HomeCinemaBanter

HomeCinemaBanter (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/index.php)
-   UK sky (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   News Item: BBC Report on Digital Switch Over (http://www.homecinemabanter.com/showthread.php?t=22044)

NO LOGO April 26th 04 01:58 PM

News Item: BBC Report on Digital Switch Over
 


http://www.bbc.co.uk/pressoffice/pre...itchover.shtml


There is a heck of a lot to discuss in he



1. No mention of LOGOs and RED DOTs. Very very few people seem to have
an issue with DOGs, if the BBC is to be believed. So few people, that it
did not mention a single sentence in the report or one word of
explanation on BBCi.



2. "On this, the Corporation welcomes the opportunity to work with other
organisations as quickly as possible to begin to make a non-subscription
digital satellite option a reality."

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.

This means that something major such as ITV, C4, and FIVE going Free To
Air will happen, or something major in resetting up SOLUS must happen.
May be now Dyke-head is gone, the BBC may even re-encrypt.



3. "Carolyn Fairbairn, Director of Strategy and Distribution, BBC,
added: "The BBC has been making a vital contribution to bringing public
service broadcasting into the digital age. "

Like BBC THREE, Carolyn. ;-)

Like CBBC and CBEEBIES that is known to make children fatter and lower
their IQs and speech skills. ;-)



4. "Therefore as we move closer towards this common final goal, the BBC
will continue to play an important role in partnership with both
Government and other organisations to realise a fully digital Britain."

A strong BBC, independent of Government, but also in partnership with
the Government and other organisations including BSKYB.



5. "On the final stage of the journey towards a fully digital Britain we
want to see our services available to all licence fee payers as quickly
as possible and ensure that there are no pockets of people who are
digitally disenfranchised. "

Well with 50% yet to convert, and most of the conversion done by BSKYB
so far, this is not the final stage of the journey, more the beginning
of the hard slog.



6. "ensure that there are no pockets of people who are digitally
disenfranchised."

Given that viewers can not watch most programmes on BBC THREE and BBC
FOUR without "continuous picture interference" from the BBC's on-screen
marketing graffiti, I don't think her version of "disenfranchised" is
quite the same as mine. ;-)



7. "Most importantly we are focused on our audiences and are aware of
the danger of a deeper digital divide," commented Andy Duncan, Director,
Marketing, Communications and Audiences, BBC.

Well either audiences like DOGs or hate DOGs. If they "like" them, why
don't they appear ALL the time, everywhere. If they "hate" them, why are
they there at all, and why does the BBC fail to implement a Virtual-DOG
system?

Why won't Andy Duncan address the 1,861 members of LOGOFREETV or 6,900
signatories of What Video and TV LOGOs must die?




Let the rioting and flame wars commence.


http://logofreetv.org/
http://newmine.logofreetv.org/


--
Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Simon Gardner April 26th 04 06:47 PM

In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.


In what sense do you claim "the BBC instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat?"



Simon Gardner April 26th 04 06:47 PM

In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.


In what sense do you claim "the BBC instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat?"



Kathryn April 26th 04 08:11 PM


"NO LOGO" wrote in message
news:[email protected] .mailgate.org...



http://www.bbc.co.uk/pressoffice/pre...itchover.shtml


There is a heck of a lot to discuss in he




semi related I guess...

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to "add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff

Kathryn



Kathryn April 26th 04 08:11 PM


"NO LOGO" wrote in message
news:[email protected] .mailgate.org...



http://www.bbc.co.uk/pressoffice/pre...itchover.shtml


There is a heck of a lot to discuss in he




semi related I guess...

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to "add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff

Kathryn



Mark Carver April 26th 04 08:47 PM

"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to
"add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


The box you have purchased will not be able to receive any of Top Up TV's
"add on" channels, regardless whether you have an outdoor aerial or not.

Top Up's pay channels require a card, only the older (and no longer made
or sold) OnDigital/ITV-Digital boxes have a card slot. Top Up claim
that new boxes will be on the market 'soon' with card slots, but for
you I guess it's too late.



Mark Carver April 26th 04 08:47 PM

"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to
"add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


The box you have purchased will not be able to receive any of Top Up TV's
"add on" channels, regardless whether you have an outdoor aerial or not.

Top Up's pay channels require a card, only the older (and no longer made
or sold) OnDigital/ITV-Digital boxes have a card slot. Top Up claim
that new boxes will be on the market 'soon' with card slots, but for
you I guess it's too late.



Ben April 26th 04 09:04 PM

Mark Carver wrote:
"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to
"add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


What are you doing on usenet then? That probably puts you in the top few
percent of tech-savvy geeks already, and thats before you include the
fact that you're not top posting ;-)

The box you have purchased will not be able to receive any of Top Up TV's
"add on" channels, regardless whether you have an outdoor aerial or not.

Top Up's pay channels require a card, only the older (and no longer made
or sold) OnDigital/ITV-Digital boxes have a card slot. Top Up claim
that new boxes will be on the market 'soon' with card slots, but for
you I guess it's too late.


If you really wanted to, you could always pick up a second hand
OnDigital/ITV-Digital box - they are a bit slow and clunky compared to
modern ones, so people are always selling them. For the channel lineup
go to http://www.freeview.co.uk for the free ones and
http://www.topup.tv for the pay ones.




Ben April 26th 04 09:04 PM

Mark Carver wrote:
"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to
"add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


What are you doing on usenet then? That probably puts you in the top few
percent of tech-savvy geeks already, and thats before you include the
fact that you're not top posting ;-)

The box you have purchased will not be able to receive any of Top Up TV's
"add on" channels, regardless whether you have an outdoor aerial or not.

Top Up's pay channels require a card, only the older (and no longer made
or sold) OnDigital/ITV-Digital boxes have a card slot. Top Up claim
that new boxes will be on the market 'soon' with card slots, but for
you I guess it's too late.


If you really wanted to, you could always pick up a second hand
OnDigital/ITV-Digital box - they are a bit slow and clunky compared to
modern ones, so people are always selling them. For the channel lineup
go to http://www.freeview.co.uk for the free ones and
http://www.topup.tv for the pay ones.




Mark Carver April 26th 04 09:13 PM

Ben wrote:
Mark Carver wrote:
"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay
to "add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


What are you doing on usenet then? That probably puts you in the top
few percent of tech-savvy geeks already, and thats before you include
the fact that you're not top posting ;-)


Please be careful with your quotations, neither myself, nor "No Logo"
actually wrote any of that !





Mark Carver April 26th 04 09:13 PM

Ben wrote:
Mark Carver wrote:
"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay
to "add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


What are you doing on usenet then? That probably puts you in the top
few percent of tech-savvy geeks already, and thats before you include
the fact that you're not top posting ;-)


Please be careful with your quotations, neither myself, nor "No Logo"
actually wrote any of that !





Ben April 26th 04 09:23 PM

Mark Carver wrote:
Please be careful with your quotations, neither myself, nor "No Logo"
actually wrote any of that !


Apologies to yourself and No Logo, as usual I was being over-zealous
with the snipping.


Ben April 26th 04 09:23 PM

Mark Carver wrote:
Please be careful with your quotations, neither myself, nor "No Logo"
actually wrote any of that !


Apologies to yourself and No Logo, as usual I was being over-zealous
with the snipping.


NO LOGO April 26th 04 09:49 PM

"Simon Gardner" [dot]co[dot]uk wrote in message


In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.


In what sense do you claim "the BBC instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat?"



;-)

http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1760
http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1758

On 12/03/2003, when Greg Dyke announced the BBC would de-crypt, they did
so without consulting with ITV, Channel 4, and FIVE, and without
consideration for those channels' positions.

Consider, FIVE, who's programme budget of £185M is barely more than
just the BBC's marketing and advertising budget alone, and the scale of
the problem for FIVE, C4, and the smaller ITV companies (then) was
obvious.

The problem is cultural. The BBC "awash with cash" (in the words of Mark
Thompson) does not spend real world cash. The needs of both channels 3,
4 and 5 plus 750,000 homes were ignored by the BBC decision.

Without Free To Air (or free at the point of access) for channels 3, 4,
and 5, Digital Satellite is thwated as a Public Service Platform for
all.

Plurality and multitude of independent sources is considered an
essential component of the UK's PSB ecology.

At least the BBC, in words, has today said it needs to correct this.


http://logofreetv.org/
http://newsmine.logofreetv.org/



--
Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

NO LOGO April 26th 04 09:49 PM

"Simon Gardner" [dot]co[dot]uk wrote in message


In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.


In what sense do you claim "the BBC instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat?"



;-)

http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1760
http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1758

On 12/03/2003, when Greg Dyke announced the BBC would de-crypt, they did
so without consulting with ITV, Channel 4, and FIVE, and without
consideration for those channels' positions.

Consider, FIVE, who's programme budget of £185M is barely more than
just the BBC's marketing and advertising budget alone, and the scale of
the problem for FIVE, C4, and the smaller ITV companies (then) was
obvious.

The problem is cultural. The BBC "awash with cash" (in the words of Mark
Thompson) does not spend real world cash. The needs of both channels 3,
4 and 5 plus 750,000 homes were ignored by the BBC decision.

Without Free To Air (or free at the point of access) for channels 3, 4,
and 5, Digital Satellite is thwated as a Public Service Platform for
all.

Plurality and multitude of independent sources is considered an
essential component of the UK's PSB ecology.

At least the BBC, in words, has today said it needs to correct this.


http://logofreetv.org/
http://newsmine.logofreetv.org/



--
Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Simon Gardner April 26th 04 10:04 PM

In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

"Simon Gardner" [dot]co[dot]uk wrote in message


In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.


In what sense do you claim "the BBC instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat?"



;-)

http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1760
http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1758

On 12/03/2003, when Greg Dyke announced the BBC would de-crypt, they did
so without consulting with ITV, Channel 4, and FIVE, and without
consideration for those channels' positions.

Consider, FIVE, who's programme budget of £185M is barely more than
just the BBC's marketing and advertising budget alone, and the scale of
the problem for FIVE, C4, and the smaller ITV companies (then) was
obvious.

The problem is cultural. The BBC "awash with cash" (in the words of Mark
Thompson) does not spend real world cash. The needs of both channels 3,
4 and 5 plus 750,000 homes were ignored by the BBC decision.

Without Free To Air (or free at the point of access) for channels 3, 4,
and 5, Digital Satellite is thwated as a Public Service Platform for
all.

Plurality and multitude of independent sources is considered an
essential component of the UK's PSB ecology.

At least the BBC, in words, has today said it needs to correct this.


No sorry. I don't see that stands up your allegation. The BBC's laudable
decision to go FTA did not mean it "instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat". C4, C5 and particularly ITV did that, the Government contributed
and OfCom topped and tailed. If it is a failure anywhere, it's a failure at
the utterly useless Department of Culture and its utterly useless Minister
- WHO ALREADY HAS THE POWERS TO RECTIFY THE MATTER AND HAS HAD SINCE THE
BEGINNING OF THE YEAR.



Simon Gardner April 26th 04 10:04 PM

In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

"Simon Gardner" [dot]co[dot]uk wrote in message


In article lgate.org,
"NO LOGO" wrote:

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.


In what sense do you claim "the BBC instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat?"



;-)

http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1760
http://logofreetv.org/redirect.asp?i=1758

On 12/03/2003, when Greg Dyke announced the BBC would de-crypt, they did
so without consulting with ITV, Channel 4, and FIVE, and without
consideration for those channels' positions.

Consider, FIVE, who's programme budget of £185M is barely more than
just the BBC's marketing and advertising budget alone, and the scale of
the problem for FIVE, C4, and the smaller ITV companies (then) was
obvious.

The problem is cultural. The BBC "awash with cash" (in the words of Mark
Thompson) does not spend real world cash. The needs of both channels 3,
4 and 5 plus 750,000 homes were ignored by the BBC decision.

Without Free To Air (or free at the point of access) for channels 3, 4,
and 5, Digital Satellite is thwated as a Public Service Platform for
all.

Plurality and multitude of independent sources is considered an
essential component of the UK's PSB ecology.

At least the BBC, in words, has today said it needs to correct this.


No sorry. I don't see that stands up your allegation. The BBC's laudable
decision to go FTA did not mean it "instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat". C4, C5 and particularly ITV did that, the Government contributed
and OfCom topped and tailed. If it is a failure anywhere, it's a failure at
the utterly useless Department of Culture and its utterly useless Minister
- WHO ALREADY HAS THE POWERS TO RECTIFY THE MATTER AND HAS HAD SINCE THE
BEGINNING OF THE YEAR.



Heracles Pollux April 26th 04 10:26 PM

No sorry. I don't see that stands up your allegation. The BBC's laudable
decision to go FTA did not mean it "instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat". C4, C5 and particularly ITV did that, the Government contributed
and OfCom topped and tailed. If it is a failure anywhere, it's a failure at
the utterly useless Department of Culture and its utterly useless Minister
- WHO ALREADY HAS THE POWERS TO RECTIFY THE MATTER AND HAS HAD SINCE THE
BEGINNING OF THE YEAR.



Well it is largely irrelevant what I think, so this is academic.

I would not ask the DCMS to help an old lady cross the road let alone
run a broadcasting system, so no disappointment there.

History does however record that Dyke's Free to Air Satellite revolt
appears to have been executed without discussing the matter with BSKYB,
ITV, C4, FIVE, not to mention the equipment suppliers, and that small
group of unimportant people; The UK citizens, general public, licence
fee payers, and viewers.

Whoops.



--
Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Heracles Pollux April 26th 04 10:26 PM

No sorry. I don't see that stands up your allegation. The BBC's laudable
decision to go FTA did not mean it "instigated the collapse of a multi PSB
Free Sat". C4, C5 and particularly ITV did that, the Government contributed
and OfCom topped and tailed. If it is a failure anywhere, it's a failure at
the utterly useless Department of Culture and its utterly useless Minister
- WHO ALREADY HAS THE POWERS TO RECTIFY THE MATTER AND HAS HAD SINCE THE
BEGINNING OF THE YEAR.



Well it is largely irrelevant what I think, so this is academic.

I would not ask the DCMS to help an old lady cross the road let alone
run a broadcasting system, so no disappointment there.

History does however record that Dyke's Free to Air Satellite revolt
appears to have been executed without discussing the matter with BSKYB,
ITV, C4, FIVE, not to mention the equipment suppliers, and that small
group of unimportant people; The UK citizens, general public, licence
fee payers, and viewers.

Whoops.



--
Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Jomtien April 27th 04 06:02 AM

NO LOGO wrote:

2. "On this, the Corporation welcomes the opportunity to work with other
organisations as quickly as possible to begin to make a non-subscription
digital satellite option a reality."

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.

This means that something major such as ITV, C4, and FIVE going Free To
Air will happen, or something major in resetting up SOLUS must happen.
May be now Dyke-head is gone, the BBC may even re-encrypt.


There is no earthly reason why the BBC or any other broadcaster should
have to pay Sky an arm and a leg to have FTV cards issued.
Sky must be obliged by law to provide these at cost (£5?) to anyone
who wants one and must also be made to charge a really fair price for
EPG placement and FTV encryption services. Current rates for both of
these are an absolute joke that makes Ofcom look like the toothless
NewsCorp lackey it is. Mind you, the same applies to Blair and cronies
in spades.

--
Digibox problem? : A reboot solves 90% of these.
The Sky Digital FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/yvnsy
How to get UK TV overseas: http://tinyurl.com/6p73
Fed up with logos / red buttons? : http://logofreetv.org/
BBC gone? : http://www.astra2d.co.uk/
----
Only the truth as I see it.
No monies return'd. ;-)

Jomtien April 27th 04 06:02 AM

NO LOGO wrote:

2. "On this, the Corporation welcomes the opportunity to work with other
organisations as quickly as possible to begin to make a non-subscription
digital satellite option a reality."

So the BBC who instigated the collapse of a multi PSB Free Sat have made
a statement of intent to reverse this problem. Good.

This means that something major such as ITV, C4, and FIVE going Free To
Air will happen, or something major in resetting up SOLUS must happen.
May be now Dyke-head is gone, the BBC may even re-encrypt.


There is no earthly reason why the BBC or any other broadcaster should
have to pay Sky an arm and a leg to have FTV cards issued.
Sky must be obliged by law to provide these at cost (£5?) to anyone
who wants one and must also be made to charge a really fair price for
EPG placement and FTV encryption services. Current rates for both of
these are an absolute joke that makes Ofcom look like the toothless
NewsCorp lackey it is. Mind you, the same applies to Blair and cronies
in spades.

--
Digibox problem? : A reboot solves 90% of these.
The Sky Digital FAQ: http://tinyurl.com/yvnsy
How to get UK TV overseas: http://tinyurl.com/6p73
Fed up with logos / red buttons? : http://logofreetv.org/
BBC gone? : http://www.astra2d.co.uk/
----
Only the truth as I see it.
No monies return'd. ;-)

Nigel Barker April 27th 04 10:00 AM

On Mon, 26 Apr 2004 11:58:56 +0000 (UTC), "NO LOGO" wrote:

5. "On the final stage of the journey towards a fully digital Britain we
want to see our services available to all licence fee payers as quickly
as possible and ensure that there are no pockets of people who are
digitally disenfranchised. "

Well with 50% yet to convert, and most of the conversion done by BSKYB
so far, this is not the final stage of the journey, more the beginning
of the hard slog.


How about they do a BBC FTA satellite receiver which gives all the currents
Freeview channels. There are precedents for BBC hardware e.g. BBC Micro
computer.

--
Nigel Barker
Live from the sunny Cote d'Azur

Nigel Barker April 27th 04 10:00 AM

On Mon, 26 Apr 2004 11:58:56 +0000 (UTC), "NO LOGO" wrote:

5. "On the final stage of the journey towards a fully digital Britain we
want to see our services available to all licence fee payers as quickly
as possible and ensure that there are no pockets of people who are
digitally disenfranchised. "

Well with 50% yet to convert, and most of the conversion done by BSKYB
so far, this is not the final stage of the journey, more the beginning
of the hard slog.


How about they do a BBC FTA satellite receiver which gives all the currents
Freeview channels. There are precedents for BBC hardware e.g. BBC Micro
computer.

--
Nigel Barker
Live from the sunny Cote d'Azur

Heracles Pollux April 27th 04 01:52 PM


Interesting post on http://forum.logofreetv.org/ by Mark G.

http://forum.logofreetv.org/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=979




--
Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Heracles Pollux April 27th 04 01:52 PM


Interesting post on http://forum.logofreetv.org/ by Mark G.

http://forum.logofreetv.org/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=979




--
Posted via Mailgate.ORG Server - http://www.Mailgate.ORG

Kathryn April 27th 04 08:14 PM


"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...
"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to
"add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


The box you have purchased will not be able to receive any of Top Up TV's
"add on" channels, regardless whether you have an outdoor aerial or not.

Top Up's pay channels require a card, only the older (and no longer made
or sold) OnDigital/ITV-Digital boxes have a card slot. Top Up claim
that new boxes will be on the market 'soon' with card slots, but for
you I guess it's too late.



I'll not cry I never get to watch the downstairs tv anyways and its purely
as I would consider getting myself one in the future if I thought there
would be something decent.

Kathryn



Kathryn April 27th 04 08:14 PM


"Mark Carver" wrote in message
...
"NO LOGO" wrote in message

my brother got my mum a freeview digibox for her birthday. We don't
have an
outsider aerial but the picture is great. I know that you can pay to
"add
on" at least E4 but can you get anything else added on and if so
would we
need an aerial then?

I hate technical stuff


The box you have purchased will not be able to receive any of Top Up TV's
"add on" channels, regardless whether you have an outdoor aerial or not.

Top Up's pay channels require a card, only the older (and no longer made
or sold) OnDigital/ITV-Digital boxes have a card slot. Top Up claim
that new boxes will be on the market 'soon' with card slots, but for
you I guess it's too late.



I'll not cry I never get to watch the downstairs tv anyways and its purely
as I would consider getting myself one in the future if I thought there
would be something decent.

Kathryn




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:27 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
HomeCinemaBanter.com