PM

Freesat from Sky
 

"spiney" wrote in message
ups.com...
"Freesat"?

Sky are canny, they have an effective monopoly, and "pitch" prices at
whatever they believe will maximise revenue.

Why is pitch in inverted commas?

What you describe is true of firms which seek to maximise revenues. Some
others attempt to maximise profits, or maximise sales volumes.


Most people can't self-install, and even buying 2nd hand equipment
often might not leave too much change from £150, after getting a card
for ITV (and of course, in some places satellite is the only viable tv
reception system!).

After which, once you've got a receiver and card, it's so easy to
upgrade to subscription channels, just needs a phone call .........

As Dave Fawthrop says, ITV wil be going actually free to air
(unencrypted), then there should be some competition, forcing prices
down.

Unfortunately, good tv progs cost money to make, and that's why we
should properly fund public service broadcasting, despite this being a
"tax".

No, it does follow that PSB needs taxpayer's money for TV to have good
programmes. Advertising and subscriptions are better alternatives than do
not force people to fund PSB.


--
MESSAGE ENDS.
John Porcella




Tiny Tim October 23rd 05 09:44 PM

Freesat from Sky
 
On Sun, 23 Oct 2005 09:12:31 +0200, Jomtien wrote:

Tiny Tim wrote:

Can you recommend a
site with a bit more info about this sort of setup?


A search for Dragon Cam should provide the info needed. It's not
something I follow myself.

OK, thanks.

If Sky did do some
fiddling what might I end up still being able to view - a bunch of
foreign junk only, FTA/FTV or just FTV stuff?


If Sky cared to alter their encryption technique slightly you would
probably no longer be able to receive any UK encrypted channels. UK
FTA would not be affected.


But is the decoding algorithm taken care of by the hardware or the
card? I don't mind continuing to pay my Sky subscription - I just want
to go straight from the MPEG data stream to disk without loads of
analogue conversions in between. If the encryption changes would
another card get me out of any hole or would I be looking for new
hardware?

Thanks,
Tim.

--
To save on your shopping click here - http://www.rpoints.com/?ruid=44653
To sign up with PlusNet click here - http://tinyurl.com/b9wqs

John Porcella October 24th 05 03:27 AM

Freesat from Sky
 

Reading around your grammar


Not my grammar, but the grammar of English.

(I take it English is not your first
language),


You 'take' it wrongly.

you fail to offer any arguments as to why subscription is
better than direct funding. Stating something does not make it so.


Correct! Subscription is better, as I wrote, since it does not force
payments of taxes by those not interested in that TV channel.


A subscription service is the complete opposite to PSB.


So?


Regarding advertising, that by definition means ratings, ratings and
ratings.


I know, and rightly so.


--
MESSAGE ENDS.
John Porcella



The Wizard October 24th 05 05:05 AM

Freesat from Sky
 

"John Porcella" wrote in message
...


Correct! Subscription is better, as I wrote, since it does not force
payments of taxes by those not interested in that TV channel.


I would'nt say so looking at Sky's packages.... Suppose people don't want
Sky One and want UK Gold or vice-versa, We still end up paying for both.

Actually, you could say ALL Sky subscriptions are taxes due to the fact the
channels advertise to make their income (and this is third rate programming
with DOGS, Red dots,*Coming soon* etc)

Always Add to Sky Advert Sky, What do you want to watch? "Something
without Dogs,Adverts and on-screen Graffitti" and err I bet they could'nt
offer that :-/





Jomtien October 24th 05 08:18 AM

Freesat from Sky
 
Tiny Tim wrote:

If Sky cared to alter their encryption technique slightly you would
probably no longer be able to receive any UK encrypted channels. UK
FTA would not be affected.


But is the decoding algorithm taken care of by the hardware or the
card? I don't mind continuing to pay my Sky subscription - ......
If the encryption changes would
another card get me out of any hole or would I be looking for new
hardware?


Dragon Cams only emulate the decryption module in a Sky box: they
still need an official card. Such a card will always be valid but if
Sky choose to make some alteration to the decryption process your
unofficial CAM could stop working with the card (this would have no
effect at all on regular Sky digibox users). The makers of these CAMs
have already stated that they will not necessarily update the firmware
to counter such changes.


I just want
to go straight from the MPEG data stream to disk without loads of
analogue conversions in between.


Sky's most likely reason for wanting to disable these CAMs would be to
prevent precisely that.

--
Digibox problem? : A reboot solves 90% of these.
The Sky Digital FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/7rm2m
UK TV overseas: http://tinyurl.com/6p73
BBC reception questions? ; http://www.astra2d.com/
Fed up with on-screen logos? : http://logofreetv.org/
----
Only the truth as I see it.
No monies return'd. ;-)

Tiny Tim October 24th 05 10:02 AM

Freesat from Sky
 
On Mon, 24 Oct 2005 08:18:35 +0200, Jomtien wrote:

Tiny Tim wrote:

If Sky cared to alter their encryption technique slightly you would
probably no longer be able to receive any UK encrypted channels. UK
FTA would not be affected.


But is the decoding algorithm taken care of by the hardware or the
card? I don't mind continuing to pay my Sky subscription - ......
If the encryption changes would
another card get me out of any hole or would I be looking for new
hardware?


Dragon Cams only emulate the decryption module in a Sky box: they
still need an official card. Such a card will always be valid but if
Sky choose to make some alteration to the decryption process your
unofficial CAM could stop working with the card (this would have no
effect at all on regular Sky digibox users). The makers of these CAMs
have already stated that they will not necessarily update the firmware
to counter such changes.


I just want
to go straight from the MPEG data stream to disk without loads of
analogue conversions in between.


Sky's most likely reason for wanting to disable these CAMs would be to
prevent precisely that.


Thanks for the replies, Jomtien. It's certainly something to think
about. I am very tempted to take a chance and go for this setup.

--
To save on your shopping click here - http://www.rpoints.com/?ruid=44653
To sign up with PlusNet click here - http://tinyurl.com/b9wqs


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:31 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com