HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   UK digital tv (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=5)
-   -   Channel numbers (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=36451)

John Rowland September 27th 05 01:41 AM

Channel numbers
 

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL and
Telewest?

I'm particularly surprised that a new channel like More4 will have four
different numbers (165, 166, 142 and 13). Could they not find a three-digit
number that was unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in it?

--
John Rowland - Spamtrapped
Transport Plans for the London Area, updated 2001
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Acro...69/tpftla.html
A man's vehicle is a symbol of his manhood.
That's why my vehicle's the Piccadilly Line -
It's the size of a county and it comes every two and a half minutes



Graham September 27th 05 01:50 AM

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL and
Telewest?



What is it the French say?
Viva Le Difference!

--
Graham.



%Profound_observation%



housetrained September 27th 05 09:12 AM

Just think how lovely it would be to live in a communist state where
everything could be organised.
Not!
Anyway, what difference does it make?

--
John the West Ham fan


"John Rowland" wrote in message
...

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL and
Telewest?

I'm particularly surprised that a new channel like More4 will have four
different numbers (165, 166, 142 and 13). Could they not find a
three-digit
number that was unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in
it?

--
John Rowland - Spamtrapped
Transport Plans for the London Area, updated 2001
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Acro...69/tpftla.html
A man's vehicle is a symbol of his manhood.
That's why my vehicle's the Piccadilly Line -
It's the size of a county and it comes every two and a half minutes





steeler September 27th 05 09:40 AM


"John Rowland" wrote in message
...

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL and
Telewest?

I'm particularly surprised that a new channel like More4 will have four
different numbers (165, 166, 142 and 13). Could they not find a
three-digit
number that was unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in
it?


Channel numbers are assigned as channels join each platform. They all join
at different times. 165 and 166 on sky for more4 and +1 makes perfect sense
as it puts them directly after E4 and E4+1. I assume 13 on freeview puts it
after E4 too.



Mark Carver September 27th 05 10:01 AM

John Rowland wrote:
Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL and
Telewest?

I'm particularly surprised that a new channel like More4 will have four
different numbers (165, 166, 142 and 13). Could they not find a three-digit
number that was unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in it?


http://www.channel4.com/more4/

Umm, it says "Free To Air" on D-Sat, I wonder if they really mean that ?


--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

Industrial September 27th 05 10:09 AM

Mark Carver wrote:
http://www.channel4.com/more4/

Umm, it says "Free To Air" on D-Sat, I wonder if they really mean that ?


Why wouldn't they?

They know "Freesat" is coming.

They know the BBC is FTA.

They know ITV3 is FTA.

They're not stupid.

INDUSTRIAL.

Mark Carver September 27th 05 10:15 AM

Industrial wrote:
Mark Carver wrote:

http://www.channel4.com/more4/

Umm, it says "Free To Air" on D-Sat, I wonder if they really mean that ?



Why wouldn't they?

They know "Freesat" is coming.

They know the BBC is FTA.

They know ITV3 is FTA.

They're not stupid.

INDUSTRIAL.


Well they managed to foul up the cricket on Film 4 this year, that should have
been FTV but was 'subs only' most days.

--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

John Rowland September 27th 05 10:52 AM

"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...
John Rowland wrote:

Could they not find a three-digit number that was
unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in it?


http://www.channel4.com/more4/


"EPG position 13 (except in Wales where
it will be on 35 from 10 - 17 October,
then EPG position 13 from 18 October)."

LOL. What a cock up. It seems like channel 35 is vacant on Freeview - I
wonder why they didn't just put it on 35 nationally and leave it there?

--
John Rowland - Spamtrapped
Transport Plans for the London Area, updated 2001
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Acro...69/tpftla.html
A man's vehicle is a symbol of his manhood.
That's why my vehicle's the Piccadilly Line -
It's the size of a county and it comes every two and a half minutes



Roland Perry September 27th 05 12:11 PM

In message , at
08:40:36 on Tue, 27 Sep 2005, steeler remarked:
I assume 13 on freeview puts it
after E4 too.


No, E4's channel 14 on Freeview. (and E4+1 is channel 39!)
--
Roland Perry

[email protected] September 27th 05 12:33 PM


John Rowland wrote:
Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL and
Telewest?

I'm particularly surprised that a new channel like More4 will have four
different numbers (165, 166, 142 and 13). Could they not find a three-digit
number that was unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in it?

--
John Rowland - Spamtrapped
Transport Plans for the London Area, updated 2001
http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Acro...69/tpftla.html
A man's vehicle is a symbol of his manhood.
That's why my vehicle's the Piccadilly Line -
It's the size of a county and it comes every two and a half minutes


Both your message and your sig suggest that you yearn for a perfect
world. Alas, there isn't one. The chances of the broadcasters making an
agreement like that are about the same as the chances of my cats
sharing their food in an amicable and socialistic manner. And yes, my
vehicle is a symbol of my manhood. It is very old, nowhere near big
enough, and won't start when I need it urgently. Ohh, and there's a
water leak . . .

Ahh, but when it was newer it used to get me into some scrapes I can
tell you! I used to boast I could get it anywhere.

Bill


steeler September 27th 05 01:49 PM


"Roland Perry" wrote in message
.uk...
In message , at
08:40:36 on Tue, 27 Sep 2005, steeler remarked:
I assume 13 on freeview puts it
after E4 too.


No, E4's channel 14 on Freeview. (and E4+1 is channel 39!)
--
Roland Perry


hmm, okay 13 and 14 is not bad - but +1 @ 39 is just plain silly. They
would be better having E4 and E4+1 at 13 and 14 and more4 at 39



steeler September 27th 05 01:51 PM


"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...
Industrial wrote:
Mark Carver wrote:

http://www.channel4.com/more4/

Umm, it says "Free To Air" on D-Sat, I wonder if they really mean that ?



Why wouldn't they?

They know "Freesat" is coming.

They know the BBC is FTA.

They know ITV3 is FTA.

They're not stupid.

INDUSTRIAL.


Well they managed to foul up the cricket on Film 4 this year, that should
have been FTV but was 'subs only' most days.


Flim4 and E4 have existing deals with Sky. Just like when film4 is having a
free weekend you can only watch if you are a sky subscriber.



Mark Carver September 27th 05 01:55 PM

steeler wrote:
"Mark Carver" wrote in message


Well they managed to foul up the cricket on Film 4 this year, that should
have been FTV but was 'subs only' most days.



Flim4 and E4 have existing deals with Sky. Just like when film4 is having a
free weekend you can only watch if you are a sky subscriber.


No, in previous years Film 4 has gone FTV while it showed Cricket, i.e. the
same encryption level as C4 itself. I agree, during promotional weekends F4 is
often 'free' to all Sky subscribers, that is *not* FTV however.

--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

Dave September 27th 05 05:48 PM

On Tue, 27 Sep 2005 12:49:46 +0100, "steeler"
wrote:


"Roland Perry" wrote in message
o.uk...
In message , at
08:40:36 on Tue, 27 Sep 2005, steeler remarked:
I assume 13 on freeview puts it
after E4 too.


No, E4's channel 14 on Freeview. (and E4+1 is channel 39!)
--
Roland Perry


hmm, okay 13 and 14 is not bad - but +1 @ 39 is just plain silly. They
would be better having E4 and E4+1 at 13 and 14 and more4 at 39


I think E4+1 will disappear from Freeview when 4 More starts.
--
Dave
Sheffield, England, UK

http://www.gnudawn.co.uk/

Mark Carver September 27th 05 06:47 PM

Dave wrote:


I think E4+1 will disappear from Freeview when 4 More starts.


That's what I thought, but More4 and E4+1 are on different muxes, M4 is on Mux
2, E4+1 on Mux C, so it looks as if both will exist ?

http://www.dtg.org.uk/retailer/dtt_channels.html

--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

mirodo September 27th 05 06:59 PM

John Rowland wrote:
"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...

John Rowland wrote:

Could they not find a three-digit number that was
unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in it?


http://www.channel4.com/more4/



"EPG position 13 (except in Wales where
it will be on 35 from 10 - 17 October,
then EPG position 13 from 18 October)."

LOL. What a cock up. It seems like channel 35 is vacant on Freeview - I
wonder why they didn't just put it on 35 nationally and leave it there?



There's going to be a shuffle of the EPG positions on 18th October.
Channel 13 is currently occupied by S4C2, which will be moving to 86.

Once S4C2 is out of the way, More4 can move nationwide to 13, which has
the advantage of (a) being a lower number, (b) next to E4 on 14

Full details on the changes he
http://www.sbmedia.netfirms.com/free...x_page0003.htm


mirodo September 27th 05 07:02 PM

John Rowland wrote:
"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...

John Rowland wrote:

Could they not find a three-digit number that was
unused on all four networks, and maybe had some fours in it?


http://www.channel4.com/more4/



"EPG position 13 (except in Wales where
it will be on 35 from 10 - 17 October,
then EPG position 13 from 18 October)."

LOL. What a cock up. It seems like channel 35 is vacant on Freeview - I
wonder why they didn't just put it on 35 nationally and leave it there?


There's going to be a shuffle of the EPG positions on 18th October.
Channel 13 is currently occupied by S4C2, which will be moving to 86.

Once S4C2 is out of the way, More4 can move nationwide to 13, which has
the advantage of (a) being a lower number, (b) next to E4 on 14

Full details on the changes he
http://www.sbmedia.netfirms.com/free...x_page0003.htm

Dave September 27th 05 09:28 PM

On Tue, 27 Sep 2005 17:47:28 +0100, Mark Carver
wrote:

Dave wrote:


I think E4+1 will disappear from Freeview when 4 More starts.


That's what I thought, but More4 and E4+1 are on different muxes, M4 is on Mux
2, E4+1 on Mux C, so it looks as if both will exist ?

http://www.dtg.org.uk/retailer/dtt_channels.html


It certainly looks like it.
--
Dave
Sheffield, England, UK

http://www.gnudawn.co.uk/

Stephen September 28th 05 01:40 AM

"Graham" wrote in message ...
Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL

and
Telewest?



What is it the French say?
Viva Le Difference!


C'est Vive LA Difference, actuellement!



Dave Newt September 28th 05 02:11 AM

Stephen wrote:
"Graham" wrote in message ...

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL


and

Telewest?



What is it the French say?
Viva Le Difference!



C'est Vive LA Difference, actuellement!


Er, that's "différence".

Oh, and "actuellement" doesn't mean "actually".

You got the gender right though :-)

Stephen September 28th 05 02:12 AM

There's going to be a shuffle of the EPG positions on 18th October.
Channel 13 is currently occupied by S4C2, which will be moving to 86.

Once S4C2 is out of the way, More4 can move nationwide to 13, which has
the advantage of (a) being a lower number, (b) next to E4 on 14

Full details on the changes he
http://www.sbmedia.netfirms.com/free...x_page0003.htm


It's a nonsense that on Freeview ITV2 is Channel 6, and BBC3 is Channel 7
etc. One day they could rationalise Freeview in a different way, taking
account of the fact that there are multiple channels from each broadcaster.
Something like this perhaps:

11 BBC1
12 BBC2
13 BBC3
14 BBC4
15 BBC News
16 CBBC
17 CBeebies
18 BBCi

31 ITV1
32 ITV2
33 ITV3
34 ITV4
35 ITV News
36 CITV

41 Channel 4
42 E4
43 E4+1
44 More 4
45 Quiz Call (from Channel 4)

51 five
52 More five ?
53 ftn (shared ownership with five)

61 Sky One (you never know, they might do this)
62 Sky Two
63 Sky Three
64 Sky Four?
65 Sky News
66 Sky Sports News

71 MTV Hits
72 MTV 2
73 MTV Base
74 MTV Dance
75 TMF
76 The Hits

81 QVC
82 Ideal World
83 Bid-Up TV
84 Price Drop TV
85 another shopping channel

91 UK Gold
92 UK History
93 UK Documentary
94 UK Boring Ideas

101 Radio 1
102 Radio 2
103 Radio 3
104 Radio 4
105 Radio 5
106 Radio 6
107 Radio 7

111 Radio 1 Extra
114 Radio 4 Daily Service
115 Radio 5 Extra

901 Adult Channel
902 Television X
903 Red Hot
904 Spice Platinum



Stephen September 28th 05 02:41 AM

"Dave Newt" wrote in message
...
Stephen wrote:
"Graham" wrote in message

...

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL


and

Telewest?


What is it the French say?
Viva Le Difference!



C'est Vive LA Difference, actuellement!


Er, that's "différence".

Oh, and "actuellement" doesn't mean "actually".

You got the gender right though :-)


Zut alors! Il s'avère que je réellement ne comprends pas la langue Française
après tous!



Mark Carver September 28th 05 08:13 AM

Stephen wrote:

It's a nonsense that on Freeview ITV2 is Channel 6, and BBC3 is Channel 7
etc. One day they could rationalise Freeview in a different way, taking
account of the fact that there are multiple channels from each broadcaster.
Something like this perhaps:

11 BBC1
12 BBC2
13 BBC3
14 BBC4
15 BBC News
16 CBBC
17 CBeebies
18 BBCi

31 ITV1
32 ITV2
33 ITV3


ISTR that Ofcom dictate that BBC 1, BBC 2, ITV-1, C4, and Five have to have
'due prominence' on any UK EPG. Therefore they are always the first 5 slots in
that order.

--
Mark
Please replace invalid and invalid with gmx and net to reply.

Dave Newt September 28th 05 08:41 AM

Stephen wrote:
"Dave Newt" wrote in message
...

Stephen wrote:

"Graham" wrote in message


...

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL

and


Telewest?


What is it the French say?
Viva Le Difference!


C'est Vive LA Difference, actuellement!


Er, that's "différence".

Oh, and "actuellement" doesn't mean "actually".

You got the gender right though :-)



Zut alors! Il s'avère que je réellement ne comprends pas la langue Française
après tous!


Hehe, "touché", as they say :-)

Stephen September 28th 05 04:48 PM

"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...
Stephen wrote:

It's a nonsense that on Freeview ITV2 is Channel 6, and BBC3 is Channel

7
etc. One day they could rationalise Freeview in a different way, taking
account of the fact that there are multiple channels from each

broadcaster.
Something like this perhaps:

11 BBC1
12 BBC2
13 BBC3
14 BBC4
15 BBC News
16 CBBC
17 CBeebies
18 BBCi

31 ITV1
32 ITV2
33 ITV3


ISTR that Ofcom dictate that BBC 1, BBC 2, ITV-1, C4, and Five have to

have
'due prominence' on any UK EPG. Therefore they are always the first 5

slots in
that order.


OK, so how about keeping to that for 1,2,3,4,5 but having two numbers for
each of these channels in order to maintain a logical sequence in the
multiple channel groups. For example you would access the same ITV1stream by
pressing 3 or 31, and the same BBC1 stream by pressing 1 or 11. My idea is
to have all the BBC channels starting with a 1, all the ITV channels
starting with a 3, and all the Channel 4 channels starting with a 4 etc, and
it would never look right if you had to have a gap at the start of each
sequence of multiple channels. I wonder if it is possible to have two
different channel numbers for the same stream though?



Richard Watkinson September 28th 05 09:43 PM

In message
"Stephen" wrote:

There's going to be a shuffle of the EPG positions on 18th October.
Channel 13 is currently occupied by S4C2, which will be moving to 86.

Once S4C2 is out of the way, More4 can move nationwide to 13, which has
the advantage of (a) being a lower number, (b) next to E4 on 14

Full details on the changes he
http://www.sbmedia.netfirms.com/free...x_page0003.htm


It's a nonsense that on Freeview ITV2 is Channel 6, and BBC3 is Channel 7
etc. One day they could rationalise Freeview in a different way, taking
account of the fact that there are multiple channels from each broadcaster.
Something like this perhaps:

11 BBC1
12 BBC2
13 BBC3
14 BBC4
15 BBC News
16 CBBC
17 CBeebies
18 BBCi

31 ITV1
32 ITV2
33 ITV3
34 ITV4
35 ITV News
36 CITV

41 Channel 4
42 E4
43 E4+1
44 More 4
45 Quiz Call (from Channel 4)

51 five
52 More five ?
53 ftn (shared ownership with five)

61 Sky One (you never know, they might do this)
62 Sky Two
63 Sky Three
64 Sky Four?
65 Sky News
66 Sky Sports News

71 MTV Hits
72 MTV 2
73 MTV Base
74 MTV Dance
75 TMF
76 The Hits

81 QVC
82 Ideal World
83 Bid-Up TV
84 Price Drop TV
85 another shopping channel

91 UK Gold
92 UK History
93 UK Documentary
94 UK Boring Ideas

101 Radio 1
102 Radio 2
103 Radio 3
104 Radio 4
105 Radio 5
106 Radio 6
107 Radio 7

111 Radio 1 Extra
114 Radio 4 Daily Service
115 Radio 5 Extra

901 Adult Channel
902 Television X
903 Red Hot
904 Spice Platinum


I know this is not true for all digiboxes but in a lot of cases you
can rearrange the logical channel numbers to suit yourself. It is a
bit of a bind with Twins since each time you rescan you also have to
set it all up again.

One advantage of doing this is that the EPG will show the channels you
are mainly interested in.

Naturally if your box does not have this feature it is back to square
1.

--
Richard Watkinson

Treasurer Sheffield Folk Festival

http://www.sheffieldfolkfestival.org/

Turn left where the chip shop used to be.

Mark Carver October 10th 05 02:37 PM


Industrial wrote:
Mark Carver wrote:
http://www.channel4.com/more4/

Umm, it says "Free To Air" on D-Sat, I wonder if they really mean that ?


Why wouldn't they?

They know "Freesat" is coming.

They know the BBC is FTA.

They know ITV3 is FTA.

They're not stupid.


Well Mr 'Industial' stupid or not, by C4's amended web site, More 4
won't even be FTV on D-Sat, it's subs only.

http://www.channel4.com/more4/getmore4.html

Quote:-
More4 is in the basic channel package through subscription on Sky, ntl
and Telewest. If you have a digital box that receives Freeview, you can

watch More4 for free without subscription.


[email protected] October 10th 05 02:49 PM


Stephen wrote:
"Dave Newt" wrote in message
...
Stephen wrote:
"Graham" wrote in message

...

Why don't channels have the same channel number on Freeview, Sky, NTL

and

Telewest?


What is it the French say?
Viva Le Difference!


C'est Vive LA Difference, actuellement!


Er, that's "diff=E9rence".

Oh, and "actuellement" doesn't mean "actually".

You got the gender right though :-)


Zut alors! Il s'av=E8re que je r=E9ellement ne comprends pas la langue Fr=

an=E7aise
apr=E8s tous!


Mange tout Rodney, mange tout!



All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com